Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Sandeep S Roy vs M/O Defence on 22 October, 2019
OA Nos, 748/2014, 763/2016,
TOd2016, F7L/2018,
Lo FBE/2016, 5952015
and 7792014.
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.748/2014, 763/2016,
7164/2016. 71/2016. 786/2016, 5395/2018 and 79/2014
Dated this Wednesday, the 22nd day of Octeber, 2019
CORAM: R.VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER (A)
b3
ed
R.N.SINGH, MEMBER (J)
OA No.748/2014
Milind Rameshrao Kalbande
Aged about 31 years,
S/o Shri Ramesh Nathuji Kalbande
Ro Or. No. 15/22, Type-Tl, Range Estate,
Khadki, Pune-411 020.
Ms. Hemangi Sachin Shelar,
Aged about 27 years,
Wo Shri Sachin Vilas Shelar,
R'o Flat No.D 11, Genesh Agen Soc.
Dapoli, Pune-411 01g.
Ms. Deepali Masnih Kakade,
Aged about 30 vears,
Wo Shri Manish Arun KRakade,
R/o Survey no.43, Plot No1/2/3/4,
Opp. Kakade Terrace, Warje
Matlawadi, Pune-411 058.
Vikas Dilip Ingale,
Aged about 29 years,
S/o Dilip Waman Ingale,
R/o Qtr.No.4/24 Type-l, Range Hills
Estate, Khadki, Pune-4il 020.
Nitin Shashikant Khatrnar, _
Aged about 33 years,
S/o Shashikant Varnan Khairmar,
R/o 6/6 Type-Il, Range Hills Estate,
10.
3
Khadki, Pone-41] G20.
Kiran Hanmantasa Burbure,
Aged about 30 years,
s'o Hanmantasa Sangappa Burbure,
R'o 13/8 H Type Range Hills,
Khadki, Pume-4 11 020.
ws
fs, Ashrita Singh,
Aged about 27-vears,
Dio Ramesh Singh,
R'o E-32, Jarra] Residency,
Phase-Il, Privadarshini Nagar,
Old Sangvi, Pune-411 027,
Ms. Vinadini Sandeep Jagtap
Aged about 27 years,
Wo Sandeep Jagtap,
R'o Sr No L1O/T1/1 Gaurinandan,
Plot No.2, Mitranagar Colony,
Baner, Mahlunge Road, Pune-411 045.
Ms. Sovita Sairam Berwal,
Aged about 26 years, |
Wo Sitaram Tamsukh Berwal,
Rio Or. No. 28/8, Type-H,
arige Hills, PuneO4]1 020.
Ms. Chythannya R. Ramankulath
Aged about 27 years,
Dio Remakrishnan Ramankulath
R'o Gr. No.64/1/, Type-l, Range Hulls,
Pune-411 O20.
Mrs. Sheetal Rahul Pundlik,
Aged about 27 years,
Wo Rahal Vikas Pandiik,
Ro Flat No.A-7, Apurva Apartment,
Tilak Road, Pune-411 030,
All are employed as Mechanist'DBQ in Ammunition Factory,
Khadki.
~ Applicants.
aS
toa
tv
as
OA Nos. 748/2014, 763/2016,
764/2016, T7U2016,
haga
nd
CK
os
Ra
os
feet
x
ia
WO
wD
re
oS
pow,
us
and 7779/2014
Versus
Union of India, through the Secretary.
Ministry of Defence Production,
South Block, New Delhi-T 10011,
The Chairman,
Crdnance Factory Board,
10-A, Shaheed Khudiram Bose Road,
Kolkata ~ 706 001.
Teh Senior General Manager,
Ammunition Factory,
Khadki, Pune-411 003.
The Principal Director,
Ordnance Factory Institute of
Leaming, Ordnance Factory,
Ambernath. ~ Respondents.
OA No. 763/2016
Kiran Hanmantasa Burbure
Aged about 32 years,
R/a Quarter No. 15/08, H Type,
Range Hills, Khadks,
Pune-411 020. -~ Applicant.
