Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Iqbal Hasan vs Union Of India on 21 February, 2014
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No.1809/2013
M.A. No.1442/2013
Order reserved on:20.02.2014
Pronounced on:21:02.2014
Honble Shri G.George Paracken, Member (J)
Honble Shri Uday Kumar Varma, Member(A)
1. Iqbal Hasan
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Mahboob Hasan
r/o DII/47,
West Kidwai Nagar,
New Delhi-110023
Posted at:
NIC H.Q.,
CGO Complex
New Delhi.
2. Sumpan Bakshi
Scientist-C
s/o Dr.M.M.Bakshi
r/o 169/18, Friends Colony,
Gurgaon.
Posted at:
NIC Delhi State Centre,
Delhi Secretariat
New Delhi.
3. Sanjay Kumar Joshi
Scientist-C
s/o Late Sh.Triloki Nath Joshi
r/o House number 1561, Sector-31,
Housing Board Colony,
Gurgaon.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
4. Urmila Jain
Scientist-G(Retd)
d/o Late. Sh.B.D.Garg,
r/o B-173, SFS, Sheikh Sarai-I
New Delhi-110017
5. Pradip Kumar
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Ramji Sah
r/o F-24, Room no-A-21
IV Floor, Katwaria Sarai
New Delhi-110016
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
6. Sudhir Chandra
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Mahesh Chandra
r/o 402, Naveen Kunj society
Plot number 22, Pocket-6
Nasirpur, Dwaraka
New Delhi-110045.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
7. Jai Prakash Gupta,
Scientist-D,
s/o Sh. Late Sh.S.D.Gupta,
r/o House number 1060, Sector-28,
Faridabad (Haryana)-121008.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
8. Tarun Kumar,
Scientist-E,
s/o Sh.Ramesh Chand Gupta,
r/o House number 1/7331, Mandir Marg,
East Gorakh Park,
Shahdara
Delhi-110032
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
9. Anil Kumar,
Scientist-C,
s/o Late Sh.Amar Dev,
r/o H-239, Street number-8,
Raj Nagar-II,
Palam Colony,
New Delhi-110077
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
10. Dr.Mahesh Chandra
Scientist-G,
s/o Sh.Yad Ram,
r/o 66 B, Pocket-IV,
Mayur Vihar,Phase-I,
New Delhi-110091
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
11. Deepak Chandra Misra
Scientist-G,
s/o Sh.G.D.Mishra
r/o D-II/126,
Kidwai Nagar(West),
New Delhi-110023
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
12. Nagendra Kumar
Scientist-D,
s/o Sh.Bhagwan Sharan Pachauri
r/o 337, Laxmi Bai Nagar,
New Delhi-110023
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex New Delhi.
13. Shilpi Jain
Scientist-D,
d/o Sh.B.S.Jain
r/o 2-D OCS Apartments,
Mayur Vihar,Phase I Ext,
New Delhi-110091
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
14. Dibyojit Dutta
Scientist-E,
s/o Late Sh.B D Dutta
r/o QTr No 1219,
Central Govt,
Housing Complex,Sector-12,
R K Puram
New Delhi-22
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
15. Nidhi Pahwa
Scientist-D,
d/o Sh.V.P.Mehta
r/o 28 Vinoba Puri,
Lajpat Nagar-II,
New Delhi-24
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
16. Anil Kumar
Scientist-E,
s/o Sh. Brij Mohan Garg
r/o House No.963, Type V,
Kamla Nehru Nagar,
Ghaziabad
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
17. Rajesh Kumar Jain
Scientist-D,
s/o Late Sh.P.K.Jain
r/o A-202,Garden Apartments, Sector-4,
Vaishali, Ghaziabad-201010
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
18. Rajesh Kumar Tripathi
Scientist-D,
s/o Sh.Sarvajit Prasad Tripathi
r/o 17A/712,
Vasundhara, Ghaziabad, U.P.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
19. S.Shobhana
Scientist-D,
d/o Sh.V.Subramaniam
r/o 11A/13, West Extension Area,
Karol Bagh,
New Delhi-110005
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
20. Vaishno Kumar Bali
Scientist-G,
s/o Sh.Kasturi Lal Bali
r/o V-28, Block 4, Type 5,
Lodhi Road Complex,
New Delhi -3
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
21. Rajdeep Choudhury
Scientist-D,
s/o Sh.Ratish Choudhury
