Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Hari Babu Pardeshi vs M/O Communications on 28 June, 2019
OANG, 2223/2013 MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAT CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 222/2613 2gikWdune, 2019 x .
Date of Decision Mamber (A) Ly ; Mamber (7) Dr. .Bhagwan Saha a » CORAM ingh 8 RN.
4s is gy 2 "rt ri ° et 4 g + Cc . $4 « os Ca red S TH Gb Mi ES > oe me 44 At 8 . : G ~ WS 2. oN n aa as Soy OH . SE Py oH Rp Re OOD ord @ kh ky ie) 6 th @ uu eh ts 4d rf SSF ert ed ns! w Oo Mm Ct Cok oF uw 4 Bordo Sl OP Cy ap a SG wm ct U2 | a > Bt ord SG » $3 gh go o G8 @D f+ 6 08 ard 43 * i £4 rs cu] Mo 4A tm oy @ Q eho Te, oui 3 fee ao TY kp aD * m & Eph sed Oo « ake og Hoa oO OD ed 07) eH ro G3 ord aed & eo Get hi & 2 Ye Ee ap gt $3 Do 0 ££ © Yi « al @ oO € Oth a ty a GW OO Paes ee i oD @ » OCF tes "ef "A OD ey i im OG rl Skt op oc @ « i, Po Et fe pe} OM x & odo by eG ed oO ort ad , oh wD om al Cod Goo & * fel ©) 0 09 ~ oot & Memhbex v M Th.
The Respondents a @ .
a 5 Y S Ul ot td ' 2 mt * ® 4D f ° oe im 43 "rt -
° 2 a , ee Oo yaa Be a hg © .
G a 43 ml a @} nod os wea ify "nf io iA * a 5 % '4 ~ a s be 3 j . 6 A 4 3 "sy QO oA % ad od E 8 ® & Q a 44 wu * weed ¢ oe 5 cs) 3 3 ra 3 KS HE Shed 6 3 3g cs $a oe w 3 G ved ot rs) "4 Ge & %% ° D "
e a 43 » § ge os My ka u $: & , a a Re) ~ ne » Feet et ty 3 iJ? 5 genet mn c Q Ye o a MG oO oe a " a A O " a AO e , eo o g a 3 Oo oH " mS a 8 a § w 8 of 4 G en uD ed bb ™" N . % 9 a8 a 8 Sa 8 v BOE G8 " - a8 m oe & Bo G " im ty i wc oO fo é 4 eu ra o 6 ws c on i 2 ' ee (33 tes fl "
> ope io wy " evel = ~ ao "i % 1G 8 Oo § . & @ 2 as O ced vt . : % +e by ce : Q o j a - Pog G7 8 a 6G ee Pe SQ " fA ¢ 2 Go # re ka a yo re & A 3 i a : | 4 si G Sf 4 G @ rf % 4 ; wy o G @ a] Os Bs o> al & 2 Q Boa GS @ & G t eg a a ef a if 8 4 Q wt Ay f 16] cs 4s * ' 3 seed hi go @ = ch 4 xt 3 et | a & om za a @ cs We 1 8 zr 3 42 ae fy uy 44 Gt {oct oy Ch @ a o Mg : , fo oh @ co "
% e 8 a , b ai OB ed rd + OD t3 mS ys wy c * 4 $2 ~ wo GB '4 nn re C i mm n 8 4 8 gs 8 § 3 weet 5 an 'oF O 3 Be MM Qs. el ot | O® BO o 2 Ds by 4] xm ® he « veh 4 o- es ut v a > a rd
- ' ies m4 @ he ® 5 BR D vel % $i Ch Eo) a, a be 5 OR Gf 2 oa 8 Bo So Q : c of id Oy A by oD 2 i re we a CG 1 4 Bo! QANG.222/2013 OG @ of 2 © a a oO 8 ve » 8 ow '. a 0 C "ey M4 ~ Boe 8 oa a 2 ee < AS G ay 2S ow Gog: 8 oo ue es 0 ; ch oy 5 a, &E eh @ . mi Gg pO} Eo ad © Te © % 3 3 ny rh co tH " a a 6 Cy ce! fa : 8 ey % 2 jon ne a t a ix " i cs % , g % we go © =f % 4 a 6 Soo ww 2 8 "4 at a D t3 of mt ay ty i S "f ns . a io Mg a we gy a is 0 & " 1G sy AS ky hy g + SS si i ay 88 of a & ry 7) £3 f G by Uy et .. . 3 ; oD £ 2 i oy ha ct es Be a; ie re > oO 4 x a rh 3 ae Oy cy sl 4 Mags ae fe ay ge o Wg . w os > a) 8 a Wife ot th ' oa a wy S G . 7m se sed ce a segs 4 hg a a 8 ot "FS oh * bs ook Cy SOs Sy RS "gs ae ai ty ra 4 "rf ia 43 a my "A wt G iG C a +4 wre "4 G ay oy a w 4 ta <4 's 2 % os a cs 2 tN 4 8 4 3 oy tg od 4 uw x cme i & -- gw " & Mf te at 4 Q. Oo Ww ca sin ic Cc oO x BE S Talecom rds Kee Oo a a s G wena rane net mannan nn .