Versus
The Union of India, Through the Secretary,
Ministry of Defence Production, South Block,
New Defhi 110 011.
The Chairman, Ordnance Factories Board,
Ayudh Bhawan, 10-A Shaheed Khudiram Base Road,
Kolkata 700 001.
The Senior General Manager,
Ammunition Factory, Khadki,
Pune-411 003.
the Principal Director
Ordnance Factory Institute of Learning,
Ambarnath 421 502.
oS
penned
be
bo
The Director General
All India Counsel for Technical Edueatian,
7* Floor Chandra Lok Building,
Fanpath, New Delhi- 116 001,
The Director,
Maharashtra State Board of Technical Education,
Government of Polytechnic Bull iding,
4® Floor, 49,
Kherwadi, Bandra (East),
Mumbai. $00 OS], ~Respendents,
OA No.764/2016
Ms. Hemangi Sachin Shelar
Aged about 29 years,
Wo Shri Sachin Vilas Shelar :
Ria Flat No.D 11, Ganesh A. Angan
Society, Dapodi, Pane-4 11 012.
Ms. Vi incdini Sandeep Jagtap
Aged about 27 years,
W/o Sandeep Jagtap,
Ra Sr No iO' Gaurinandan,
Plot No.2, Mitranagar Colony,
Baner, Mahlon ge Road, Pune-411 045,
Mrs. Sheetal Rahul Pundlik
Aged about 29 years,
W/o Rahul Vikas Pundalik
Va Flat No.A-7, Apurva Apartment,
Tilak Road, Pane-411 030, ~ Applicants.
Versus
Onion of India, Through the Se noretary,
Ministry of Defence Production, South Block,
New Delhi 1100171.
The Chairman, Ordnance Fac ctory Board,
AYUSH BHAVAN ; .
10-A, SK Base Road, Kolkata 700 001.
CLLTLLALLLAL TALIA LLU TOLUCA
had
fa
oa
b
bed
OA Nos. 7438/2014, 753/20 16,
3/2016, 77/2018,
86/2016, $95/2015
and 779/2014
ta
a
The Senior General Manager, Ammunition Factory,
Khadki, Pune 411 003.
The Principal Director,
Ordnance Factory Institute of Lea ming,
Arabamath 421 $02.
~The EMrector General
All India Counsel for Technical Education,
7° Floor Chandra Lok Building,
Janpath, New Delhi-110001,
The Director,
Maharashtra State board of Technical Education,
Government Polytechnic Building, .
4° Floor, 49, Kherwadi,
Bandra (Ea st) }
Mumbai-400 031. - Respondents.
OA No.7 71/2016
Sandeep Swapan Roy
Age-31 vears,
Réa: 402, Vainganga Apt,
Shivalik Nagar,
B-Cabin Road,
Arbarnath (E)-421501.
Jitesh Bhaiyalal Gupta
Age: 31 years
Shiv Krupa Kirana Store,
Buwapada Bhaskar Nagar Road,
Ambarnath (W)-42 1505.
Ashwin S. Tagtap,
Age: 30 year
Add: 503/9 Felton Panvelkar
Classic, Morival,
Ambarnath (BE) 421501.
- Applicants.
Mh
Cea
ee
thi
And
GA Nos. 7488/2014, 7463/2016,
FO4/2016, TIL2O16,
6 786/2016, 5952015
and 779/20) 4
Versus
Union of India, Through the Secretary,
Ministry of Defence Production, South Block,
New Delhi 1160 011.
The Chairman, Ordnance Factory Board,
AYUDH BHAVAN,
10-A, S.A. Bose Road, Kolkata 700 001.
The General Manager,
Ordnance Factory Machine Tool
Prototype Factory,
Ambarnath- 421 502,
The Director General
AU India Counsel for Technical Education,
7" Floor Chandra Lok Building,
Janpath, New Delhi-110 001.
