period
of one year which is not commensurate with alleged supervisory
failure of the applicant. Learned counsel for the respondents
clarified that, CCS (CCA) Rules
minor penalty charge sheet had
been imposed on the applicant for the failure of the applicant to exercise
proper, timely and effective administrative control ... contends that the Whistle Blower Protection Act
will not lie for failure of supervisory action but then Annexure-A2 seems,
on a plain reading, coming
positive case of the petitioners that due
to failure in supervisory duty of the opposite party another employee
misappropriated the Government money and subsequently
positive case of the petitioners that due
to failure in supervisory duty of the opposite party another employee
misappropriated the Government money and subsequently
allegation of lack of supervision in his duty leading to failure to maintain
absolute integrity and devotion to duty as required under Rule ... Rules, 1964. The substance of the allegation is that for the failure of
supervisory duty by the applicant, one Shri Dilip Kumar Dash
failure of
justice.
Page 11 of 36
Downloaded on : Sat Oct 19 01:47:19 IST 2019
C/SCA/11769/2019 JUDGMENT
(4) Supervisory jurisdiction ... step in to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction.
(5) Be it a writ of certiorari or the exercise of supervisory
jurisdiction, none is available to correct
justice where there is no procedure specified,
and thereby occasioning failure of justice.
(4) Supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution is exercised ... failure of justice or grave injustice has
occasioned thereby, the High Court may step
in to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction.
Patna High Court
others (2003) 6 SCC 675, it was held that in exercise of supervisory power under Article 227 , High Court can correct errors of jurisdiction committed ... permitted by law and failure of justice or grave injustice has occasioned, the Court may step in to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction. However, it also
others (2003) 6 SCC 675, it was held that in exercise of supervisory power under Article 227 , High Court can correct errors of jurisdiction committed ... permitted by law and failure of justice or grave injustice has occasioned, the Court may step in to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction. However, it also
failure of justice.
Page 12 of 36
Downloaded on : Sun Jun 30 16:24:28 IST 2019
C/SCA/4668/2016 JUDGMENT
(4) Supervisory jurisdiction ... step in
to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction.
(5) Be it a writ of certiorari or the exercise of supervisory
jurisdiction, none is available to correct
