Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Vijaya Kiran Chawak vs M/O Information And Broadcasting on 29 March, 2019
® 3 3 3 3 3 3 i 3 ;
\ 4 OAND.423/2018 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAT ORIGINAL APPLICATION Wo ,.423/2018 Date of Decision: 29° March, 2019 CORAM: R. Vijaykumar, Member (A) R.N. Singh, Member (7) Vijaya Chawak, tran Chawak, "gt me 4 in j-
ang ae oy 3 oD ry ret fet re Witte ~ 4 ¥ ay ING Soo Nate of Birth: 16.09.19¢2, Rae SE pee a . ~ Age: 55 years O8 months, T _ Worked as Phat emer Cia 2 Meh yx aes py (isroup Tm the Kae vy x M um CA. a Flat No. .. Applicant. (By Applicant Advocate: Shri R.G. Walia ).
Varsus.
toe lneced Lasteneiires lb \ B . @ @ t Pm i ~ Ag o ce wt + ved ved S g 40 = g rd o tt H a o .
n o na my oe & , oo 4 ct ra wd a hy 4 A wy Oo eg 2 wy - f < bad xt ad é & 5 . m AE Z ~ © 3 . oa £3 2 i} ry : 5 -
. , 2p 4 3d & % i 3 . ved ag Phy ve) "oy bs * ce et 1 a os by he mw i "4 ss ~ o @ 32 % ute "of "a 2 os yo rm OS ar 4 : . x Lh a . a % 4 eat B they ved on ad wd o oO a Lt ny 5, ci fey 3 " © a 8 os he, s : y 'ed it a PI e oo bo ie ar 4s % ¢ et a ta 'he ~ me Gh ~ @ fa ork ' "a mp A = OD a A ml S & Cay & fu og mM a o we On "OH ts es & mS 2 u . hte a: if i BJ ee «AB Q % $b 1855 oe os oi ae ast - : 6S, i yet ar % i M fe «Eo 6 me) oo #8 "
oZ fb tM G - , as dA os ur O Cy om i ~ red Yt G 2 g bey ae Se " ve, OD Bs iB clog Af g wi = tS Me '- epee oe ' eek Y q fe a 4 ote PRG aoe oo B a3 at Co GS wo ea uM ia mp oS Pea £, rt 43 cr mom ho ow a ry En m4 od 3 CO A ss cn %
- oO oo f+ 6 @ 43 i 1 cost Hi sco CO ost S oo rool ss sf Bet peg oad ER Gi it6I ? tp) bord eo by red 9 w Gf Fete) g $4 tACy u g on rs ai gh ue i a rd Ed ~ EB om ord ow BE @ Sot ap OS © O od oe % en oD of M () fe te Ch 2 meet a ed MM Fad Nes 4 iB te Sed % . '3 we a Ya o a a @ Ery tis oS s ot z & 9 Be vel [) 5 i x " x & Dp nm ue cd us oe 4 a % B <3) 42 oO ord @ ~ 4 ed "a a ay "4 2 ; bs ss a ¢ - a ft i ba Ry r Oo 4 ran es $ a ® 3 " "3 © ef 2 m3 = fs 43 Pat Ct oA 44 a << M4 & rd ces 9 digati aS 2 agp dL or the S82.