r/o A-15, Andrews Ganj Extension,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
22. Dr.Pramod Sharma
Scientist-D,
s/o Sh.Mohan Swarup Sharma
r/o 3/187, Sector-2,
Rajinder Nagar,Sahibabad,
Ghaziabad (U.P.)-201005.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
23. Rekha Gupta
Scientist-E,
d/o Sh.M.L.Gupta
r/o F-47, DDA Flats,
Sheikh Sarai, Phase-1,
New Delhi-110017.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
24. Putrevu Kondala Rao
Scientist-E,
s/o Sh.P.Venkata Rao
r/o Quarter No.1106,Sector-4,
R.K.Puram,
New Delhi-22.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
25. Vinay Thakur
Scientist-F,
s/o Sh.P.C.Dogra
r/o D-4, Type-5,
Hudco Place, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
26. Sumeet Jethra
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.B.D.Jethra
r/o DB-201, Block 3B,
Transit Flats, Hudco Place,
Andrews Ganj, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
27. Ragyi Singh Yadav
Scientist-D
d/o Sh. Torhi Singh
r/o 42 B IInd Floor,
Indraprastha Colony,
Sector-33, Faridabad.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
28. Dr.Ambreesh Kumar
Scientist-G
s/o Sh.O.P.Agarwal
r/o 18/506G, Royal Legacy,
Vasundhara,
Ghaziabad-201012.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
29. Ranjeet Kumar
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Kesho Prasad
r/o C-13 Andrews Ganj Extension,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
30. H.Madhava Reddy
Scientist-G
s/o Late Sh. H.Muthyal Reddy
r/o B-46, Tarang Apartments,
19, I.P. Extn., New Delhi-110092.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
31. Vineet Tomar
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Vijay Pal
r/o A-2,Tata Steel Officers Enclave,
Opp.Kasna Police Station,
Sec Beta II,Greater Noida
U.P.-201308.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
32. Sangadi Madhu
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Sangadi Satyanarayana
r/o 381, DDA Flats, Sector-19,
Pkt.3, Dwarka,
Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
33. Paul Arokianathan S.
Scientist-D
s/o Late Sh.F.Stanislaus
r/o No.13, Tekchand House,
249-A,Nelson Mandela Marg,
OPP. V.V.Bus Depot, Munirka,
New Delhi-110067.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
34. Kanthaswamy.U
Scientist-D
s/o Late Mr.K.Ulaganathan
r/o 501,Tagore Road Hostel,
Minto Road Complex,
New Delhi-2.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
35. Vipin Kumar Sharma
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Devendra Sharma
r/o House No.-374,Sector-11,
Vasundhara,
Ghaziabad.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
36. Gautom Khanikar
Scientist-E
s/o Lt.L.Khanikar
r/o Sheikh Sarai,
Ph-1,Flat No.F-95,
Delhi-17.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
37. Sanjay Kumar Sinha
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.G.K.Sinha
r/o 57, Asiad Village,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
38. Jagjit Singh
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.SulakhanSingh
r/o Q.No.-417, Block-F,
P.V.Hostel, Lodhi Road
New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
39. Ashok Kumar
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.K.P.Sao
r/o Qr.No.-321, Type-IV,
Laxmi Bai Nagar,
New Delhi-23.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
40. Rajesh Bahadur
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Prakash Chander Vidyant
r/o C-102,1st Floor,
Golf Links, Sector-40
Noida-201301.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
41. H.P.Sharma
Scientist-G
s/o Sh.B.G.Sharma
r/o A-28,HUDCO Place,
Andrews Ganj
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
42. Guntuku Prasad
Scientist-F
s/o G Ramamurthy
r/o C-61/X3, Dilshad Garden,
Delhi-110095.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
43. Gautam Ghosh