The Director,
Maharashtra State Board of Technical Education,
Government of Polytechnic Building,
4" Flaor, 49, Kherwadi,
Bandra (East),
Mumbai-400 O51. . __ » Respoendents.
OA No. 7862016
Mr. Ashish Pundalik Deore
Age 28 years, Occ. Presently
Working as 'Technician in Factory
of Senior General Manager,
Ammunition Factory,
Kirkee, Pune.
Residing at Kand Patil Nagar No.5,
Dehu Alandi Road,
Dehu Gaon, Pune-412 109,
Shri Nair Sunil Kamar Jairarn
Age 43 years, Occ. Presently
Working as Technician in Factory of
Senior General Manager Ammunition
COLE
LLL LOCOCO OOOO
Ns
Sand
&,.
bo
OA Nos. 748/ 2014, 763;
PO4/2016, 77
F86/2616, §
an.
3/2016,
71/2016,
95/201
79/201
9/2¢
sed
res
a
Su LA
s
7
ah
ne
Factory, Kirk Ree, Pune,
Residing at Type 13/10,
Range Hill Estate,
Kirkee, Pune-411 003. ~ Applicants.
Versus
Union of India, Secretary,
Ministry of Defence (Production),
New Delhi 110 011,
The Chairman/Director General
Ordnance Factory Board,
Yodhya Bhavan,
10-A, S.K.Bose Road, Calcutta 700 601,
The Senior General Manager, Ammunition Factory,
Kirkee, Pune 411.003,
Principal Directior,
Ordnance Factory Institution of
Learning, Ambarnath 421 $02. ~ Respondents.
OA No.595/2015
Rupesh S/o Ashok Bauskar,
Aged-28 years, Occ. Working as
Machinist (Skilled) at Ordnance
Factory Varangaon, R/o,
Bhairawnath Wada, Po. Thorgavan,
Tah: Raver, Dist. Jalgaon-425501.
Vilas S/o Ananda Mahajan,
Aged: 36 years, Occ. Working as
High Skilled-HT at Ordnance Factory
farangaon, R/o.Qtr. No.183 A,
Type-Ti0M), Ordnance Factory,
Estate Varangaon, Tah. Bhusawal,
Dist-Jalgaon. ~ Applicants.
Versus _
The Union of India, Through the Secretary,
ba
KD
A
Appl
GA Nos. 748/201 4, 763/2018,
7H4/201 6, TIUQ016,
FR6/2016, SO8/3018
Cx
and 79/2014
Ministry of Defence (Production), South Block,
New Delhi 110 O11.
The Chstirman/Director General
Ordnance Factory Board, Ayudha Bhavan,
1O-A, Saheed Khudiram Bose Road, Kolkata 700 001
The General Manager,
Ordnance Factory Varangaor .
Tah. Bhusawal, DistJa slonon-425 308,
~ Respondents.
OA No.779/2014
Anup Ravindranath Meshram,
Aged about 4] years,
working in the post of FED Fr-A
in Ordnance Factory Bhandara.
Gajendra Singh Rurve etl,
Aged about 36 year
working In the post ot Fireman in
Ordnance Factory Bhandara.
Ravikant Vasantrao Rukade,
Aged about 35 years,
working inthe post of UDC in
Ordnance Factory Bhandara.
Ravikant Chaturbhuj Ahinwar,
Aged about 29 years,
working in the post of Foreman in
Ordnance Factory Bhandara.
sumedh Domai Meshrarn.
Aged about 23 years,
Working in the post of Fireman in
Ordnance Factory Bhandara.
cant No.] to 5, C/o, Shri Anup R. Meshram,
R/O, Qr.No.3/1, Type-Il, Jawahamagar, O.P. Bhandar
Yah & District Bhandara 441 906,
EEE ld
S
3
f
aw
nN
a
Sal
a
¥
wT
*
*.