S, eye GANG.222 7/3043 3 & Ore ¢ ' Articile-IT aT ey) ge LOT oy Hh tvf oe ay reg ond nse $3, S48 or "4 oie~TTT a =a Ark st swt iy mT £3 Sy O55 th te] GAN5.222/2013 oD Qe AD m DP a ad » Oy 43 Be EE omy . ia 4 ta ie ry mw EMs 3 a hy OM . Boke ty ced > wo a od th "ve oh 3 QB my % a Pog : os ~ 8 2% 8 @ ow wm BS oes % ee ce BS Qe ay oo 4 * ce - oe gy a "ES wy og A nay i i} . , a8 BS a er oD o hat be Rt a oo ; 3 4 o oe if) ry Ly SRS 3) " ok a es i e dio M4 uy fg @ es 3 ; OM fs 3 " & Qo CF Ga a By xy e § nt o "4 ify : y wp ted wf 44 its] Sing Pe ih ~s, tt 44 < Mf c a " o As me * he ngd hy « "3 "n oa 2m ' ey ty wes we Tl iy' 6 "ee 6 w 0 A gay ad ™ ky : * be oe : te os S noi f--4 mM 3 mo 2 is . < T - {! ta 43 & BL te e a 8 fy oe Est et OS we wt ay & 43 0) 3 wed
9 Oo Dp > ' i ny RE a 1) wha a Hy oy BO @ a iS "rE mo ot oy Be wo eR ED by " a3 ny o ff 2 ot sod ey oe Q o mt Bend wre o G w w ~ 4 » eed ved fx} a) se a0 a C3 oy POOLE ECE T LEE TELL OOO OTOOELET (OEDADEDE #2), wetects OANG. 2322/7013 a ' wm) ° « Cc a an " ; ; , 6 ! 3 a wy he ' 3 6S © 8B RO oD & 80 GC HR G6 fF 4 5S os ee 2 wy i Boe 4B @ O° 6 a wed t3 4 uD} om oD cs 1G 4 " a * 3 3 i ent e 43 cd sg "rh z a) b C m yoo Oe o. we wo % a ot u ot fe a t ' At - rt © a 3 a i " rt 4 id o © we ig Be . ® $4 3 Bg a mw OT & a 6 € ® © & 8 w & 5 ff 8 4 i ; ¢ Go * iS 3 - , i fs ree : ! 2 " a F 43 @ RF B® © RF BF & wm BY fe i Go A 4 ea oe g * £2 Ce, £5 oy rol Cc ce rese a0 OFFL ad oF ot 20m z Q e £n i Ag £ Conelus "es ; ied ag : i % CP sreg * md uy £ ret Ch rhe ie sed fe % {+ : Bod Ee gg e i "cl fig oe wo Bo hg ut ba Ue Mos Ae ce see§ fez 6 $b es tH wee ® c iy a MG i ra reek '4 rq ws " Ohy Bear he ; ' - orf eek 6 "cs o 5 ga ie : "A eC o ad " i m4 & di u ho & 2 » Gg 5s 8 &@ ™ b& A © by : g 4 as i ms 3 os eee ss o gt hy ne m Soo a) "3 So & 8S ; 5 o <2 4 bee $ o od oy w Ned bet . et ao bs uy he i ns G be 3 oD o rt aed a gS wg .4 594 ¢ het 1% ' C3 s . 4 Ad Oa a os 44 : : ess @ a iB 2 4 cc , ra Es On 6h, a & z a u i at ee we i a " ® on oY C pe : " rs % 6S ' aad a sec es ws Pn wo ard E-4 ie vet et a od 4 o : ; oy Q :
iG wm om bP g ' m fp is sf 4 . By Bt ", 43 ™ Ct wv a , "s BX es \ ty @ w e 4a ee i Go ge i \ + ce % i % 7 i i 44 uw ond cy i GS 4 & ob 5 "i mt BD ; oS © 6 a) ~ i" aq Ow a re a co Es a fe i UO om Th mo om 6 G ed Sk "i Pos GB SP Bot tg G&G wa Oo 2 od hy he ho oa bay ¢ 6. 4 " Gi @ 2 = £ ' "4 2 + at ws iy ' & OO a OO , ; ne "4 ose4 us rat wd a Eas cd im 4 ne ® rs ort god a uy a ° der:-
w eH oof he ha a * 3 a g rae) * w x Oo ty ws mm bh Od ned "3 vu OH Cs x LEk Zk SNS ES ed age aaa sae sana a ae ead aaa aaa anna aaa ane OANG.222/2033 ort ei) i ow wy ¥ guait + Eas = on. Ka x BRC < LMDO ¢ :
cn aks, Y +t er x i = va = re %.
