obtains more votes than the aggregate votes obtained by the other candidates, the candidate who has obtained the smallest number of votes shall be excluded ... voting is done by ballot or by voice vote. It cannot be assumed that voting by voice vote was not free and Members voted
motion of thanks to the Governor, which was carried by voice vote and the House rose for the day." The statement, as It will ... Speaker put the question and the closure motion was carried by voice vote. The amendment to the Motion of thanks was moved by the Opposition
House and it was put to vote and through voice vote, the resolution was passed, under which, the appellants were suspended for a period ... from one year to six months and it was put to voice vote and by a majority vote, the resolution for modification of the punishment
Money Bill, the Speaker had illegally passed it through a
false voice vote. Such an act cannot be treated as having
voluntarily given up their ... been stated that the
Appropriation Bill was passed by a voice vote on 18.03.2016. In
para 86, it has been stated that the joint memorandum
last time, the Motion was being put to vote. A voice vote was taken and division was going to be taken. At that time could ... order on merit? The Motion was already put to vote and voice vote was taken. … (Interruptions)
SHRI G.M. BANATWALLA : A point of order could
Deputy Speaker declared that the motion was carried with a voice vote. Thereafter the business of the House was conducted in accordance with the mandate ... that he was anxious to speak on it. Ultimately, by a voice vote, the majority resolved to accept the mover's resolution. Even otherwise
motion which was put to vote. It was carried by a voice vote. After it was carried by a voice vote, the Deputy Leader ... members of the House, a resolution was passed by a voice vote.
8. In response, Mr.Guru Krishna Kumar, learned Additional Advocate General appearing
MALLIKARJUN KHARGE ( GULBARGA ): They have not voted. There was no voting at all. The budget was passed by voice vote.
SHRI ARUN JAITLEY : Voice vote ... vote. That is prima facie; it has no proof. In a voice vote, who knows whose voice is the loudest? Two people may shout louder
whether the decision of the House would be taken by a voice vote or not. Since it has been challenged, it has to be decided ... whether it should be done by a voice vote or by a division. That is the only question. We do not have to decide about
voting on such an important thing to sideline the rules. You are voting to sideline the rules.
SHRI BASU DEB ACHARIA : Instead of voice vote ... BASU DEB ACHARIA : Now, why is voting required Mr. Bansal? There are two types of voting. One is voice vote and another is Division… (Interruptions