work time Chal Le the ' os gh ys i , , ae) Ps a 4 a a y B Ww 7 c B oe G a % i on bd t 6 y Ae s 4 ca oy ng 3 CG 3 ; a "7 , ; 5 4 bef - 4 oe oy ve Cs a3 ® JG - "
o x oe Py arg gd G "ed . As rep) 1 G aA baa x. 1g es yg Ss a Q @ G 44 nm 43 « a ih ot 1 hed 3 cu AS 0D oh bed 4 x 5 ft + a, fe % 2 © GS ® HF ¢ © # Bg se . eG tyes + a ba a 43 es iB in i aa seh 440 fed w iM fata a Aca ae f i a A wy G : S as a cy of C aa i ' ¢ " i S rs @ w@ 5, i py Bs i : 2 ky 2h ed 4 a wy & mn na oe 4 uy -: Gp mi. i "7h cf by Wo in a 43s Bas te p a a a @ i 4 re wy at ch £3 ae *e Keg '4 at a He a fe 3 i iD " z4 pe 3 oo ® cE a Yes ey a the sos, OD. G oa es + abet a oy OL GOUF mt 3 a 3 oO G ; - im a a one
- iS " ne G & rh es oj bi bg Oy ay a rt "y GO Ye a a @ 8 ® Fh, ise} mw 35 ' od ' poir he Le Gi e MAS AA on Ut & et z sed w ae o set o 32 . Rae Qh 3 bef a uw et om » % 2 G hy Ha GS "ed hy PPD tes pHing ies eae Li aap nanemmenere ie' reccecenan rates ten epenanmnmarrrrpeeriee ceverveseretreeedranee tenn antee XY & Q N Eh w a * aw wr a & tis @ 0 a a Ge 44 w ft © wi oe i ss rf i ws 4 ka $3 AG & @ 1 G 8 a 0 «3 ae ' 4) 4d he 4 : - 3 os ud Oo 3 ~~ oes qh ~ 7 8 @ Gs ia a ts vd $5 04 & % "ef x c be 5 "rt : CG G @ 43 ' + we ei 2 red * wet vet we gy $a red i aq S Gk a - ed : Pp Le - : t an £4 a 5 me uy 5 he @ 4 . 3 = ci @ oo 4 ve » cea kD rt _ a G . mh - ne a © x uy uy 7 wed mw ct id i BE aay ri gh 6 a a G8 m og SG ry tO 3 oc a & Cha . & 8B ee é Pa "4 C iy mt ws «> Oy ' cy ose weed c on iy on a ie oa : a Bs Ne + o cos opt my ted $4 an "F $2 ¢ m4 33 oy 2 rf o a 4 Ag, Se @ 3 "3 a Ct wed ae cy Oo sed oO 4 3 i} mc ce a 4, 43 AS foi a rte oh aN os ne UF ' orn Pp Ft <f 4 ' o as in % wD ca! 3 Be By '
- 43 os per $5 gt eet © a #5 , uy 43 eh ari Bs a4 > . a i gy oon w gt ma Of ts ys Boo © fs mend © By 3 a id Ct ot , sed a w@ a : % " weet be
"4 ee ee a » & # , «OG SB mm fF oy be ha Ly ee se ws o © ® id wd : = + Q ty ae G ria & a ctf] wD LO . Oo Ba oUt won og * on ae 3) 9 . 8 FF 8 i f Ch, ™ m O a be fa mh my 8 bs Sy ee ys aed aa 2 a oo « & Soe ww 8 Y oo cy o a 4 $4 aed te 's ws wr gs ' s bed wo an mn 3 ae iw w u g v4 sol * Cy x 2 a rt 3 ed 5 = £ oO Eras é a Na o ° Do . A . ea 2 3 & 3 TS ed 3 og G . a) 2 red ra : a $2, 4 oy x i i Ct v @ : Fe © = "rl Qo G GO B&H of ee gas ; "rf b $4 ved ut be nt ae ih a 1 Pa g G Ad ' au iB HS a be i my G4 Bt wy Bp, oO ied rs gd C} ' aa 43 gq wy me 44 & v3 ok a ha ' MM c 4 sf fH Q3 43 bet rE "
oo et 2 rd an fry xd.
= a Zz eg @ us ty TH Syott G &4 a my By od on uy Shy 7 ity ys bo sf.4
Lt he at +t 44 m4 ied 44 hey DB 69 05 US & 3 oy G ie wate:
ABXUMS rk Ar wi i x et Nt ord NMHeKRES { Tor 6 4 :
a et % & + ae {An tt 43 whe thori 3 oe ot £ Confidential wt File No. M-No.M-22021/78/2018-D0 {FC} a Government of In Ministry of Information & Broadcasting 'RS! Wing, Skastei Bhavan;
New Delhielig ool New Delhi, dated 17 April, 2018 filed by Smt. Zon Appeal Perit * 5S) u Oo Tr 8 % to Secretary Chawak, x CBE.
haixperson, Taye Va fnew under az tT bee nweed ened rene bd tte LI Ittihad?
OANG423/2018 * Rules against Mambad dated me CEO c arder of remeval from service} under of Rule 23/44) of CCS {CCA} order 23.8, 20176.