x G remo c th i & & Ee fly soy ticia~f Ar OANG.222/2013 +5 tt 'Ls 0 "4 4 ae VR he oN fel at és B No. 2+ iss G . sr shaves BOOVE ff oo oN ae ty "23 G3 "4 3 a ce ws eee Bey gS oi at 44 Lentil ae rt ha ny a Sans tW AW C2 wet ie a OANo.222/2043 rticle~IIzt rf 4 wt thy 42 ved re m4 tad SY %} aa 4.3 cs ney rust wd a ae ae SELON nm AG, = nk Ste Eat article-IV iy ae Ad DANd.222/2013 10 Bd ene, Bt owns Ab "eee % ah 3] a ai 8 ne ot 'r hg ag Pi AY ie) ool th a 4 oy = & 5 S34 in on vey ay ef g a e w.
he Liste zt see RP?
es £ 2 & ae i nae 4 CYES Oey ay pat ey .
yy VV Wares a sy 12 spf ae i wake ee = ty Try ade Me see ea.
ie Ho ce Re ke GAND222/2013 fe "
# es ed o S Sieg cA & + Tog?
mae SPT, COMMIT 5 Dy im 2 Bed owing Case Ns focal ond * Leena ane neetereDed Ee ebI bared dh DEAE late ers POE CONC LECCL cgdaggge rere a + oy a ® mm et we ra "
2 i oO i Od B eo A mt . 6 vet * § & east 4g 4 oy 2 . Seay, ot GQ x 33 td an oO od is) uy bed eh 7 - a a 4? oed Oo ay m SB oc co ~ @ Mm 43 roi @ ra GQ a3 ct "Le wo Shang + fut wg g 4 % a c + 2 es 3 NO Bot MO woo, mM @ . Db 6 8 6 DB oS = Sy C on] oy ra S 23 Q Gey ts A 3 43 «i o g ef S oO a ~ 4p Oo ge & ® og @ 8 oD a 3 ra NN 8 gy ht & ' a 6 " § "A o " Ss w@ : a ry es ; ws ve 4 , * 4 R "ry Oo 4 iL O ; ¢ ae : GQ 4 i oy y 3 rot tes Ut C wo OR aD Boe SB a be a S3 "rf BOS 3 - g . ry ee a ha m g © os a vs. so @ 8B yw @ Bo (U8 o So @¢ 8 & & gt 44 vet C cS reg 3 " aot * £3 hed oy wed v4 tng ts a es a 4 . sired i a ta 5 um cf ; et a 4 ay ie 7 ta + a ti ed ty . oe hy 43 * 7 fed H ned us &3 % 4 £4 Ls « w@ iE @ o 7% ay om i a a x 2 ed ty we at co S Gog GD Row om £ BG 8 zB FP oy UE 'oe 42 Bog tw ym sf pp a Od OR ga i" & o ices 3 3 @ 8 aoe gs So @& £ 8 g gS 5 8 8 mn o i eB MB ow oy @ » 8 "ob QO a & eo 8 oy wm DU i fey are we @ §edg . a $B oe « hee, ea on eat ce Cs mS in red " in & oo o Ee is oa 43 3 eo fed oh : 4 2 ck a on e cok | me ah ary J o Fs) CG ret c ont * oa 4 iG a jos ty « ered ad Hy a 43 fe a on $i 5 i ah Lye { hod in re " wt a " 6 'cae ' td ad wD. 2 Fa uy o <3 om , a " ' as vs sod i eee ait , fe, a a ed * ong pet 1a os ay u | 3 <4 G & 24 " ae a4 74 iD " a s 3 6 $4 2 B 8 8 » 8 @ 8 5S 2 9 2 B a &s ae i ae 2 2 eae , t A 4 « he ry o 3 "ej Qn - GQ ibs - fs oe i 5 ® = by 5 os 2 2, 5 rd a : 1G tS a * u g tt . & uy "
os ° oO 7 og ae 6 8 s 8 % & @ os Lh, oo a a Ch ce £ on org shh a At ba od 3 ra ts © xf 43 rt £ m3 in wf Oy : a 12 "4 a F os wi ry @ had 44 nf 4h "rg 4 af 4 vd " iy ae ae a eo * un a 5B oe ow & '3 OG a cs 3 : BE r a) c a tre A egg 3 ' + fo is Bo ' So ve ; c a 2 4 ba i mo og # o oo UU Fi ® , . eo i 03, we x a cas , c wa " a wed 4 ot ae bs : Bd * "i Ca &y, : "eh "es a Bes wm i Font rt , ; 4 ti oO @ ad rot % a vat gt «. iB y - at - nt ood So "74 i vet M o wv Bg so ood # Bo Dg oo & 8 © % vd 4 Bott OD ee a ' as fs te md vet ( Sa "5 in ri 5 - i 4 B % Oo 7 7 . ie a 35 ' rt iy ey cS Boy ed in M4 3 Sg eek Boe 66 GOR OG oS 7 U8 5 OO 8 rs 0 Oo & a @ A 5 OC yt UU £ 3 gw ' RS t an u eh % ; : J ot rs wt 4 a 5 hd es