ue
os
" : : : oO
Qo oop 0 O O Be ord Bard Oo fh 4
3 rt Ret Shot " a Bed fod ny
eed a4
]
f2016,
QO
0
af
lf
95,
79
we tS red , ey 4d we ved
é :
=
fmt -
5 " " " . 5 uy
5 3 OS, 2 i 'y 5 fi @ 6 x
wie ee "ey 5 Qo ws na wl w dG vot Mo oa cf
Se Be Be eu if ce 3 ue 4D eg Fs
ee SD os oa 8 & 5 3 a wm OO va Oo a O a
SSR % ne a 4 Ow 2 8 " 38 Bog
' ™ t " ~-- de o th "a a nh " on OX)
' , ; ct coo Ow a Y
Od a 4 se Set " oe whe ad a
ca C4 of i on 1 i . "3 '6 Oo o or a my gt wy
oD FE oe oy) Qos ws B 5° g . "dH nO ™ 3
"ef NT Et. OS ret Peet hs ; DD a wet tse m4 On = .
mor aS Go & ag, OF Sw 2g GC 9 gs
% te ey i SOM et "rm ; ct si
ne m3 oy ~ iT Boe mY baa ae
ee mm a os oD et Ooty. be eo} fi 4 wet &
- cnt 6 oS {9 z ant. ' ere - ¢ da _ a a
wt wy Cd t edo ng ea, cy reed a rots Cs Si . CG re) ke Ct Oo
wo , a * wee o oo rth * Ba
: 1s» oo) $ I WO ran) ed os ,
Bn? ae Som 6 od 2 . a 6 OD ; DO go Se gor
ne os Se ne anne oy ad oe ge
Bost oy 24 2 mo og & Gs @ Set o wo me ot
ORD ro wes £4 - hee ce eek Ef eo uh 1 i " r i .
j Fon > 4 ' soe f Ae hae x * in oe n i
" o aon f & moot EB 6 HOT Gal Shed ey Oto
mo oe OO OS ou OG ry 2 G & OG B oH Bs "6 o
AA eS ,? g 28 & alg 8
2 " 3 cSt xy be ' aye ~
roo. 4 Bp eo 8 oe Bo rag 1 Se
a Gr "a eed Boy CO & oO A pe
woe et & eS oS | ~ oh 0 oH 4d
Beo OF 8B Po ES tg ma eof . ~ 2B
ret 99 SO a a ae GT OE a
$; qn, cs fiaad re " is . t Fy "4
5 rd wont faba a vey ef ot " n . we "tt Q ea nd st
fbed * » ot ee f verd Sb ngs set 3.3 iD voted 423. «sh a ved : { x5 oon
Sop Oa we OM SG wD OM Be a,
Wo oe cs ae i Nd a te Ab td le EN
a o> a W ag os fh is Fs) D, ee Sy 3 th op wen AF we ory vor hd
~ B fi Cy pty ys ved m2 rd ot 0G wt 30 it
"tte tod ah Mot Bg 4 md rd "i fr obo
q oe my a fa * se, Go mt - . get
Sabet My moor 5 greek oa t is } "
fate A o> Si oe Hoos Q, ra Oh a+ ¢ 0
bed et ey bee bw £0) . :
se, CE Se 1G Me ved Ch 8
Appearances
a
3
A
Oo o et 3 Oo a et Qt
i : ed wy ay AS
l,
7
wee
3
an
lard
f
Me
wy
iy
fe
OQ.
h
OA Nos. 748/20 14, 763/2016,
764/ P2016, Pils 2016,
LO 7786/2016, 5935/2015
and 79/2014
COMMON ORAL ORDER
Per: R.Vijavkumar, Member (A} "a. To allow the application.
b. This Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to quash and set aside the impugned orders dated 18.09.2014 and O8.10.2014 wherem the Respondents denied Applicants to appear for the LOCE. | c. This Hon'ble Tribimal be please to direct the Respondents to allow the Applicants to appear for the LDCE examination to be held from 20.12.2014 to 23.12.2014 and direct Respondent No.4 to issue the Admit Cards for appearing LDCE to be conducted by Respondent No.4.
d. This Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to direct the Respondents to consider the App is sants for promotion to the Grade of Chargeman (T) if they qualify In the LDCE examination 2014-15 "cond iced for the purpose with all consequential benefits.
