vertical
(social) reservations will not apply to horizontal
(special) reservations. Where a special reservation for
women is provided within the social reservation ... treating the 20% reservation for women as a vertical
reservation, instead of a horizontal reservation within
the vertical reservation."
The Hon'ble Supreme
office from various sources." This indicates that there
is no special reservation or preferential treatment available to course-
completed Act Apprentices for engagement
found place at serial No.4 under
SC category with special reservation of MSP in the selection list vide
Notification No.36518/DSE/Estt
therefore, convenient to deal with them together. The percentage of reservation for SCs and STs in the case of direct requirement conducted on AH India ... percentages of reservation specified for SC/ST in recruitment on local/ regional basis have got a special significance. Under Article
disposed of."
14. The judgment dated 25.10.2021 passed in Special Leave Appeal (Civil)
No.27300/2019, wherein the aforesaid order/judgment dated ... prevalent for the time being, we
cannot fault the impugned judgment.
The special leave petition is, accordingly, dismissed."
15. Paras
open selection process against a single vacancy. No
reservation or any special consideration for persons with disability has
been highlighted by applicant in the deputation
doubt a prerequisite for
reservation in promotion for PWD. There cannot be
methodology used to defeat the reservation in promotion.
Once that post is identified ... absence of rules to provide for reservation
in promotion would not defeat the rights of PWD to a
reservation in promotion as it flows from
prepared without
following the reservation roster. Due to violation of this reservation policy, they
were excluded from the panel of IRSME ... given in its order
dated 17.05.2018 in SLP(C ) No. 30621/2011 and order dated 05.06.2018 in
Special Leave to Appeal (C ) No. 28306/2017
satisfying the conditions
mentioned in DOPT OM dt 4.1.2013 by ensuring the reservation rosters
which are strictly maintained as per the instructions/guidelines issued ... SLP
No.30621/2011.
17 = It is to be noted that again petitions were filed against the interim
order passed in SLP No30621/2011
belonging to the MBC quota, who would have been selected irrespective
of reservation, were not considered against general vacancies. Instead,
9 OA/310/01190/2016 ... petition. Challenging the said decision , the State of Tamil Nadu
preferred a Special Leave Petition before the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
The relevant portion