4 - w as GY} wa " ® ae ch ed ie At wo as G $3 yo » «© ny @ 8s tw - 2 &§ : a 3 P GUAR 5 eh ti 43 ¢ "a pe i is] La a hea w oh o 43 a a 44 $4 O iia) ryt 1 4 ed Q , ow uy * o f BS 3 a a By ra . co } & a a ed " wo 4 o «~ § 8 & ane Ho GQ 43 rw) 3 % @ uy Eat oat i 3 4 hs at a z o eed Ey (3 1 : e 3 " hed wT in Bo ® ey my * 42 2 ay He Pa Q a o ws wy 4 4 id g om OM 4 eB 8 3 oA ee ei 4 1 4 % gy $87 £3 & a" $4 s 4 2 @ ag 4 ' 3 i gi ee "ns rs @ 44 eh e kg we " end rca D o t 3 @ 6 vd Dp ; 3 Ei as 3 iu 42 "«s te Q, ® Oo on § i © S td D ' uw @ ah @ Pe @ w 4 mt feo ce c 42 ed a 'e " Ng C3 oy sed 4 ww a a id a "4 a vi u 3 : & Asi a a ae % G kt ~r4 , % "ct "f 4 . ver y vet ; P ie i a 2 st) a es 4 oO @ a a we wD od ® ra Be <t QO | um w c "3 m ot v3 i Ch oe AS 4 oO qe 44 o kn @ M iG / rs Hi a Y a vi oe Go CoN bs % a a # oy 4 ot ue , my 4 ms oo £ 3 Xu 5 is 4 4 Q ce go + ww a "ok 2 6 @ 0 o "3 nee "$7 need 3 a ce ert iS) wa ed " ~ fet 96 Ww . ; wed . © oa oy wd i bd Db &. as td ch bo os 4 rv a ed 3 = z ie & a wo 7 & Fs ws % " wo 8 ae w bd a w be wy m, ' te ee 2 a ee Qo @ oO ge @ 4 £ ; rf © 2 U8 a +h at 4d om oS 4 4 eA sed . as i @ , ces "3 vet a oy uy ned cs ay Leg i ry KS 4 ub wo G , 4 C " a i Booed OG ' «i Q eM eso G@ oe tn i D Ed ° mS 42 4 mo o ~ a oo st is a o ws o ae oH 4 uo neg Ee i a 8 a 8 i Mm, 4 ia 3.4 a) wt "ed % " aw a c $25 iS OD. a , gt : aod 4 a ae oe @ j ; » & bead a ws a) oy 4 a ng (i mt 3 oO ort : ; e fs , £ vet ' a w & 4 I e o YH a a Ss & wy «=S wt ; @ ae = C4. . iy a Aad i 5 ot ro fot ee ~ te BF my rig a ge ® e > fo" ia 3 "4 9) ey O th rea) a AG ES o as ge ' a i} 4 es ed @ $4 la e an 4A he 43 a a a . ra or so % G Q ao Cy i at O po 2 wt : ae a ' sb Cy f+ ted te 7 ed ug "i 3 4 aed #3 a he coat . : a G 3 Pod Wed ¢ ay i i wm 4p w i n : rt is x - A o a Qo w «=~ i aa i * af ft c Pi a »o © & OPA iD 4 aU 8 oe * 42 > og © KS E m c tC a og ao ra a ek "s "et on re a , sed Hi fe G ices wot aed : o bi " oh c a @ ID v @ 6 i eet ws 0 a (> w 4 re ms @ ba fad G - oe 4 a 42 2 a 3 i ¢ ooo @ 4 e © ae oo Oo ® an a © ao, m4 Be a GS po 2 2g 8 Bo © w 8 & D 2g o B 43 a ms ie @ a o wt Dy O Se 8 . Yet pak ey ~ bey, * aa er . 3 ry " Y wr4 fad he wd rt oy ci o D 7] ig, ey ® 3 et ' greed od veed 43 ty @ a rs 4 ed oe 4 oO 3 Pe 6 wm va a © "4 e i aS " 4 va iB oy i re a vm ay 0 xt a wi Y oy ord oS ; se a oy renee @ a a on « eof i YF oe ' oy H os 4 = 6 & th. oS ua w cot a GOD "i © 3 7, & 2 e SOU i nr' o & " - " tei he Med An bs has 3 a D @ xe ba wef i 4 ot 43 a vert O aed os to is a @ bo ma "4 t a cong £ + ees eteettnrerervecreneesgy wets terol 8 aS iy 2 ; 8 s 4 a fas "ey 2 : : 2 r G mg a th rea By ry QO "4 ua x 44 ad a AS €4 w ed geod a eh ts ow o hog 4d rp ed fo G cM mG a "4 ved se é "5 4 @ by in en O a by A ved { B Coy werd OB ¢ ma 4) +91 43 SS wv gt $1 mn % a ard © w ord Aa wn "t ra 7 Li ries & it 5 + 4 ke bed i aed 3 @ i - ; & wed 2 ra 4d y :