ee ncerecve: real eete ated eed ata atta / wees vente ana er nora RB» GN & Dorn $4 & ha Wd me EY 45 db *~ wee Oy es bot ot 4 OS vy, Wk teed aoe wy Oe & oo. 8 Es ys a te Bs BON gy Ga 2 yw tt ay 8 we OP ey mee OS SG Be eg gy OO oo Ba S by & Bos gg Sf te ong §e Ne Ry ewe & ¢ a Boe on 43 * BD vy a "4 "* a Ok vot DY he be eS rah iy od Wy Z a 3 Nm YG '4 i G r wo "4 oe) a z ce MR gy ee ON We 6 gp 4 UW OS gy 7 @ " ee sed AY Ged oe oF 43 wre mE ge Ly ope ES Weg ee BM Gay B op B HG oh ae 'tj fs BS Ra ag Ry Bg +f 5 seg ny 2 ved ON ta he ° @ tO TP ogy bs ky ry oa 43 OS ay oy h Le gs re xi ee ee y tj Ry be By 45 -
i oO) Sy we ty, 5 fe Hog OO SOU og cs h, b 4s Mong 3 ay an > & 8) OR Sty eg a 2g gy S pm & Go in 23 on 3 Woot Gy 1, te hy is) s W Sg ort 45 EP on <3 Sa Oy te wp 4a +e Ae Bw ty we Cho aa. & GO my we © wt Wine, rt i?
=f & z= x & basa "4 Qe oy oy 6 & Ba Be ke he ES be My 2, Yat SG 4 ay by key & time 44 ay yr wh ed iy a wn me 2 of La ope A ® py US A 2 et hd os Boo.
Th, uy a 7 i mo wg in £4. sng tet Q a wy '2 hay a 4a hy Q hy a
i) wef o my or§ 4 i iG
i) 3 te seh ceed hh £3
-&5 .
wy uy uh % AS 3] mY hed ty OD after Authority may, 2 ngpiring Government closas &.
= and shail, x abe s cage, not has generally question Goremment gearvant if the himself, a Ok examine appearing tances CLP CRS.
the him the Gorernment the avidence for 2 ¢ Bim 27 agains anabling the at purpose Bs CaAUCaS nm any elec 3 = gervant to expla uu t bs gains n the evidence ag appearing i Le a St "e3 nf ae Lt 5 oe gy ey 4 ae gs Goong Ent ' £ % 44 2G mt A a 8 OAND.623/2018 By < 3 S £ 3 y :
Ct fa fn tt © ty Ee3) Ak Bs be 3 Gb be io hy M3 ty oe :
r > a 3 a" RY She for woo {A}, dated G2. 88.2978, stipulates thet we et "In case he {IO} @xercises the I discretion of taking written briefs, it ~ ot wiili be put fais that he should first take the brief 'from the Presenting efficer, supply a copy of the -same te Gorvemment. servant and take the repiy brief from the Government servant. In ease the copy of the brief of the Presenting officer ie not given te the Goverment servant, it will be like hearing arguments of the Presenting Officer at the back oF the Governument sarvant. In this connection, attention is alse invited. to the Judgment of the Calotbta: High: Court in the case ef Coliacter of Customs ve. Mohd. -Habtbet fis730) 2 SER 322 fCal.j 7, ain which 2 aes laid dewn that the requirements of Rule 24{29} of the ccs {CCA} Rules, i965 and the principles. of naturad Justice demand that the delinquent efficer should be served with a copy of the writhen brief filed by the Presenting Officer before hé is SPREE EN anne ae gaa d se na ea gn ena ada seaewsaweeseervereree Ne * 7 % Dy 4 "4 rep BY a. Gt +N a o> Wao SRY te 8 Rp ory 4 tid rey i now Et ow ee" 32 ox Beogae 4 3 wT mom 3 0 & " "Pe ae bag ' ts a 3 ToD a 3 Of iy BD oy ogy G 4 Dk nc ae Roa OB ae gt Ms a ft Ce ree . rho G , & : 3 . <i Gy ie 4 ny oS o 2 co 4 fp BS By 2 oS cg it fe te oy rt be | 0 S ba Ch bs 3 & & a 4 ga 5 sh 53 OD a4 © Boa He & Wy G tos ge oO 4 iT 2 8B og Sg 44 a oy ' fos i% $3 og i oh D 3 3 "esp o£ th SE Ay 2 a a ee o> a ae e a 3 2 te a er, MHS, 0 G 2 oy ay ot iS ong 3 a 3 ay DU OS am et 7 Ly «4. @ A ag At pont ol 3 se wt ° 4 re 45 a ER SEG on wy SE oe ~ t&m . 4, © a Ly OR OR es wy 2 43 eg kp He Sy yan, i foe 3 em Om BAR eS 4 ie "3 0 wy B x hy Bg eos gy ge Od ep & By % ay a &4 cy ab oy Ch Gg 7 3 Bg Ow By 5 ry 8 OR ay at ab es Pr Beng gy ae Bs .