&, This Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to grant ad- interim relief in terms of prayer clause (c) supra, fr Any other or further orders may be granted in the interest of justice.
Cost of the applecation be awarded in favour of the Applicants."
ae : ats NE ny y ory {hye < wt essert af OF Nol ?7oyfs0l4d have obtain Per man dope em ot mee Rom ety Bey vey ty OY Fy os Phese applications have been file ae Oey ey Oo " ae he Reiveast nd on acy. ee x section Lg ot Ene Scministrativ GA Ps Y O/2014 apy i¢ and 55, os ths a ce ded bie sp} wet is wo red uy 4 ed 5 cs oe oc st ax {ow shed bd B ot $8) iD @ ot vod 87 w & "ct ot Led $4 @ "« a4 ee rad Wy a "ef bf oy wy etek uy a 4.3 «cd 64 red ES 2 iss) C3 red eed be co e@ oubse me At rn te i of as) a fs w 6 ef, 1 us ft " vy is! w 40 ashe SS ved OG Sh oe © 44 om a8) : a x wh $4 43 ie) wz 4 0 4 C ~ wy ' : & i rt pe hy 5.4 -4 : 4) wy ) Ad a A on' wf 4.3 O O com} a wD 4 are} ered Gy 4 "v4 iy ce QO Ye on, G se is ae hea £ reef oC c "3 es it & gp ae oO fF 8 & & ch Ga rs 4 4a set uy bed ey = i ce & 4 3 a ce a hee o O 43 4 4 2 $. 4 vr ? . ce oy £3 ae 4 > bt 4 {) so Co bea £3 v oh s C3 we Lay i wd , . go "a YB cord wes os 4 w wy "Th re 5 Sa Oa Cc i im 4 #4 Xa ii) wed 4 2, . ord a @ i 3 44 eed ro i - ~ " ao 0 vg a SS Hea be ba a3 z " vO 3 oo es $2 doe 6 o a og oO 4 Oo ge DU y @ 8 woe Ma - F ; ie = a a o wl 54 7 "
@ wy eg a £2, ig ry ' a5 3 ! 13 Zz 7 a EY Req » ify uy - A .
ii ts Woy D 4G ? 3 yo BE a 12 to Gy Ooo) UG @ Bt ah OES i a * . ay 4 Y 5 ' * cA a > €} -
; ted te ED we gS ad a 4 yy y iso oh ioe v4 oe Aa ma a . ed $4 Ls 2D 4.3 ' 4 a G b~} ' re 5 f4 C4 ie es - a es + aw oa oa eft bd bs i 4 td ' 0 eG tf a ss oS i 1 Es 3 8 @w By a S53 me oe oS eh Og a BD gy @ Qh bs sy G tr oa a" ved m " ' $ 5 Sed Gu oF ie ng .
A wt i. ' % Oo me orf 4. ot 4 ny aa Heh oD est ag 5 ° a4 a4 - et cs 43 w wd y wry ; a "tH ° vi a :
@ 7 by, © ay ny aa u " eG ' bs, i Sa " {3 G ys ve wy $3 vee ra ba i. hy . et ioe wa a @ a abe $d Ad uy et £ | v mgs nob - gr ane ae L "Nt ers SS SS x * ox 3 ' a ty Nt wy ai t fe = * Ari a wr Lae Nae Un a c oO Xe yd MW r a 4 Qh r ~ SS a 3 Ne "
ab n fey ca he he & W e ~, o 5 - of n ~ . e | * Se mM F 8 7, Bo ny who ed OG, id + gh 6 4 ES 0 om a 3 we ify GQ o a a Fant Nw 4 a! 1 eae pec y a ;
gS Pans "ge G a a = at 2 sent wv oi ijt ant $3 $3 ed en} a ie yD "| ch or a Md s 6 & 4 wy a 0h, ids wy . ty 44 oO 4 ut O ed i) Oo verd wy "ct Lo ved ' os wy © ig se i oH 43 Sef cy WA te Oe a O, T +} tt sd be ct ML oor OO we <f KG a an ( gs .
