confirmation or any rules having been framed stating as to when an officer would be confirmed, his seniority would be counted from the date ... rule, his seniority has to be counted from the date of his appointment and not according to the date of his confirmation. The corollary
will not count for the purpose of seniority and for eligibility for promotion, confirmation etc.
(v) Other conditions of service will be governed ... that to enable seniority to be counted from the date of initial appointment and not according to the date of confirmation, the incumbent
rule, his seniority has to
be counted from the date of his appointment and not according to the
date of his confirmation. The corollary ... dispute as to whether the date of confirmation would be the measure
for determining inter se seniority.
In Union of India vs. S.S. Uppal
seniority. Accordingly, the Board acted illegally
and most arbitrarily in placing the juniors of the
appellant above him in the seniority list and/or
confirming ... that is, long after the date of
confirmation of the said respondents Nos.2 to 19.
The question of seniority has nothing to do with
rule, his seniority has to be counted from the date of
his appointment and not according to the date of his
confirmation.
The corollary ... date of first
substantive appointment, meaning thereby the date of
permanent appointment or the date of first
appointment on probation on a clear vacancy,
confirmation
entitled to get his seniority
reckoned from the date of his appointment and not from the date of his
confirmation. It is, however, also well ... that to enable seniority to
be counted from the date of initial appointment
and not according to the date of confirmation,
the incumbent
dated April 26, 2000 protects
the seniority and consequent promotion of persons who had
judgments in their favour from the Central Administrative Tribunal
duly confirmed ... eligibility list must be prepared
by determining the seniority on the basis of confirmation as Junior
Engineer. That list should form the basis for promotion
that seniority in one grade or
cadre would be dependent on the seniority in
another grade or cadre."
In State of Uttaranchal and Another ... mean to say that the seniority would be reckoned from the date of
confirmation but we only intend to point out that the Rules having
that seniority in one grade or cadre would be dependent on the seniority in another grade or cadre.
In State of Uttaranchal ... mean to say that the seniority would be reckoned from the date of confirmation but we only intend to point out that the Rules having
service and eligible for consideration to Junior Administrative Grade and their seniority was circulated which was the subject-matter of challenge by Sunil Misra before ... seniority should, if applicable to others, be applied to them also. In other words, if seniority is to depend purely upon the date of confirmation