a ' CP SP SUG Ree Qh As ane B c Oy AD ee ty Oe em oo ot @ , ~ 2 te aw pau Seay ity ig Gh bp se BH a * a vt ne B mh Os ay ors oy 6 ay 5 2 : aps iy Me :
a « my gore 2 G 4 det ¥ e cs 3 a by & wy rd rg er % "uo br 3 x ry, AL ty fey ey sy UR ty wy a t ms wy FE 42 "oS C3 44 " 4 5 Bon om & he Bow F LQ hy 4 Seopa a : oy ' By 2g ' care ' i : 4 oy ky BD ee uy, & 3 a A cs mr Met is DG ae ta 33 wk bey "s es fay ord wR ks u ° th egg bey eng OB & oy fer ' » JB ort '3 of Bo 2 bbe : a 8 5 2 2.8 8S a3 GQ os xe Sy vet oeb : GS 8 o by bb eg Uy % ba ho eG Bs oy % .
OT Boy fh % 6G tg Thome GOR g O, Hb Fo bw of 6088 4 228 4 a ww AD 4s oO a LL oP 4 Aa kt Ge fy ret OG Be 6 OG 6, 5 ARMM MD DAES hse dd Cannone nd mandate DANG. 4235/2018 qu Ch grt QO G ter at Qe ote reed An or ae age set bean e ¥ ! Wee ita wleng v4 8] © :
aye Bover s Mox pondents.
nm ee Pe SAA aid} nt An a re) uy $4 oh wv = oa OR ~ :
Boars re > ea ay Aa Seow i ay leg sy ad Pea RL ABORT EL,
4) y '. .
% a ao Q 4 é e "a 4 i ip Q ce 4 j 43 u. a os © a ( i » . a ny M4 » 43 bed e o i & 43 ae} i vi @ w ied ie k a ard : & oy ae G © 23 ee ve ¢ ae} gi 4 oO x4 Be oe ro) 43 « @ . = 43 eh 4 mt LS eh i H wet t. ca en G 5 = ral a I a o G Mt ed " a ba i * @ 8 S fu ah 3 a + @ ot ; rt G vd a 5. of z fa 43 ss) wy Q o; ay ; 2 @ oO ie ' ng or 4 f ca) M4 : fo 4 Oo cal Ge x A are cP et pO oC 'A 3 iS) g RG cl hay £3 a i? 44 - " * Gu geod od se G , bb & 2% a ™ a 3 a 8 3 8 Fg ow & 4 @ a h 5 iG Hi vd i be ts wD | & oo a a "%s Cy , c e a ££ 3 @ e & 9 vo B . er Bk ca VD as ws se SS A oS a M4 i ee he = 44 4 By) v An 5 Le Q io a ay a iw 4 po oB © @ So 6 »p a ® j 3 tt 4e 65 a C3 ce o ~ | or wo {} a oY 0 4 CG wi QQ M4 9 VG ted ; - 2 ei 4 ord Y x 63 S G "ce « o o ed Qo '4 GB FS me 2G 5 rd a @ iy A o a i vd fy wel a ra $3 s, u e a es o © 7 Set e £ 8 &@ g 8 5 Go we go o 5 @ G RP FB & 2 2; i oe yB : zs 4 eed bet ae wt we * ; 5 ' ¥ ng cl ct or} ms : ve iy $2 1.2 Os » a 44 o y vm i € ra w Gm BS So Hs who oy So 2 4 Oo «4 a © " Ws a ' 4 rh - o Ww ©) es is) a ent @ & ® ie) hen: @ o i : od - mo Pay, . ot $4 SS &, ard rs af 43 4 @ SS "t ay as , ~ ih) e bod t iB y 4 ' 5 rs) ' qh @
- od tt 3 ot bg y sd sae Sa US ; oc @ . G © : ao a ty yy a 4 , he tm v4 4 ord u ea ho a ct yet at a i be 2 he ce] we (3 ce; ' hg 4 bd pce Oy, eed. rt Ly fa * ean' che an + + yod ' Cy i) aa D ms i $2 Fa ie "4 ' & ® a % 33 3 o @ ¢ 9 & os nr) ef a 3 2 2 oe 2 " ° i gs a ht et ond Ci Ae ay at oa ry es o 4 x4 4 bs ; o uy 5) ve mp st By at uy rast 2 te «ed ce bd D4 nt a nar me Se es M4 bs in "s & 6 oY © 4 , 35 "4 a 624 io ee a C fer