Scientist-G
s/o M.S.Ghosh
r/o U-3, Hudco Place,
Andrews Ganj
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
44. K.S.Nagesh
Scientist-F
s/o K.S.Satyanarayana
r/o T-16, Hudco Place
Andrews Ganj,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
45. Prateek Kumar Saha
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.Kalidas Saha
r/o 313, Laxmibai Nagar,
New Delhi-110023.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
46. Himadari Shekher Samaddar
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.Phani Bhusan Samaddar
r/o Flat No. L -2, Andrews Ganj Extension,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
47. C.J.Antony
Scientist-F
s/o C.U.John
r/o 162-C, Pocket-C,
Mayur Vihar, Phase-2
Delhi-110091.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
48. S.Getzibai Mirandah Ebenezer
Scientist-C
d/o Sh.A Samuel
r/o 26-B, DDA Flats,
Sector-7, Pocket-2,
Dwarka, New Delhi-75.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
49. Neelam Kaul
Scientist-D
d/o Sh.M.K.Kaul
r/o A-302, Sarojini Nagar,
New Delhi-110023.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
50. Thokchom Ibomcha Singh
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Thokchom Bidhu Singh
r/o 203/5, Sector-1,
Pushp Vihar,
New Delhi-110017.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
51. Sunil Kumar
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Rajender Prasad
r/o H.No.11, Village Paprawat
Najafgarh,
New Delhi-110043.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
52. Mohammad Saleemuddin Khan
Scientist-D
s/o Late Sh.Rafiuddin Khan
r/o D-506, Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road
New Delhi-3
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
53. Janmejay Thakur
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Dinesh Kumar Thakur
r/o C-603, M.S.Apartments,
Kasturba Gandhi Marg,
New Delhi-110001
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
54. Anshul Kumar Aggarwal
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.R.L.Aggarwal
r/o DII Flats, Flat No.-51,
Road No.1, Andrews Ganj,
Delhi-110049
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
55. Ajay Kumar Chhakara
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Gianender Singh Chhakara
r/o BU-219, Vishakha Enclave,
Pitampura,
Delhi-110034
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
56. Anuj Mahajan
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Jagdish Chand
r/o B-40-C, Gangotari Enclave,
Alaknanda,
New Delhi-110019
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
57. Nagaraj Kulkarni
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Virupakshayya
r/o 57, Pocket-5, Phase-1
Mayur Vihar,
Delhi-110091
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
58. Chandra Mohan Panda
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Raghunath Panda
r/o Pearl-803, Gardenia Glamour,
Sector-3, Vasundhara,
Ghaziabad-201012
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
59. Pradeep Kumar Gupta
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Ishwar Dayal Gupta
r/o KC 68/4, Kavi Nagar,
Ghaziabad-201002(U.P.)
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
60. Sree Ramakrishna Y
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Y.Deshpande
r/o Flat No.127, Amarpali Apartment,
56 I P Extension,
Patpar Ganj,
Delhi-110092
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
61. Brijesh Krishna Sharma
Scientist-D
s/o Late Sh. Bal Krishna Sharma
r/o Flat No.S-30,Pearl Apartments,
Ramprastha Greens,
Vaishali, Sector-9,
Ghaziabad-201010(U.P.)
Posted at:
NIC H.Q.,
Labour Informatics Division
New Delhi.
62. Sanjay Kumar
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.S.N.Pandit
r/o B-305, Shivkala Apartment,
Plot B-9/11, Sector-62,
Noida
Posted at:
NIC H.Q.,
Labour Informatics Division
New Delhi.
