Page 6 of 106
details and her repeated dialogue on phones and SMS with Mr. Vijay Kataria
on his mobile phones establishes her constant, continuous ... other hand. There were 11 calls / SMS‟s
Crl. M.C. Nos. 2019, 3182 & 2022 of 2011 & Crl. R.P. 208/2012 Page
absence of eyewitness, the trial Court, based upon
weak circumstantial evidence, like SMS/Call Details (Ex.P.18), ought
not to have convicted the appellant ... such. They submit further that
the alleged SMS/Call Details (Ex.P.18) is not duly supported by the
certificate as required under Section
contended that the last seen theory as alleged is
not proved. The SMS as per Ex.P.66 is not proved and no
certificate ... Serial Nos.212 213 (Mobile
No.9916827817) of Ex.P66/SMS print out coupled with the oral and
documentary evidence on record clearly depict
Yadav, another employee of respondent School that the
petitioner had sent some SMS by computer through Vinay Kumar Yadav‟s
mobile to Smt. Bimla Devi ... requested to provide the
following documents:
i) Copies of the printouts of SMS taken from the
computer of Mrs. Harvinder Kaur.
ii) Voice recorded statements
drawn on Bank of
Maharashtra, Dwarka, Delhi.
07.05.09 The plaintiff received an SMS from the defendant
no.1, stating that he is liable ... Civil Suit No.140/10
:4:
19.05.09 The plaintiff received an SMS from the defendant
no.1, stating that he is liable
9873883039. On further
checking, it was found that the aforesaid SMS were sent to him from the
SIM No.9990401054 and the contents of those ... half an hour at
the red-light signal. Thereafter, he sent an SMS to the appellant asking
about his whereabout and at about
with each other
bo':-;h"by voice' @115 and SMS caiis.
0 1 "the'~case of prosecution that ... lacc.us.ed--. were in constant touch with each
N04 by sending SMS to accused No.1 was
inrgrinirg» their movements till accused
evidence relating to the details of the short
message service ("SMS" for short) Exs-P16a-P16h, Exs-P18a-
P18c and Exs-P19a ... examination to SP, Cyber Wing CID and obtained the details of
the SMS and two C.Ds., at Exs-P16 and P17 and on completing
Later
on 22.09.2015, the second daughter of PW.1 received the
5
SMS to her phone No.8495065602 from the mobile of Divya
stating that ... Chitra, the
second daughter of PW.1 received another SMS to her mobile
that Divya is going with her old friend and not to search
Sms Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs Union Of India on 1 March, 2019
Author: V. Ramasubramanian
Bench: V Ramasubramanian , Abhinand Kumar Shavili
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE
