Gujarat High Court
FIRST APPEAL/872/2010 on 19 April, 2010
Author: Bhagwati Prasad
Bench: Bhagwati Prasad
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK ����� P? ;XSssV??i-\?J`? ?(? lNC???????g? ?
?1H???p??> lo? ?SD??%??d"??Y?fD:???K????z?8??v/T E??C???W( ???1 C]?a*?a?U??I??: !\???3?Hy { ?%X???d9 ? 4 ?L13h???n??[O%? �n-9 ?z'/.2??K??? aj??JEG ????? ?|a?p$S@?p0? U?c ?~>6'tU?&FdF"? V:?*}"?z ,9?b=???? z m?? ??&hK?Z?.Y?(p?i???A??? ??>?}=E >y}?G?y??.??vR@?4We ??v�${? ? ?s ?? >B'U?Z?>P?9* ????�VgV6i?>?L?9wS??? ? KR?K' ?fIe ???;???Z?? ?u;?]w????? m?} r??>? ??O;?B ?? ?? 9?? g????B ??6?}???6?R??? %?z ? ?? ??% ? ? 5?ImR?H?? ?/??`?}?{RR?bF??|F ?/]P/2?l?; ??@jB??5???"hG ???F=?? $E?\&?L8 u+??????#??kn??gvc?? < ? ?WK?;?h?3y? ?O >B Y?0?}??)??EBt?%tZ. ?}Q w??{?????B~ ?kV?}?j?]?`N???0?!? ?? ???m??{??EN???_? i ?M? &???mtT?}???w?????; ?# ????XA?G?S=ut?P????l?? ?.?}hN????n @?7="@?R ? %H? ???P??;m?.A ?>? ?,??J RA EB?8 I?%U???9 !?9# 4$P?? ? ??E? ? e?=AsB>?R???;??? UN??-?K?? ? ?? ^?da??c> ?8?|? sz"rv?W?PK y ;?? ��0&��PK � � � P?<������������ ���styles.xml?ZK??6 ??W *?SeI?z??f]?i? H?"?�?? m??D???/? ?2%??!? ????7?!??~g?h? '4{p???p ?d? ???[w???? ]?I??# ) ??!?| ?3~?? N,D~?y4? S??&??{?SNP? ? a? ?? Z *0Z?- 1? DK�8???B?v??n???b??????{KY?*[? ~?t?#?py? ??B 'X?{?8? 6?
?, ? ?
??-"?Z ???j ?m?0Fl80 Q?z ?p?4??D?y? ?? ?0tP? T? G-? 3?R:???? ?C???v? ? ?p ?$??H?? \??tqFe?62;p?&?? R8?a ?T?Q??? ??W"?` ??72???5??5JIrxp~D9?? ??O#? Y;??2ohHMy%h??2w?3P ~c4EY ? w?? ??'V?)?"???? ?} l????Z?:Y??0dR?8? ?#???=?? t? ??,?,?-?t 2FGx????KFiiF?<&!w 8g?eL (`?t??1??? ? w???? ? $ c?8? x?0?]?? *? ?!_?p?h|p3??J?B+ g? ???v?? ?v?? T?!?$?Ty?EI # S?V??P? ?I(?D fr??F0=a?X??J? ? v?iC?F ? [p?B??nV?B?P([? ?& '_a?`"Of KP?)? ?p? BZd?A|>? ? ?#? f?ZT+l?'u?? $OI[5????B?GYgFo@?~ xy ^?? 7? ??3?J? @?C?[?K?SpA? W6 ?? ??f/? &? J`&Q? Z`H?'??@ ?v?tk??j?qt?? ?('B?vM????u?=? ?wR?l|7??9V$ m??#+n?F ?/V? oqR?? r�r?j???]? ? ??)?? hj ????y?5???fzU??\?5??????*k?We? ??S??i?R?Q?9??lM6 S ???????-J ?*{GM]i??Tc??{??J?3_\??
??? ???3?|Z] l4?IK?ZS???s????4?. ??[ J? v D9(5 >?7?r?OgmsY7sSU?? Eg??7??x ??5?? M?UK?Z8?6? ?B ?B?R?,??5i?Xz ???Uk{??-????????M????l ??RU(~6?}*�? ???;?? :?????? PK ?? ?? ��?&��PK ����� P? OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 mohd 2010-04-22T15:30:44 1 PT1S PK � � � P?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?zgXS??"=?"?JG??�A P?t?&Mz'??& ? ??N ?."?H?"??{???s?? .B???y T?????w_\? R???"?a??,3??qIW5? uH?]e ?|W? ?-S ??1dz??vBPB]?f??n?^ ?z???? .?1F=?? ? ? ??C? d?D??p? ??;?MP?< ?! ??YV)-L ? a3F D??D?}?,Y??=?wc??
0# ????[t???w?D?N?}R??.uP?f 7??? ??