is a act n a "hed ! my ci o i3 ce oo ' Ly "4 g ts bn é a fs es Go a a 2 4 a o . HOE oa o 5 o '3 ee, re 4 y ett vd wh aa i . oa % ian 4 be a 6 @ ww ® fia ; rr DB mp Mw BF va wa « G ° a on th 2 4 a ; 4 2) sed " a e da a hy a @ a . " PF pone o nm FS g i a @ HH 44 i o e 3 " oe i a i 4 @ we o S fe oo G 4 a © ay 5 . £ é a & Ee & & @ mm a ~~ . is , a {gt a QB wed ae bea he 4 wo Ad a4 ate ai re * 44 ad 4 BS 3 el @ rd 13 ; 2 4 4s wt - ied GA 3 rs) . rs rg aa a4 ro em) ly ra C A t rt 44 t 3 a bs eH s Os 7 a °C 7 h ron S sd ef 'a G co iy oO a 5 : Seer . ct ; 4 2 MM @ i : 3 . as) % 2 8 a | e g rs O oe Y ct "ei & oo - > i ni oi ued 4 : 4 2 ci re os , vel & Ws C - o & & & & & B 2 uD ek BG ge 2 BE oc i 2B 9 o 9 & , ~ a i .@; cc oy ms s rs & es i a faa Dy $e o 1 ; wy fh, ee Q ic ; os 3 be oy D - me bh & bas a Fa, oO hy Pe $ oS & fy iD w tt} i i Q "4 G uy ne OANG.4823/2038 12 iene ntanna na rns - vee Place dene teen annneene depen edie te ina nalne Tanselatennelata tuleiepihensandvite dave ceded veadsacctcactatatettate aattaanctattay "A . @ a eo vo Pa g AG 3 $2 ip a Oras oC where aone r e a record, La £ i © 43 r.
m4 3 ra! My oO e , rl a] Dy a ie et £3 D x @ ed vo fs 5 a yee . Ad i rf ia fet ce & . Lg :
5 a @ a o i a a or s Peon oy Do © * Pook x i had xt me ct ; . 3 Oo #8 43 8 4S 5 ot 7 O bo w G od $s . 4 et a4 ry a gs a a os, " ; , @ 4.4 ES % et ca td pb ee 4 & 8 B . » GZ & 6 gS :
aa 0 é os ; s 6% t qs a eed qe ~4 fd a3 hy a 44 uy ©. G Co fA a3 - iG ri$9 * m "eh ed ) 2 hy Aa ed {3 ved C3 % Bo Bg ! 4 5 BON . cS # , od wt as ® ws , @ oR 2 pM Gm S " nea f rt «ay © ra ht co oe na ha mf o wo m 9 . @ <r a as ved a $4 rt & ma G4 m ua yd "<S mg we ed ' ; $4 a Gr Dy ved aH ie a oO ae oy ae & ae o of 1 a ie "Cs a h if ¥ 14 ve PB oy, mn oso F YF a BS : Q ' e u 4 : 4S & % Ma a OS D " ~ Of a : i 4 44 6 i St kG ie) P on has @ pr re ' 3 os me Oo 5 faa ts cs oe my . oO a Sw G @ 2 ae % \ a - 5 Bo es OG ' s Lu LY;
hes yam is i Of te H a i roly ey, Fe art fr, x So rh et oo fo ot f& @ @ @ 5 6!6UUU m4 3 & && DO om og Bo He fd mG Mm -- oO OO 3s G 4 @ oa o art a ~ed "et @ th GQ G Gy CG be 3 OANG.S23/2018 43 ote 6 wf os O a wD : Showed ogg tp wt OM Be wove tet ba td a @ & & p Lf le i oS eo oty tm kt Pa Roos = fe oO ROS a AD oy Cr fy @ va mo be o> i, O 45 7 fe ty eh RY 4 7 Wg ay hy 2 @ hy Ms be Gh ba mp oF $1 & ty oy J a bs 3 os yt OM ry a "3 3 ty oe Bh oy ey aS a4 as oh eee so 3 8 5 fy pe iy 8 a" 2 re Ag a oe ° MLN is at a 4k 4 oh ht 9 , mao s i % as 2 4 ve A & a TA ty uy Lk ont by < Ee a er . Ps : .
oh, P = ved * So 3 w~4 ® 4 4 4 ba) Co 2 .