& B "tas 5 0 UE » @ o ii , €@° § G & : : 4 . an Me SS s an ed non €. iB 42 Be é "| g EOS DB p 8 § 4 8 4a g Bo» © ge 4 5 f " i " G ce re a a 5 ; Peet
- 8 Bm Bos SG Sf ret Oe Be we " i f . bass . 3 on 3 ae . is 42 ats 4 ni os Pe 4 % vet rsh be ms ie oa a et apd cy 3 5 o et 6H -% & SoD Cs uf Uf DO po G '6 oR © > "yd . ~ a & 1 3 A ae 3 q o } fs Wy ~ o *y th <2 ' . Cs ot @ on wo @ ' Q c g) Oy 4 3 CG me w Ae 4 a - yh t ad a § a mo a i dd 'S 4 ad 3 w ot t4 if Px we te te fd a, ' be td -
4 a S ky * ® o 0 "4 3 Dp ie «3 2 a ued " wd ies Pe) i : wed we a ki Q hs 5 srg 165 2s o ws, " wv wo aa : 4 5 cL 4 4 te 4 JS in 3 as : ; nt ng a baby Oy ing 43 3 44 @ cS o i & Sa, i Ey a a Be O wy L . Sh 44 ae it ry * erd 4 % Cx 4 - oe 3 Zt : st i in eu Nf " hod ae seg "4 oO 4 " be AG v a " rd o | vel het 4 4 3 D '3 fy nef "3 : u DB : i i 4 is 13 = i a ve oo aw ' cod 4 i f on mh < . ie $4 et 63 y "8 g te % oO 4 & 4 CG "4 ; ed 5 kG 8 +
e) " o " ay ny nan a ct q a Dy Ad x =o iM ~ a mt x4 ee wD xd - S ot wed wt ay ce rh i> ve a in a 3 be eh wu a G ~ Gg ~F &B . Bo Hoo o oe. ht iad , acne} Sa. > - 4 ve bi 3 cho te a mt . . be 33 it ra e 6 sh a 2 3 at tw ' ae G 3 4 3 : me oa G we ; "4 " on iy a i Q c tra S 43 qt oy " a 5 a mt 4 w se aa @ iy orf o" as 3 © a re to rt A Ag a re) a Bb oh i co 6 go S yo Fo tt" cB Oo % ®B a i x e a Ss © es - ret a a #2. c Shs a co) e ba bss th «nt & a4 o " c bas iB is ae nS ved o % fa G 43 in a a3 - 2 oO 4 fe) re % ted "% hy sf a "tN a eG } . $3 . open 43 th ns 3 5 6s, :
£ t cal Me, a '6 ' oo 3 ; ' " wt ay a ne: a & O ai a a j HA y w a a a A "@ x3 3 4 & re @ o % fet ; i B oy "3 3 se t ae 4 64 2 a o saad zs DY & 9) ~ "rl og Gg F g Bo orf et ke Tn i o & @ wm ¢ oe wor 8 BOD B oS a e o a "3 8 ' : Reo ee He ai ie) ci © c on 0 mt ca ct Db 2 os sy :
3 a 6 oo & SG Go4 G&G «wa BD O ¢. A gp F SAR one we $e * 43 hg @ @ w 3 } aa 3) 3 G3 ES i a ed ci @ vo O ce) 6 SS tf "ed 44 4 ie aa b> wy oh ey a e a G a $4 a3) yo x we * 4 2 ond I . oP en et Sod * 3 ost m © Ky o o 4 cat] 4720 poh 35;2
a 2 x £ Se 7 rh 2O E t men erd i det cl 2 OANG. 2223/2015 & BMG fF 4 Sg OS Bo EH ge m Hoan % oO § ee "+ 2 & B B & £ A ct 3 ; a mr 2 & re 33 Co re) i 3 i ies ot a a 4d bes a . Ae we ot : od ee co a as ae M4 ext 5 - hed uD. : oO rs ay ao) « 2B B SG oe Bw mw oy 8 2 ow o 5S © 2 eo riod iG wy 2 Bots & = cd D 4 Gi 3 6 8 UR a & a a Ga ch veh a os f 3 cc ad 16) 4 4 Sa 7 bet Or 2 a ss 4 a Sos ae wy 7 « - toy Bet 6 © 8 pp Be GH Bows so Ss 4d ra 6 em oS &% oo OQ es m4 (%, o got Fy 90 - "ee + aS * 3 fet we Ch * ~ re j a 2 ub SH wG a 1.3 Se a £ st 3 i & % ? Gh @ <3 chy i rc 4+ a : me wu rea Co 44 Ic 