63. Pradeep Kumar Jain
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Ram Pal Jain
r/o Flat No.-103, C/82-83
Nishant Lok,
Shalimar Garden, Extn.-II,
Sahibabad-201005,
Ghaziabad
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
64. Radha Krishna K
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.K.V.Surya Narayana
r/o Block-4B, DB-101,
Transit Flats,
HUDCO Place,
Andrews Ganj, New Delhi-110049
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
65. Apurba Kumar Sen
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.M.K.Sen
r/o Flat No. B-5, H-3/94,
Bengali Colony ,
Mahavir Enclave-I,
New Delhi-110045
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
66. Avnesh Kumar Sharma
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Anand Swaroop Sharma
r/o C-006, P V Hostel
Lodhi Road, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
67. Ranju Malhotra
Scientist-D
d/o Shri Hans Raj Arora
r/o E1/9/12, Sector 15,
Rohini, Delhi-110089.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
68. Rajiv Goel
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Mahesh Kumar Goel
r/o D-49/7 Dilshad Colony,
Delhi-110095.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
69. Avijit Dutta
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Ajit Kumar Dutta
r/o 11/1, Semal Road,
Shipra Suncity,
Indra Puram, Ghaziabad.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
70. Jimutbahan De
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Amal Kumar De
r/o C-2, Andrews Ganj Extension,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
71. Inder Pal Singh Sethi
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.Gurnam Singh Sethi
r/o B-80, Pocket-II,
Kendriya Vihar,
Sector-82,
Noida(U.P.)-201304
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
72. Ramesh Chandra
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Bhagwan Singh
r/o House No.208,
H-Block, Sector-23,
Sanjay Nagar,
Ghaziabad, U.P.-201002
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
73. B V Chalapathi Rao
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.B.Raghava Rao
r/o A-505, M S Apartments,
K G Marg,
New Delhi-1
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
74. Rajender Sethi
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.B.L.Sethi
r/o House No.594,
Sector-7, Urban Estate,
Gurgaon,
Haryana-122001
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
75. Anil Kumar Singh
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Phool Kumar Singh
r/o C-303,Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road,
New Delhi-110003
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
76. Ashok Kumar Jain
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.J.P.Jain
r/o D-II/59, Road No.1,
Andrews Ganj,
New Delhi-110049
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
77. Dr.V.S.Rana
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Amar Singh Rana
r/o B-10,
Andrews Ganj Extension,
New Delhi-110049
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
78. Sharmistha Das Gupta
Scientist-F
d/o Late Dr.Phani Bushan De Choudhary
r/o M-23, Sec-XI,
Noida-201301, U.P.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
79. Praveen Chandra Dhar
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.K.C.Dhar
r/o 467, Sector-3,
Pocket-16,
Dwarka, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
80. Raghavendra
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.V.V.Vinod
r/o 8/7,New Minto Road Hostel, Block-1
New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
81. Vijay Kumar Chutani
Scientist-C
s/o Sh.Ved Prakash Chutani
r/o H.No. 1/19,
Shivaji Nagar,
Gurgaon, Haryana.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
82. Sanjay Kumar Chauhan
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Atma Ram Chauhan
r/o H.No.-359, Type-4,
R K Puram, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
83. Alka Mishra
Scientist-F
d/o Sh.Vivekanand Jha
r/o O-52, Nivedita Kunj
R K Puram, Sector-10,
New Delhi-110022.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
84. Pramod Kumar
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Bhom Raj Singh
r/o G-46, Type-5B,
HUDCO Place,
Andrews Ganj, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
85. Virendra Pasricha
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.S.P.Pasricha
r/o B-89, Kendriya Vihar,
Sector-51,
Noida(UP)-201307
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
86. Padmavathi Viswanathan
Scientist-G
d/o Late Sh.Venkita Subramani Iyer
r/o F-3, Type-5B,
D-1 Flats
HUDCO Place,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
87. Naresh Kumar Sharma
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Bishamber Dutta Sharma
r/o B-404,
M S Apartment,
K G Marg,
New Delhi-110001.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
88. Dr. Mrs.Ranjana Nagpal
Scientist-G
d/o Sh.D.D.Kalra
r/o P-2,Hauz Khas Enclave,
New Delhi-110016.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
89. S.Sundaram
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.S.Sivarajulu
r/o Quarter No.584,
R K Puram,New Delhi-110022.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
90. Sanjay Garg
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Suresh Chander
r/o D-29, Arya Nagar Apartment,
Patparganj, Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi-110003.