ee i we = > & a a had ed, MO _ Wee eet onsen ores ir 43 ot "eS 4 QD & i wy oN tat @ bet o ay ro gy a a? % fe ev ci eo OY GS fs S 4 ww Oo gf «2 ot G i xo a QB bet wD > es ped Wg $a £3 »> "k) 3 13 S & xf eed Mt it "5 ed 6 wef ey, vot wet Qi a a si wt a hy , ee ed on 4 g he in us a ma a =f 2, 13 ch, 3 ww wo p c . a D 2 P i c 5 5 be ¢- Oo «¢ Gg PB @ A gg " @ ut v = a ee] oO = &S ve ro hy o ce ¢4 ih % a & : wy - @ perk * Rea a a Pe Ga » Go M4 ry eS Ss rm a oO wed mf Be DF e Ws © By ' o @ a hg so 48 7 A gD OS Rs nF ~ E ot ry {3 vane 3 Be 3 a £93 a $A a ct us 2 La we 4 cH G a ard pe eg a ff Soa 4 mh 3 3 ky ¥ ~ 4 . vot ao gs Pe) 3 * * ' ® ; us ri a gd hy as 4 .. 2 av rt oO a ? itt ved cel C3 43 v Me "cA wr ww ee os ny TB 42 j 4 so me "4 3 & fd a3 #4 ~ A oo v "4 Sh} "oe 02 wn ; iw 4 a «6 wef 6 ; @ 4 oO my @ cet ard o ' 4 a < ti ocd i i ' a3 44 iG me wo ted $4 = a ti © @ ae oe Cy fe a fet od 2 we 2 is 4 & ' re) ms oq QD te oh, ty a ai Soe . . GB rhe <4 4 4. o ce ei * ste 3 } we £3 gt hed C J vat . ws . oe 3 ; ws ° oe) 4 Ss i ; wh ed ° u ¢ oc ota a "3 fs iw t cA G i 2 i why 3 Q x ' Z eet . B res co 3 y be¥ es 3 fe wet ay ws 44 Ca, Ah Feb Seg ty " 'y hae GC 5 2 3 Y EB oa o oon Ss 8 2 4 " rm eg moO w 3 wo o ss wh ed 2 Oo ised CG ' hed os 44 i 4a a @ a : ad
- S f © Qo OS & & oS Be n the m4 a wl rn tn a e § © ws fs i ot 4 i wd % rd ha fA ~ i 4 bef a --a & G NM og Hs te : 5 v wD i rst ord ae % * oe ye oe as ra} oO 4 ; * "e 7"
a fe so 8 mB BS e " ts ms G&S stay me ¥. bod ; to goed au « wd 4 : G > ey "
i @ ~ ti by rd _ a a 3 f B a ' 4 % Lad Ld ne % ry ' ee a : we © : a ' & 8 op 8 ; wo HO, o & eo a nal ts nal en reer + oa f ba x a be wa 4 a " i 43 G a we 4 ft ad e n 4 ih rt ae 3 ord ord omy DB t3 ed " Ad t) - ky ny, in ' a eet Ra re 3 a) we Be : 4 ved o ct , oa 4 iW 2 . "4 in © £3 nt weet i MM a 3% e Seve PSS se co % re Gio ed ed % uw Bo or a ved Ab +g D, et "Ch hiya ct BD ae pe ed Woh 8 & is, a yf : 4 "DOD m cd ke oO © 6 j 3 Re io er w cy @ ae Oy Oy 44 rs Ob #) qr £2 cork us 3 G 42 uv w isa) "3 cS fd L r he
10. ii.
ys & o
12. S OANG.AZ3/2018 pilin he Disc ty t p v # CO -
O "Ve & w a hs ro . 8 Bs a Poe ~~ % @ ¢£ : BoM ge ew a 8 M B a ow oe mA O "3 1 <H ah % 44 a a ved '6 G 45 «a a a oH Gop na 8S my OS Q O 2 pO GS oA © B " a ra mn s wee ne . io] vd . é 33 "3 aa fo ha ome ip ee @ es i re ie eof nn +s a CG i ¢ a3 baa 3 $4 I ye iD 2 . a ® & ze ™ m a Fa, a 2 ei y a os as « ws 4 & Bi 0 G thes x t i iG a bes xa rd eo os & ; 0 " o £ ot edo g o Bb "3 wn 3 Yd « 3 i ® " - Lon vat » eh. 333 43 ied fo 3 43 ¢ es cs re and C . w ( G Ad A Qn 3 ved es ted O . rheg r 0 . aS # 4S ae o ia wer, ort c 43 9) 44 a eA tH vf ee a wn vt g tel i Ug @ a FF v4 o w Fé ce rd 4 *y © & Oo w B oe " G 3 «6 Q a a Ad me ma i Cy oS "3 ! vd 6 2B E+ be 'o Mt » © 8 & % oa G OO Be 3 uo 2 O - 6 % 2 a 4 @ r Bp . 3 et c ra a Soe ® «i cn moo cS @ = wn a i 4 "