5 m4 sae 3-3 oy bea . md 3 . ore ; os 3 a ee 3 bg e U3 ot Abed thos ay rd 4) ea on i "4 3 <O nr: ; 2 a fs O BOF Po og "4 c v } wi w & : oo ft e bead cn ; Soom on ge Ow » OG mg io eo oO Be AOS "4 Son F © Sf & G8 D4 $4 8 ve "od oh is w stot wD - et 3) ond on iv (85 o et wz ke wt , % " a " & vot "| t cs) ro iv {3 1) a. rs 3 63 a ee <r S ow & cd & io lO 6 GC ' ry wy fet ed = hy c wy Ra ge ai e ~ @ a 3. Sd SG w « ih i a a a i. CE Os wo Be "et a ea a i Do 4 : by 4 o ; cs a , Beh ba 4 7 3 ig gi a i wy G ao G i Od hy fe y Gu @ S 2 3 ut Neat a B "rd iz ce ; te o er a te ted acd te u3 4 ie $3 wet y qe Q a b3 Csi os "
a 4 rf @ en S Go fs Sa p ; vs a 5 fa ' a "
4 &S ot 4 "3 Oy ong ie r en in a Eee @ Et Bed ie @ 2 e Oe Com ee, G who wa iH 2 Oo eB 5 2 = ° a \ i ah on G
-
bE 2 Na! G x Yk aa * Oo wee ot $i S g fat an 44 0h;
C7) i ie he O m 42 : oe 2, e is oS - et . % wo a 4 wp 3 5 rt a Os 2 "5 i ® #8 « Om gy eo 6 eo & n o . Bo 3 45 geod : ct vA it 5 co wrt @ a 1 . ps e Q A tye ce og fom Co " MH ow A go om 6 , goa 6 & e a 6 a 6 MP wy SS Bed Bow os "Eka ag ty De ok ~ } wd fe my ¢ d : : . ' , im BS rn u we $$ § FB 8 °° £ Bw 8B ee rr S % BD a @ OM OO 8 Go & oO ee fhe * i 43 gerd is co Ww iw > ® re > wn oe Cy et or a3 By x yD ea Qs 0 fs a ss ., on a in Aa 4 3 Of a i bd Q i a) @ a ot -4 4 ENE S ww GB re ef te booed a & Go Fo od Gi Oo i"
he ~ LM oS g o Nw.
a a ven eeeceeeeerceenss pee ne ear intie ERE EE ie tne AN LEE EEE Ok GANG.222/2013 16 rf ey a zy srt a od QO s A 19 4 of ie 4.06.20 t Ne 3 rt D ret we, my ng ot as vt ans f 2B ma An ea "
Fre Den te Nat i LEMevea.
mm 3 x ved agt Ld OlZ.
ye Os cGs.s @ AS 43 i3.
$b G oy ad th wy ke era $a be ' 2 mtent 3 ot ha Ese iB eee ne Ld. we wet Thy & oy sed ances, Patel reported in ZL ci Eee @ @ qe ms w@ c w teed Qs st &f ' wed "4 ni me : '4 . * * @ h wn 2 & 4 3 * er vet a oe & rca See we &S a % | % ort u% Md a} rf a £ 4 a r gf i Sek i & ted cf rm; Ss oe i di © a % o 2 4 <4 op . gt "oy 2 4 v . 44 p ats nn, £3 ne ca ae ey + & © ea So it ta mn = * ~ my as G 2 gs o % . J Y uy "rd ey ta GS 4 " 2 os Ch ad 4 g try 4 $4 ot fed nN ia a AY we ad Ee o a | 3 $ & KY cy ie Gi we} 7 wh 3 { Z mm . 7 weed ' wed o wy beg " " eA 5 8 Roa 9 HY ® Mi ts a e an:
= ky ¥ 4 "xg 2 3 roi ' G eg gy rw hy ? rod im @ 5 ie ' & rd vay @ * fy, a fy Ft ai a a BS " @ 8 GB @© | A HB Hoy BO a ke Ss m ¢ mo 7 z id oy Med Gh o G a 0 a 0 : thet 6 4) 8 G $ ; eet 4a wt wD ® m wy ae (3 : St Oo ral Qo @ 3 Fs ay a a a G @ 5 +4 s eo OE 5 2 & yoo wg G8 8 ee
4 w w a é ed 8 1 3 a GB eI Gg = Ls my + S4 vd cs & nf dg ge pee 7 6 ge gs . g :
' pa eA & '| Qo a a rie) Any , * 4 o aS a 8 9 8S 8 we oS eo Roe foo 6 ao « 4 wo 3 b 9 BO boy 8 s a gs m8 4 ; ~ C 3 1 } thet oe " 4 & e ie oe fe a % 4 med ; % rs a 5 a @ i G a ct re 3 me iD m os e i x3 G Sonne uw &a v wy :
