Spanco Ltd vs Hartron Ltd & Anr on 19 January, 2016
Author: Amit Rawal
Bench: Amit Rawal ... Date of decision: January 19, 2016
M/s Spanco Limited
..... Appellant
Versus
Haryana State Electronics Development Corp. Ltd. and another
...... Respondents
CORAM
Online Micro Services Pvt. Ltd vs Spanco Bpo Services Limited on 14 December, 2016
IN THE COURT OF MS. POOJA TALWAR, ADDL. SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE ... registered office at:-
546, Chirag Delhi, New Delhi-110017.
....PLAINTIFF
Versus
Spanco BPO Services Limited
96/97, Neel Tower, Udyog Vihar, Phase-IV,
Gurgaon- (Haryana
2010
Page 5 of 20
· Datamatics Financial Services Limited
· Goldstone Infratech Limited
· Spanco Limited
4. Application of the Related Party Transaction (hereinafter referred ... Information Technologies Ltd
• Asit C Mehta Financial Services Ltd
• Goldstone Infratech Ltd
• Spanco Ltd
• Ace Software Exports Ltd
a) Companies eliminated erroneously citing inadequate information
1359/Bang/2011
22 Spanco Ltd (Seg) 25.81% 19.02%
23 Triton Corp Ltd 34.93% 27.05%
24 Vishal Information Technologies Ltd 51.19% 41.77%
25 Wipro ... under :
1. " The learned TPO erred on facts in selecting Spanco Limited as comparable in the order u/s
92CA without considering the differences
Informed Technologies Ltd.
iii. Mold-Tek Technologies Ltd - Seg iv. Spanco Ltd. - Seg
v. Vishal Information Technologies Ltd.
vi. Accurate Data Convertors
India Ltd., 3) M/s
Accentia Technologies Ltd., (Seg.), 4) M/s Spanco Ltd., (Seg.) & 5) M/s Asit C
Mehta Financial Services ... 1232(B)2011
Accentia Technologies Ltd., (Seg.) 4) M/s Spanco Ltd., (Seg.) and 5) M/s Asit
C Mehta Financial Services Ltd., We find
treating two
more companies as comparable, namely, CS Software Enterprises Ltd.
and Spanco Telesystems and Solutions Ltd. The Revenue is aggrieved
against the above alterations ... including two companies in
the list, namely, CS Software Enterprises Ltd. and Spanco Telesystems
and Solutions Ltd.
5.1. Before embarking upon the comparability or otherwise
Technologies Ltd. 106.82
13 R Systems International Ltd. (seg) 4.3
14 Spanco Telesystems and Solutions Ltd. 8.94
15 Triton Corp. Ltd. 23.5
Average
Technologies Ltd., Acropetal Technologies Ltd., Asit C Mehta
Financial Services Ltd. and Spanco Ltd. (all segmental) followed by M/s.
Coral Hubs Ltd. (formerly Vishal
Systems International Ltd. (Seg) 20.18
23 Spanco Ltd. (Seg) 25.81
24 Triton Corp Ltd. 34.93
25 Wipro Ltd. (Seg) 29.70
Average Margin 30.67
9. Subsequently