ag oon Se Ge o a ; & Bos ee ee Q 3 S e d i a ' a o xe . ~ i e wd a n red on ha wo om OU Fe gs so a 5 GUS > 2 % a % 8 ~~ "oom EB pe 8 Fa Ct we ved 5 ee @ G 6 ved a a 4 4 . ' te a vied pD ay ha xt Q, yy . ro i i & @ vhe . M wv gt a re a & i 4 ror $5 _ oa Rg . o ot 0 7 ar % ay a " mC Oe eal o cy OF by «. Go om Bw OY BF ey tb ft Th ged v4 « ~ . rt 2 Be 4 *s f rt : sc wt ie wD a e
4 of g ge ae FE > % o G & a 6 2 G 3 @ ag GS - i 32 $4 fel rsa! 1 4 he a * r 43 * 5 oot isha cst r q ae eh @ gt . ' ae 44 G ug 42 rot 3 4 } ef c es 3 ; foe ; 4 re 3 a "ed i < pO Oo Gs So fo os be ' c hy > oO ~ 5 «. 6 43 w 44 re) 3 ra G ve qs ° ce) ord w v Shed me Sy ceed '3 $ od as Oy a ot ® a iow BG a a » 3 4 Hog eg Co B® , m4 yO ie 4 oy eo C Ry ® Gi in G GS ved "
oy a : 2 "rf - a = be y a o) a4 av a @ 4 mm @ 44 re . a @ gi 4 Ww i o ( a i 3 ' a Li 7 bet 7 ced 5 7 <i Sod 4.3 a Gh ard ¥ WD G G 3 G "sd beg 4 a io itt ue a3 w ng og os ed G : a ey ut a 4 MI oS 4t xi . ns "a vt ist ot Aa w oD ba is om et a ry Py Py a + a oO a ¢ 4 4 oo cad 3] \ ' iS 4a os oe 44 oS CO 5 9 &@ os o & & i os 8 8 2 8 ¢g 8 ul ey os 1 a $ . fa a As & a ® 3 < a 2 5 . rs : ee ; - oa x é r @ , & & rel Be] kb & OF et a + wt 5 i a3 43 a Q si iw " rt be of oa aA a 1 3 5 to 5 r tA oo C e & e a et * 2 pm 64 a ay " oh <3 hy ae Gh - ; M dof Oh (4 Gr i$) Ch iw i hy '4 \ OANG.A23/2018 ert <i rt wu at a we Lis ted « eA peek 43 ~ A
-
a ta ther ae bo mR the ai hi 1 aed wd erg i} "B uw "0d ad 3 ° 4 sot) cy W} 8 D 3a 1G Ga a 3 £ af ars i reg s in £ AL 4G 33 Ue SP db ced 42 3 a bed & 4H c fi uF DANG.923/2018 % ee 4 4 vf ts mt fs wa Lo x an ca ie sq ' a 2 &% Ch Shy eo. "4 i red "et Os Ae ty hy ae "4 4 . is gt re a ~ val bn sae ; Gg Wy 8 any da Ay wy es a oe i % weed beta Wy a ' hs a % ea og o a ib a3 a 4 ty w % % eG * nr} taf ;
gm 6 ss a ae :
2 % rep AS et g 5s "ok ay "4 6% , "4 4 heme) "
id oy ore B® 9 % "4 S v oy 4 o ny i ay 5 "he 43 Og & 9 . 9 Lt a = m Bos re "3 i aa G 4 £ ty 2 0 Q tt a Z wt th a A ip Moog hea OM pt a Z "a "Ch Re Sy 4 re) ot Bs) ig a te ty Be i red eg me & . 4 " , wey ' a =. 4 ty se Hey 2 ca s % we 3 at 4k 4 ce rt Mm bef ks tm Fg, ® a "ry ' 45 o 4 AY & emt © u ot by Bed SI ci ws 5 ig xt coma HS Uh 2 t E43 tS Ted > § a ' b % a Se iMé % G De Ny i) :