ay ay D o} ; od os Fr iG vel : wed «% op i $4 3 rhea Oy hs % tb MB ty mm g 4a 8 oO mM 3 HS g BS ge Sy , 3 8 S 2 my 4 "ry ad af wee] ' cA? ; ad at "eh, ty i Go « 3 wD ; yD a " - C3 : a ey Bm a 9 & bb F oO Mg ee Q oe © és & (a = vo Sto a t3 vey - 4a o ae thy Be qt =x w a 65 of te ri gg ge G8 5 Ra wort 8 mB BR ~ Go. saa OQ. = Bes g mo & 4) tH M4 St @ 3 as @ i ns, a Bb A be m4 a q % 1 india and others Vs. & wm iy m a f x op i @ ae ity co i 6 [Ul moO By Bs . at 4d n rd hs nb O o a + ci 44 Se (4 Eo B se 4 a a H 3 Pe a t , 4 ws WD Ww . i i 5 wee ard 44 8 , 44 B Ww Fo» & 3 2) Ra A x 41 ® , SC 4 6G UB Ul UR US = ~~ B Bet oe w gS cS ei a (G rr et nt - & G ® a ay 4 w ce rot See ty vt o a Ew a v4 we g ws '¢ a Ot ee ag Go p # %§ & ss e 4 s 3 B vA 4 mi 3 ; $l ~ 2m Bs, 4 ie os 0 6 Og 6, advi p 6 2031 rT. ¥, ean
7. Aen 3 oY Fp or ant ULLAL POPE PEEP PL IED EDOET ee) se annntvese Y. sssentntnstnpesinre pnsinemmmnpcnstagrin a ded ty 4 on a 8 e R et $22 g 4 is 3g " & . a # a eS 8 * nm gS @ % an s ms - ie e 9 * eh <4 TS * on z "4 v4 R ° % , "4 2» < o oo J ei o wy ths a qy Pe * S * weed ae G 0 mo 6 i a 3 ie a my 5 Be @ © x 3 a rc Mi cs} » "
oy mo ea a Bo 8 geez 2 5 « g 4 4 x me 43 D da Cs ort R om, 9 . - of Y a . uy pte red ree, w fa 3 a ' t , ¢ io) ot an we! c 4h 3 ' 7 & Ne iD a "A uy 4 @ c sy O on es i s Oo ors 3 ss % G " ao 2 yo 8 & 3 Bos 5 a % Q, on fe g ai QD, % 3 a wy Ing oy eo % » 5 is 43 ue a a a) o % ved i gs a "s i 4 e, S Ee TS 44 "rf aw $2 oN tb. a & by aE the wo Oty es we a Pa ss a . 6 & Pa r bea a a m \ % ' te . * i ens _* Dp uy 4s Ho A Bg @ G mG a o eg 3S TOD , tn Ae oot RG Mi fa $4 od ip @ Ly x og Ww & SE » '3 ona iY o 3 & & wo 8 & a GO A iG o rt o i ' t - "4 @ +t i cod Bas a i 4 8 g os ioe Saad oe ~ ' ay te ® a $3 0% & D &@ OD cr ty + be ib a org NS St Ee OE UE er YOY % O a a 4 4S ee 1 & st 2 D> co 4 2 hey wf oy, % . 43 bd ~ ; os 4 s cs o a ty oO. 3 es a ss yy aon 43 4d a ge o, 'ot # a ft . ot ied ; + os 4s ty ™ cl % is eo fe ts 6 " us See ' f :
'3 2 vs = MS AS eo w $4 5 me ort Ad an o 4 oy © qa i+ 0 Sy me Ry; a4 eas x o3] a ee ty 4 wed i og " } i 7 eet eS Dp ea ns ° a . m Fe te ws
5 ws * ce "inf 4 .
aot ALD &% & 5 eet s . 2 eS uy . oe ee i oi] aS ie a 2 @ i f os +s @ Q uy ww 4S H @D > n Z fay o. 44 % a a 4 ® a ui : Ss oy 4 "ga S 5 7 «
- G i Au © u : wz .
, 3 g is 3) cee bes neanconnedrereetineds oD ames DANO, 22272013 srl ped
- % wi . ee 4 hg iy 42 as « ws & 4, G43 i tb Nee.
"
g % oy aes .
2y 5 ey a thy vs nS Ad ad HH is 26 ot 2 ¢ co 73 & LA red roy wv a ¥ a 4 $i 3 sy "rh Py bs oy wet oS ft ms, S OG Ba ed oy a é& ns a AD Ry ~ aos : as id wy a z 8 sed vas S$ @ 4 KG ot Ke ad seg "
' a ad ae oa oy os i S3 Ct :
be % % fe a as f 4d qn & hg oS "4 B bs in 63, el wret 3 a bow & fe aa ot Gy oe 6X apy :
3 ts & ts ba 2 p 43 . At ony ie Bes 45 35 Mo w ani, ay on Sef wy sexy vod 43 SD red re} ted Oh "teen Whee sly . .