91. Joydeep Shome
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.M.L.Shome
r/o A2/803,
Krishna Apra Gardens,
Indrapuram,
Ghaziabad-201014 U.P.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi-110003.
92. V Hanumantha Rao
Scientist-D
s/o Late Sh.V Ramachandra Rao
r/o Plot No.6, Flat No. B-13,
Informatics Apartments,
Sector Pi-1,
Greater Noida-201306.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
93. Rajiv Prakash Saxena
Scientist-G
s/o Sh.S.P.Saxena
r/o DII/181,
Kidwai Nagar West,
New Delhi-110023
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
94. Sanjeev Mathur
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Tej Bahadur Mathur
r/o F-018, Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road,
New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
95. Deepak Mehra
Scientist-E
s/o Sh.Jog Raj Mehra
r/o C-44, Anand Vihar,
Delhi-92.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
96. Sanjay Mendiratta
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.R.S.Mendiratta
r/o H-502,
Aditya Mega City,
Vaibhav Khand,
Indirapuram, Ghaziabad
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
97. Rajinder Kumar Kaul
Scientist-E
s/o Mohan Lal Kaul
r/o 6/169,
Chiranjiv Vihar, Ghaziabad
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
98. Rama Hariharan
Scientist-F
d/o N.H.Narayana Swamy
r/o 9C, Shivalik Apartments,
Plot No.32, Sector-6,
Dwarka, New Delhi.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
99. Manie Khaneja
Scientist-E
d/o B.L.Khurana
r/o B-129/1,
Derawal Nagar,
New Delhi-110009.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
100. Rajesh Kumar Pathak
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.M.P.Sharma
r/o B-601,
M.S.Apartment, K G Marg,
New Delhi-110001
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
101. Neeta Verma
Scientist-G
d/o Late Sh.N.L.Malik
r/o E-18, Hudco Place,
Andrews Ganj,
New Delhi-110049
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
102. Anil Kumar Mittal
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.G.C.Mittal
r/o Delhi Govt. Officers Flats,
DA/12-B,
Hari Nagar,
New Delhi-110064
Posted at:
N.I.C. Delhi State Centre
Delhi Secretariat.
103. Deepak Kumar
Scientist-C
s/o Late Sh.Kishori Lal
r/o House No.-3719,
Gali No.8,
Narang Colony, Trinagar,
Delhi-110035
Posted at:
N.I.C. Delhi State Centre
Chief Minister Office.
104. Sandeep Jain
Scientist-C
s/o Sh.R.K.Jain
r/o B-29,
Overseas Apartment,
Sector-9, Rohini-85
Posted at:
N.I.C. Delhi State Centre
Deputy Commissioner(West)
105. Brijesh Kumar Khandelwal
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.R.P.Khandelwal
r/o E-2/5/15,
Sector-15, Rohini,
Delhi-110089.
Posted at:
N.I.C. Delhi State Centre
Chief Minister Office.
