about 2.48% on a
turnover of about Rs. 18 crore and in the relevant year the turnover has
decreased to about Rs. 7.5 crores
Ward 4(2), Jaipur vs. Bharat Metal Fabricators.
turnover has decreased as compare to the previous year, he restricted the
disallowance out of labour expenses ... looked at the labour cost as a percentage of turnover
which has declined from 11.18% to 6.06% during the year under consideration
and has restricted
price. Moreover with
respect to 43.27% of the turnover, no reasons have been
given for decrease in GP rate as compared to last year ... turnover. For
the balance part of the turnover where reasons have been
given, it is not possible to quantify the decrease in gross
profit
rate of 6.76% on turnover of Rs 114,52,126 which is better than G.P rate of
6.06% on turnover ... trend which is emerging is that though the turnover of the
appellant has decreased during the year, it is able to report
estimation of turnover and income thereon. We find
that the Assessing Officer has estimated a net profit @ 1% on the estimated
turnover on 1.5 crore ... nature and will not vary with the
increase or decrease of the turnover and therefore gross profit rate inspite of
net profit rate should have
actions. We find that the ld CITA had
categorically stated that the turnover and the direct expenses incurred by the assessee
8 ITA No.2318 ... consumption to the percentage of turnover had increased by 34.95% and direct
expenses had decreased by 0.89% in the year ended 31.3.2009 when compared
ACIT
change which not only resulted in decrease in the turnover by 15% but
also resulted into shrinking of the margins. Therefore, he prayed
estimated the profit @ 11.5% on the turnover of Rs.
16.84 crore. The Hon'ble Bench has also considered its
order ... Assessee has claimed that with
the increase of turnover, profit rate is decreased. For
5 ITA 54 & 164/JP/2013_
Choudhary & Brothers
further
argued that the sales turnover had increased by 14.18% but the
manufacturing sales had in fact decreased by 4.94% as the appellant had
begun
turnover of Rs. 15,31,53,579/- which is an extremely large
percentage.
(iii) No reasons have been given for decrease in freight
receipts this