a 'rem danetesegtannindesicnsedtoneeneecen os 2 D sebneooetcaeenete ee onevetii -- : y S @ tb wD hed qd ' Ga n & i My uy A. iD Bef bs & s ao © @ @ BD g 6 o. ws © cs He oO 4 ca] % "- ig 43 ha a be on i BO Me OH 3 3 ¢ ks a 43 a x cg 42 rf fa cs "f a bt g "ct a " o G ve a & ay © 3 ia) MA u ts ey oo Se et nas a Rad > " 4 a C ae Lt " = 9 tm 8 S Bb 8 ae wy a GC @ 9 fF 4 wR BB aw BG C3 on ¢ oa a 4a sed oe at ao wh td i © g id wy ca a a sy vet vs te . ved uy % oo : B G 0 . i OK bi m4 tt i td 3 a « my DB yw @ % Rg ed & @ PB soe 3 % ied a SB gy & a en ct C3 wy G w oS oa ws a as " G6 2B 6 F @ ane "4 43 "sf "4 re 5 y . 4 " ved '6 or % a 4 re 4 t i GO G6 6BlUR gs 8 ¢ ® oa o 4 Kh a oe ~ my , s ' ' e: g oe ot : is ka a Hy Fay rf A 4 g , vse . me . . st 4 a O + a i "ed , i ee 8 a a an ' w ae By, €® sg So BO, my op Bog ss % i ia Go iG @ Ys be gS i} "
t 5 > WV rd Ms ¢ 4 fe Q 3 : ' 3 3) hog xt " ms ors se oe ms + tha By 3 : 3 4 oT w CG oO Ad Sy Mo Sow tS By en g a @ ony a pot et : 3 reed Da ae "hes hat Se ad % a cS se} a i or * Fes @ CG $3 me 5 id " oh i) ka es @ $ ' » t f + G ior * wy (Supra), S = others Vs. ; On Ud o & & 8 : G rd = us ih Cy a 3 re ka m™ rot 2 ced 07 O oh, cD 13 3 4 O Ww ip we C 5 An "sp 4 ' .
: : : ' t a ay ° e a ra fhe i oe Cork et @ Ef ge eed u i a 3 a 4 + a 2 43 2 $a nC on AL "4 ved be "4 ~ : 7 G ny "oe by a Sg wens * Lol OAND.222/2013 a cf on raed 4 5 5 8 ", ed i "rf * Oa $4 + 44 fea bet " Be » om, os 'a : oo Oo sh ba ay a m4 oO a oF Pad 3 a 4 ran ' fA qh . iA w on mi vu $2 3 a és 4 " a or a co . i hep be 7 a % . Aw © My Pret q e. oe ot ook . ify on ti he > bp * G&S B Bb 8S » 5&6 BP Ge wo» BY Oo 8 ® . 3 a " st Fs bee Ly Ch, ood cn a $a ce ts oy cd ry "s on oa, oa rs) a a art te? ty ® og 2 ci RS BS ff «a @ 4 GH te me % oY dod gg uo 6 a: re ® Gag we ee ee Me 5. j 4 gh Oo $2 Gc = ws wat fa 4 ' a4 , , i Gs o © © mg B&B B Oo ° Pop 5 8 ~ € es . is @ 43 ed Q w & ris) ves a Oy "? a 6 B ed 5 fs aa ca) me pool " 8 ved rm Ge ved " ol oD ged & G &, wet o a ® oy 4 et . c a : . Hy 6 et mC Dog @ we EG Ga te 5 a cg 54 a) 8 a By ve " g 4 4 Bef a @ ne; v4 3 38s % ue GQ Saad AG et read o fh Fs wD 4 ra] ot Dy ah us a "3 Dy Ke 6 By ees sy re if Oo fF 4 © Bef 3 woOUY a 4 [ed : ~, y , f C A ; 4 2 ry us 4A se @ res cy ig be 43 o gh "rd oO Fray hd C, ved s y a "3 BE 5 ra ot % a 2 + wd "
V r 6; : ae ' vet fa a y te os w ' of :
x x g e 0 at "t rte & 2 vet @ | "a 3 cs eG wv ts ota wt aed Bom Os @ B 7 2 oO ' ma gg Ci a © 8% boa # » Gael i ay tn | os we hy ay a i o Q & a 5 ty tf 1G fk oy a * & a oy gS G a be a ee th Be $f rf me, ae hg i a ty ey ag rm ta 43 5) 3 Sf 44 &.K. S.N. Marula (supra;
& a kK a iN o me 2 i ' we i 8 a £ - ot ib i. 3 O6.01.2 " i ( us oo ug : \ i . ; s, cb so od kK a wt « rf be t ost ' A 43 v fa, "4 © ual ee i} Me ced ed Dy on Pa a & Bo Ok o ba eo 2 * Q 42 4 of a Ry g ~ Bs gt 5 = os © 3 oy a iw £3 orf 5 wt vO) ' Bs & Qo ~. G a G ra se ay a oO Oy as a ng FT re t ' ra os 5 4 2 es H : Ei a E7 ee 3 w 3 : "ed 4 4, 5 Og G DD, va wv ne G, a) Fea os) y G AS as ard 4 & a a a we O Me EE et OO 2 Bw OU UU UU Cee NNR CPE OL AEEELT 24 O4NG.222/2013
23. Accordingly, the O.8. is disposed of + -- sont o - mt ty. Phe a Few ox + Farm a Tha a 2M UNS ArGresaeigo Lerms re Y3 Ye ee ot nn ot KEL RPL Sfh 2b IS Ra order 28 £2 COSTS.
of (R.N.) Singh) (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai) Member (J} Member: (A}