&??f6y??0?%e?i?_*M?K?]4*M? ?4??q?A?^vW?]?$ 4?\? 7 >??i?iX<} ?%|? ?�??* ???;????,?????% ?o??8??? ?T?/?>J?9-c1g??Z ?~k?Z??e ??y,�??.? X??^?Jj=?%+?|?? "Or?4 ?_li V? ??
{??? [?Z?fX?S? S?# ???8?| ?X}' ? j??W? ??[?^??B???)????&? 72?y|? ?? ??% 7?? ???<) ?? ? ??)b?????Da? ? e??u9?[ 3?w??^??=XKsP ?yJ???t ?? ?$+ ? ??<)J?oR???? ?.?V???t5?s?%??N?L ?W ??l ?l??Y?^fJ&? $< ?#v? ?x?r ???{??[??? I??L?/E]?C??z,g???mG????? T ?"??'?:q??t???H?h&?U???"??|??d?Oy??o??s}Z?Z*X?C?????ww?}l?H{?v X? $?;??Z?O???KqM? `?? &? >??;)Ju?? R}O?4 0g?q?_} ?w ?? E?m d???? #8?h???&??Z?j O? ???8? r???Pw:?>G? y:?]~'? Z?n :?W2?*??.?KG;?3???D? ??U?[| 5"P8{ ?^????W U ?6 ? ?!:m 6??k [?f???T??I????7 V?6 p????h9? ?q9 �F ?d?+P?!j??l??? ???d?" Qj-?h?W??
????? ?r? }Qo?=????|6 ?�??n??hq???? ?
??
`? ? ???]h ?a"?? ????8??Lt?y?? t?>????1?%t?<5 ??g?? ?9;C?b??Xo?X\f?YZ@ ??W?}B????1?i???TI?^I@?e>s?R????r ?? ?m???N??? ?ti????�??{?? ?!? #??-~=?????B?-?=?b?J?;6?~A? 5???? 8 ??? ??+??2??{R? ??Q C[??Ng???yy7?
d"g??Gbo i -:?y>s{?>?^t??E + \r?? ??2 ?i?u?W_{v?E5V? y? 3e?R?!c?) ??? ?GT? ? ?'? ? ??]n?Ow?S&0?6?xj5 R??d?6|z?>B?Lb??U??'??b?>??Z^????AH ?V??D&?l]?? F??I? ?O ?7?F(?+b???2?? u b.??@?tz?W?~ ??B ?? 1???@Yb(?z?3? `?V? ???d??_? ~ ?'K$??x? mR{B(|2\G??eM?8? ? @ ???~x?HG?f?? ?ye???< ?!?? \??hz/????/{ k ??>F?S? ?bR?P,l?? ???:??0?? ? ?E?\ ??k? ?????)???:-?,>~? ?o?T??Mr??g??) ????PpC? .p ????? y?P x?l r???,??}) ???a ?\?]Z j?Bs???? ? ?+??T.??[?? v?????R? ??z?? ??6k? ?? ?k?n?c??7? ?%?17??? ??? ??S?? ??QDh?mp?e ?;??jZ n3m?????wA? ??-? k?e {x?+??Q??XG /??@?+?L???ST?%??`? c???? k?Q ?b?Ej??? ?????aLC?A?@s[ d???%?a?na.?N.3H?T7? 's%??V?? ?&m??P g?|?CdE f???['?|?n? y?U ??6e?j?$1???7?lO)b???yG? ? v??? ? ?*?~)?V/??/:Oxs?kp???L~?#?,Z}?{??O c??? ?[T ?7^Y* ? ?V?? f???A?M{?cX???? &jn~~????b??h??? ? >?e?"??J?H???*4K???A?w ?5?&?.7???L?^?E[X?? "Xs??L>?+ ~u??K????%??&???? 1?$? ?E?+;_ +?5Nt???? ? �iNV??????I ???t?! ~????f? b?\5??lY>?'?c ?? ??Vc? ??=?b?d?p???? ?< ?G 2 ??'R??5?o??u9?w??!a???.y6????|?C[=?_?^?{&Z?? F;?!? ??<2P?(my???b ? p?s _)L ????#??b ?F??NS?;>????K???9??3YxA_?????v?A+??R?(q?M ?v?+: ??V?ti?DS/ IJ?c@? ?PYJ?I??+3]?i??? M?1?*??? p ?
?? ? ? ?8??? y ? ??3 ?? ?T+???| z?d?-6???:????jL?}??R?3 ? ;7?W? ~?Jn}?G? ?Q????????#U6 3? ?
???(? ?B? ???4K?cZ?M%i?'?9 ????4"b ??\????2?7???? ??�??2 h???? ?? ??5??_?? &M?? y?? m??-??I#? i?j9?wc:~? ?R? ???%?|??Ft?_? ? ?8?mr?=?d???P u)8???N c?71CB?C ???c?(*!N???Sd?s??:V.?t???FN t&???$?D??Z???6 ?W4??e??? T??m??t?