106. R S Mani
Scientist-F
s/o Sh. K Ramachandran
r/o G-17 , Type 5
HUDCO Place,
New Delhi-49
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
107. Seema Khanna
Scientist-E
d/o Col KG Khanna
r/o , C-2/1 Aditi Apartment
D Block, Janak Puri
New Delhi -110058
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
108. Arpita Barman
Scientist-E
d/o Sh.Anil Ranjan Bairagi
r/o , Z-10, HUCO Place,
Andrewsganj
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
109. Durga Prasad Misra
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.Bata Krishna Misra
r/o , D-202, Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road,
New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
110. Vikas Agrawal
Scientist-D
s/o Sh.S.C.Agrawal
r/o , W-8A, Green Park Main,
New Delhi-110016.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
111. Girish Kumar Gaur
Scientist-F
s/o Sh. Shiv Nandan Gaur
r/o D-6, M.S Apartments,
Pandara Park,
New Delhi-110003
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
112. V. Udaya Kumar
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Narasinga Rao
r/o D-013, Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road,
New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
113. Siba Charan Pradhan
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Mohani Charan Pradhan
r/o D-313, Pragati Vihar Hostel,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
114. Vishnu Chandra
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.H.C.Mathur
r/o N-53, Type-5B, Nivedita Kunj,
Sector-10, R.K.Puram,
New Delhi-110022.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
115. Ramesh Singh
Scientist-F
s/o Sh.Kripa Shankar Singh
r/o U-41, HUDCO Place,
Andrews Ganj,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
116. Shiv Kumar
Scientist-E
s/o Sh. Ghanshyam Das Gupta
r/o G-9, Type-4/Spl., 2nd Floor,
Andrews Ganj,
New Delhi-110049.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
117. Chander Shekhar
Scientist-F
s/o Sh. Prem Paul
r/o C-301, M.S. Apartments,
K.G.Marg,
New Delhi-110001.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
118. Mala Mittal
Scientist-F
d/o Sh. P.K.Dhingra
r/o C-57, Vivek Vihar,
New Delhi-110095.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
119. Shalini Mathrani
Scientist-F
d/o Sh. R.M.Mathrani
r/o 9, Kautilya Marg,
New Delhi-110021.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
120. Pawan Kumar Joshi
Scientist-F
s/o Sh. Mahabir Prasad Joshi
r/o Flat no. -15, Nilgiri Apartments,
Alaknanda,
New Delhi-110019.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
121. Rahul Kumar Jain
Scientist-C
s/o Late Sh. Mohini Lal Jain
r/o 66, New Gandhi Nagar,
Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
122. A.K.Chanana
Scientist-F
s/o Late Sh.D.R.Chanana
r/o 11/789, Lodhi Colony,
New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
123. Naeem Ahmed
Scientist-E
s/o Late Sh. Alhaj Ameer Ahmed
r/o B-608, M.S.Apartments,
K.G.Marg,
New Delhi-110001.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
124. Ravi Vijayvargiya
Scientist-F
s/o Sh. R.P. Vijayvargiya
r/o N-1-2, M.S. Flats, Sector-13,
R.K.Puram,
New Delhi-110066.
Posted at:
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
125. Ms. Ratnaboli Ghorai Dinda
Scientist-F
d/o Late Dr.B.K.Ghorai
r/o E-67 Ansari Nagar East,
New Delhi-110029.
Posted at:
Cyber Security Division,
NIC H.Q.,
CGO Complex
New Delhi.
126. Ms. Rama Nangpal
Scientist-G
d/o Sh. Ish Kumar
r/o B-3/50 B, Lawrence Road,
New Delhi-110035.
Posted at:
TDPP Division,
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex
New Delhi.
127. Ms. Anjana Choudhary
Scientist-G
d/o Late Sh. A.N.Dhingra
r/o C-II/72, Bapa Nagar,
New Delhi-110003.
Posted at:
Cyber Security Division,
NIC H.Q.,
CGO Complex New Delhi.
128. K.B.Hariharan
Scientist-d
s/o Late Sh. K.K.Balagangadharan
r/o 203, Pocket-D-6, Sector-6,Rohini
New Delhi-110085.
Posted at:
Cyber Security Division,
NIC H.Q.,
CGO Complex New Delhi.
129. Anil Rathore
Scientist-D,
S/o Shri B.L. Rathore
13-D, Pkt-A, Siddharth Ext.
New Delhi 110014
Posted at:
IDC, DCWSD
NIC H.Q., CGO Complex,
New Delhi. Applicants
By Advocate: Shri R.K. Kapoor with Ms. Neelam Sharma.
Versus
1. Union of India, through the Secretary,
Department of Electronics and Information,
Technology (DietY),
Ministry of Communications &
Information Technology,
Government of India,
Electronics Niketan,
6, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi.
2. The Director General,
National Informatics Centre,
Department of Electronics and Information
Techonology,
Government of India,
A-Block, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi.
3. The Secretary,
Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances & Pensions
(Department of Personnel & Training),
Government of India,
New Delhi. ..Respondents
By Advocate: Shri Rajinder Nischal.