"a et oe a > ao by MS = Uittcnamean atnngren en ¢ OANG.423/3018 rong OF oy aD Ky 3 te As hg 3 et ie Ge ce 2g cs os oy og 42 z ny a Ea bide 3 bt ' 2 oie is = ed $e '2 C5 sf CE et gets te Doo PS hed 3 A AG 43 ng ed veh 3 3 ¥ r WU ay ay ~. & hg we Gy Cord oe Sy TD AYER fe Ps ud he he be oe "4 An es t ded a} os a ® 0 g i tt aS o te i os =e tt aes 43 4a ey oe ia a +r 2 . a & rh, AS wey eyed 2 i BPMs 2 oh, 4 3 i " f a vd $s oO m4 ed te reed se eh te wo Hay te, Bh oy be = ' 43 Shu G 5 % @ 44 at 2 fe < s 'cd 5 OO 4 4 > " ps ws Q £ te oe 2 . tx q 3 . ed xy + hy ord No bh 3 a a aa & % he oY £ i <A or} \ ' a ~ rf * c aot kp | 4
16. a A OQ L & a * tt % B 4 G ww 3S Ok at ey 44 w bed M4 xg hed a 42 2 0 u 3 a As a) mt 4 u Qa G n wD whe C QO sed a ay rs th x 43 @ ae a a © ved 6 « ® o SS ry 3 3 ip a a At Ww ou oh4 og} by n rh 4d % uy
- ae " ne gy -- ~ is we a 3 % 3G 34 % sn ms ss z Dy 4 Q 3 % v ® £2 { a is fob ot or] « rot Cb o > ved ved w A rt fa 3 a Bos od » my Gerd gO " G al fi, a Cg a 3 oh 4 = . a3 4 as a . ; sed a ® ng wo Bog OS oe ¢ 8 Fe BO a 8 o ag wood Q £3 2 aa e , td @ 6 os te cs rot 4 r ¢. '¢ a bo 4 o vB or} . " : 2 is) a ow re 2 sed Aw Het 7 43 as : @ sd de f M4 RO af G oO 8 8 a o os co oi . o 6 gs Chy ~ ut "4 a goot ta a wi o &3 * i & 3 gv ka £i' 4 us ts Ry th O pe a ht md co) Q tat OM st % GC nn © @ ¢ vog © ig ® 64 5 wg e f me 3 a & a 6 ™ gE £ 4d . we 6 G a a '4 ved 4:4 " bef ted £3 4 4 a ms hb ag we . oD G 4 + i Oo Sel © a eg iy ¢ 4 3 4 ¥ @ net 5 «5 3 a o @ 6 a es woo 2) ¢ oe . Oo % uD ys et 4 "4 HO "4 ord is a 3 'x 3 a4 " ae « Set : me Boy ig cd , th gm ti @ me th 4 ha y wv wt Hed y B pa os Fa) C Oo 9 2 4 Bt ea & © 6 © $ a & he rm ty 4 be iD G a wi x4 o + D @ th eed 3G g é 5 co Q) 43 rc dee ta ae i a sol St 44 $24 4d . ot 7 5 Uy *n wa 2 im wo oh ' Ae {3 p on R Ad we DO G¢ ff Cg "4 ' fe " "a ag D
"6 co i ved od od o e % & Ds ® 5 +3 ng os ws os my o ok TS Pa 4 C a of 'd . Bi 1 'L ad Ab vee o 8 in 4 o 8 a me Mo de moO , rf ie) os os in $4 G iby ws hi a @ us 2 © 0 8 FF FP og f 8 8 By ane S 5 5 6 8 4 Sg C9 Sw Po 4 Boe ~ oct 3 oN 4 68 " e @ ae © @ ged ay > $41 Ww ® O ge os) ed oe wi " iat p4 ¢ my gi Oy tA a 4 ot $3 oo) ct & é 3 £:
y @ tn yD 4 "eg vi ae 8 ed -o$ Ka 4 44 G2 ard vt "
4 OUP mS we ih @ g ' we a Bo ts & vy eS rt . ei a Bes By o hy i wy dS bet Sp gn Oh nr) a : eo SF @ FG me ME kaka G3 ae G oo Sho a Oo ooo ¢ + 8 SG " hi , & GR ya me 28 wh of B Gb re . Bb G ue @ "He \ cE ve be yO ' rh ~ v4 si ue i oe ® Gy oa (2 u3 es) od Sy » ee in zB red od he tS wy rd ce) ws 63 ard in c j red ih 1) ort * YD Gv ab 3) * oO i ip set QB me Jo $4 ard G % of , US iy SS i ned A cp ef, ues 3 "4 "tS $4 ts) oO O nee % tp fey we 8} & Hof it vd 4d by ia ra] co 3 3 3 3 :3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
g g hm jot liberty to challenge the same, if so advi:
Sen (R.N} SINGH) MEMBER (3) * ¢ Ak f ~ OAND.A28/2018 y 4 a UF ot iD 2 ae = ee 4 "
circumstances, tnere Ch an Casts.
iR. }VIGAEKOMAR) MEMBER (A)