??!:+_+eJ?2U ??Fw???j?X??n?4Fp?&k??~?$$rx uOg? ????)!?aR ????u*?u?? ??wzh|++ .Cz?}%X ??K??2?? ?' ???# _=??7??p ??P? M???k???1h??0?^\?g?qO?T?h???'?(o?1?? ?}?\z??z?? ?u??=? 6H? @???WmU?[??. m W??,I???*?|+?y?K??w6?' ??$????n? ?I?Ln?)&??& 3??e ?BQ????v?9?" ? ?$7?0.x? I?{?K???0??
W3?(m? ht??Z LKB?????n ???n\ $???:d?? ? ?3F?-??M?? ?Mb??Mw???b???c?. 5?z?T? ??u?yPf????c???p?? ??
�
-?0?? ???6??? t? lO??`??O$ ?L#?3??7H??Fs;"8P??-U?t1�??2??,????8 ?? ? Pg?? $??w{?YZ(d9?? ?d????MM?? z??n? Y????L?Q#?Wr?$,$/?n~?5?p {??W C}4 ?7? ? }b ?Q7 ??oz*7+? ? ?�???F3?? ?8??%R????Q i? _????I ?????f????zcOn&??{??D??z?^??? ?
1??a?��cCl?4e? ?A?? e???4 5r"??SI?;) ???P2 ??? ?:??~i\Dg}??@v??cl=?4? >??48?? ???y?pF!???W?,?o?zSZ??????L:?fBx?c?@???? ??\B?'fi? ? ? ?6?G?
??? ?+? Xx ,???{+2?sE?F???V? WZtG??8ht?^?? ??(.?,? ???? ??Lc? ? +?F?# ? ^?}?,?? ???? s?9? ????\?Q?? ;Zl???N/3?z?p? k U{????
?P7m?M?"
= 8f??b ?T}?C??j????\???? s?P?? ??t?G ??|J!?/??V?????>kj??3???l??a[??U?? ???Y?o+?? ?v?=e,"? ? ??h ??] ?rIa???c%???? y[8[??Z?f??????
?_?q5 h?Dh?'a"A73???? ?v?a?? ??i?nFv35? ??hZ ?:$?%3???0??6Q?B ???G?R??Gk?,? M?\vF?,V _? ??G ? ?n??B)????OL???O? ??i .95?? WhE ???O?R5E?A? ? E??/MV?w?b.??B&]a? ?e?u {?X???}_?~?0??p??? ? ?V??q?T??E ??? ?? T?,??"??9? ? '?= t ? ?)??c%???-?~?bU?J?$Z?M ?'t??lCt????V?u? O}???t?4N? (?6? Da? :??4! ?5??mvr?? P4? T???F g~[o???)U ?7x=???,?? 2 ?00?> ?'?=?????+0 j?1?^Qi6??? a?
??c~??{N ??r??7 ? ??? ^ �2??=yS?D �????E??&??I?4* ? P? ~5G??K?WM?? ??I?
?}\3??,2????`?A?l "??w.??8yy PN???\43o?~? ?5?;?U& ?dl??H ?3uJ@t?= &n u??%??1 ?}?g?T } U???@?~k ??? ?? J"?? ?0??G a?? ?? ?O?t?x{Z?*?A???8?*]Uu?[? ? ????= ?|?}Hw? ?[?b_?9?0' ? ?=?? ??`ZoJ+q?q??E? T,B?0AW????.? 6?= 9 ??9???=/? ?I?n ? ?X?? ?�?wf?
?#W:\h???|?`?[ 1H. ???A?h3?b???q?/? ???e? ??? ?? ?? ?4_# 5??q'?B??? & ?&??$ C|?*3?????S???g�q??????o; H ???'?~|t x?? ?x ??PK ? E?9!�� #��PK � � � P?<������������ ���settings.xml?YMs?8 ??H??? 2 R S? ???@ ???M?
x#?.I ??% * ?! ? ??nu???\[???+H ???_*? ?�?HLo??Q?t?}k?u??I ?U?A2 ?K ??%?^ ?*}|?t???e?A?_}A9-?*?J9??e/,y$^6? ?Wy][m4 e?t?4@1?? `W??? ??????$?Mo??zu?k ??)xv?R?an??? lNv?F?????{???_? ?F {?'z ?Hh?Y?5 ???]???0?y%??z1??(3????? ? ? K??�~?Dj????}rVmg??_B??~ n? PK ?Tw?? ��G ��PK � � � P?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ????.?g!v?? ?mz?? c?Z i ?W????X?0 s????|?/ B'?C??=:/?N X?:3??e?6?S?&?w???j????Q%?,??)??f???r ?fhJ??2a;"; 0?7?? ??l P?J?T ?&w?? s)b:ZL??V?LP?5?u?}?y ? N :? *j?b+h?0`pS?uent!??}e? x T?p??2"( ? [?
u? ?L???7?S??d??
??(??LR%??5?F?UK?] ? ? !?: ?) >?????w?VH? ?u,???V ?Top