ORDER
By Shri G. George Paracken:
Applicants have filed this Original Application seeking the following main reliefs:-
(a) Direct the Respondents to consider and grant the benefit of FCS to the Applicants, with all consequential benefits in the subsequent grades as well, and to suitably modify the dates of in situ promotions by antedating the same from the dates when the eligibility period was completed by the respective Applicants in the respective grades as per the details of the Applicants regarding their dates of eligibility to the various Grade, actual date of in situ promotion to the said Grade and the dates w.e.f. it should have been granted, as mentioned in the CHART annexed as Annexure A-6 with the OA;
(b) Direct the Respondents to consider and grant the benefit of FCS to the Applicants, with all consequential benefits in the subsequent grades as well, and to suitably modify the date of in situ promotions by antedating the same from the dates when the eligibility period was completed by the respective Applicants in the light of the orders of Honble Supreme Court dated 02.05.2011 as passed in SLP (Civil) No.6864/2011 titled as U.O.I. Vs. S.K. Murti in view of the provisions of Articles 141 and 144 of the Constitution of India, and the clarifications given by the Ministry of Law; and (c ) Direct the Respondents to maintain uniformity in application of minimum residency period in all the grades.
2. According to the learned counsel for the Applicants, the case of the Applicants is squarely covered by the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No.13133/2011 - Union of India Vs. S.K. Murti decided on 02.05.2011. The operative part of the said order reads as under:-
This petition is directed against order dated 5.10.2010 passed by the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court whereby the writ petition filed by the respondent against the order passed by the Principal Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal (for short, `the Tribunal') dismissing the original application filed by him for issue of a direction to the petitioners herein to promote him under the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS) with effect from the date of eligibility was allowed.
We have heard Smt. Indira Sawhney, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. Jitendra Mohan Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent, who has entered on caveat and carefully perused the record.
The respondent, who was working as Scientist Grade-D in the Botanical Survey of India became eligible for promotion under FCS with effect from 1.1.1999. However, on account of delayed convening of the Departmental Review Committee/Selection Committee, his promotion was delayed and by an order dated 20.10.2000, he was promoted with effect from 19.9.2000.
The respondent and 10 other Scientists of Botanical Survey of India filed Original Application No. 826/203 for directing the petitioners to promote them with effect from the date of eligibility, i.e. 1.1.1999. The Tribunal dismissed the original application and held that in view of the clarification given in O.M. Dated 10.11.1998, the applicants were not entitled to promotion with retrospective effect. The review petition filed by the respondent was dismissed by the Tribunal vide order dated 14.1.2004. However, Writ Petition (C) No.14263/2004 filed by the respondent was allowed by the Division Bench of the High Court and the petitioners were directed to give him all the benefits on the basis of deemed promotion with effect from 1.1.1999.
In our view, reasons assigned by the High Court for directing the petitioners to promote the respondent with effect from the date of acquiring the eligibility are legally correct and the impugned order does not suffer from any legal error warranting interference under Article 136 of the Constitution.
It is not in dispute that vacancies existed when the Departmental Review Committee considered the case of the respondent and other similarly situated persons for promotion. It is also not in dispute that in terms of paragraph 51.25 of the Vth Pay Commission Recommendations, the Departmental Review Committee/Assessment Board was required to meet every six months, i.e. in January and July and the promotions were to be made effective from the date of eligibility. Therefore, it is not possible to find any flaw in the direction given by the High Court.
The special leave petition is accordingly dismissed.
Since the time fixed by the High Court for compliance of the direction given by it has already expired, we direct the petitioners to do the needful within four weeks from today. Similar order shall be passed for all similarly situated persons despite the fact that they may not have approached the High Court questioning the order passed by the Tribunal. This direction is being given to avoid further litigation in the matter.
3. The learned counsel for the Applicants has also submitted that this Tribunal following the dictum in the aforesaid judgment of the Supreme Court allowed OA No. 1111/2012 Shri Vinay Kumar Vs. The Secretary, Department of Electronics & Information Technology and Others decided on 27.09.2013. The operative part of the said order reads as under:-
2. Facts of the case are that applicant has been working with the respondents and was promoted as Scientist-C under the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCE) on 01.01.1999. He became due for promotion as Scientist-D on 01.01.2003 and thereafter the Scientist-E on 01.01.2007. However, the respondents have promoted him not from the due date but from a date much after the same. The applicant is seeking ante dating of his promotion to Scientist-D as well as Scientist-E. He has sought this relief, mainly, on the ground that Honble Supreme Court in the matter of UOI & Anr. Vs. S.K. Murti on 02.05.2011 had upheld the judgment of the Honble High Court of Delhi in Writ Petition No. 14263/2004 dated 05.10.2010 in which the Honble High Court of Delhi has ruled as follows:-
8. That apart, instant case of promotion is not one where promotion has to be effected upon a vacancy arising. Subject to being found suitable the petitioner was entitled to be promoted in situ. The situation would be akin to granting a selection scale to a person and the date of eligibility would be the date wherefrom the benefit has to be accorded.
9. Under the circumstances we hold in favour of the petitioner and direct that the benefit granted to the petitioner be reckoned with effect from 1.1.1999 instead of 19.9.2000. Arrears would be paid within 12 weeks from today but without any interest.
No costs.
The applicant has sought grant of the same benefits to him as have been given to Sh. S.K. Murti vide the aforesaid Court orders.
3. The respondents have filed their reply in which they have not disputed the basic facts regarding eligibility of the applicant for promotion to Scientist-D and Scientist-E from 01.01.2003 and 01.01.2007 respectively. However, they have contended that the promotion under the FCE Scheme as per DoP&T guidelines is to be given only after the Assessment Board has suitably assessed the officer and found him fit and thereafter the recommendations of Assessment Board have been approved by the Competent Authority. They have relied on the DoP&T O.M. No. AB-14017/32/2002-Estt.(RR) dated 17.07.2002, which stipulates as under:-
Promotions are made effective from a prospective date after the competent authority has approved the same. This is the general principal followed in promotions and this principle is applicable in the case in situ promotions under FCS as well.
Further, they have stated that when the case of the applicant was referred to DoP&T they advised that the benefit of the judgment in the case of S.K. Murti (supra) have been given only to the applicants of the case therein and have not been extended to others. On this basis, the respondents had rejected the representation of the applicant vide the impugned order dated 09.02.2012.
4. We have heard both sides and have perused the material on record.
5. In our opinion, the case of the applicant is squarely covered by the judgment of the Honble High Court of Delhi as upheld by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of S.K. Murti (supra). The stand taken by the respondents, therefore, is unjustified. Honble Supreme Court in the case of Inderpal Yadav Vs. UOI, 1985(2)SCC 648 have ruled as under:-
Therefore, those who could not come to the court need not be at a comparative disadvantage to those who rushed in here. If they are otherwise similarly situated, they are entitled to similar treatment, if not by anyone else at the hands of this court.
6. Accordingly, we allow this O.A. and direct the respondents to consider granting benefit of promotion to Scientist-D and Scientist-E under the FCE Scheme to the applicant from the due date with all consequential benefits of pay fixation and payment of arrears as directed by Honble Supreme Court in the case of S.K. Murti (supra). This will be done within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. No costs.
4. Respondents have filed their reply opposing the OA filed by the Applicants.
5. We have head the learned counsel for the parties. We agree with the learned counsel for the Applicants that this case is squarely covered by the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of S.K. Murti (supra) as followed by this Tribunal in OA No. 1111/2012 - Vinay Kumar (supra). We, therefore, allow this OA and direct the Respondents to consider granting benefit of promotion as Scientist-D and Scientist-E under the FCE Scheme to the Applicants from the due date with all consequential benefits of pay fixation and payment of arrears as directed by Honble Supreme Court in the case of S.K. Murti (supra). The aforesaid direction shall be implemented within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
6. There shall be no order as to costs.
(UDAY KUMAR VARMA) (G. GEROGE PARACKEN) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J) Rakesh