oS <5 © a ot Th cag GC a} ms " ¢ wy On at i Fy z ip Pky om Oe & C ts Oe o v % 5 mre boy 54 G Ci 4 Aa SS Pe ot a +t eo Go »p & & a A G. Gp @ & S$ QO Se Bd goo BO oe Be 8 é Pom my m4 os a ue Mt oa ao oo 43M sed w i ne cy x - by ra 6 v Y 4 p fs ; i ef ry 4 C gto ord "
6 re) tee "3 & web a 5 +3 4) 0 ; a oe pos a - "+ fy . } $e a a } 3 O 43 3 iD i wet tn 3 ard "ey r . de ed £2 Ch nt i wD An {it got m ci i ref «rt 3 os ce; a is} whe oS £3, hed ke bre co bei O 6 cs re un a 44 Shy " a. @ od vel Ba rat al wed $.4 ; Em an ee Ye Ais 7 w ca / 4B ct "eh a o # a v yO my Hog i mG w ao M4 Gorey G bf a - 3 Oo om a | 3 ag c os t o 6 Ce od g © BB @ an u a fe 4 o ane rt © oT pS 4 o m 6 a ms 3 % : My nh ae a mm Dp Ms ri ka sed b6 oe 'oO & ~ 7 43 rd 43 rcs} © ; en nf vs 4c sof us -
$3 if cy @ Ra os ee a <P Lee et 8 ct 43 " e ws @ ee ~ if} oi co Q a i . id . Q gi fo i it ; "4 vod 3 i ¢
- . rt 43 a e i © i rf et ba is 3 Oo go tel 3 oom od i Go oy 4 4 Me a Be ' it wu . 6 a 4 4 G o) 5 a © np ES mB OO G i . gh "a 4 om ko oon a 3 a a4 Q i) . ' A or A oy a . si < 5 " rt par ue oD 4 c % ie : mt wy Phy ved it ny det bed {3 a vet ai Ae ahd + as iQ " &. at UO iv = i! ~ oom - he o ae D rs 4 Oy i A 3 9 S85 bw g 8 | B 8 » & 8g PF ~8 8 8 8 o 8 ¢ e 7 9 3g 8 he nd : . mn, t vee ad otee i ved a ct ria : a iw cc) wd og 4 @ 9 g v fF 4 Son awed f wher Me op ' on gs gt 4 ay Ww o . . 4d 42 _ 2 re ey 'ei 13 Oo, $4 5 a weed et ain} Pa} - xy @ ve 5 orf im a iy i G a ft Ue 4 . ° i "i $23 th pay -, oo"
fe sed 6 UR ~ wi ao Qo m . & 2 rear od rd ba eet wate 4 o / 4 @ "5 a , the os MS a ct © 3 0 cs o hd 4 al oS 43 a G 65 ao v toy 40 ant fed o + Bs) 3 oe w "4 . 5 wy as ¢" Th mm Cc iB sy ;
"4 ary O ¢ a a od a . a $3 6 a c "
te ia a atk set ae 3 v7 i Mad "4 3 i 3 o
- we ey 4 ha 5 La 4 e ves iv 4 on Cy od oi 9 ns "4 i 5 as} tb he "4 ocd e ' a Ato YQ w o vb a ° oe = +5 4.3 ys oO i cee 42 4 pre od ce w "st "a * ha QD G '3 $$ os Bb 8 6 poo . 2 Bb & « nr QS het et 4 4 C yy u wy iy t 3 be ate .
- (3 A ' ao) cx if} GQ ; ty : fa of 43 a O ao 43 3 a @ ue cy te! . ce a id " : kd wind 4 4 @ ez ne sw a e ~ ry a bet ved t 4 o - 4 "cf a ) £6 oF eu Oo o ii Ms $4 os La a Q © 6 c ag 43 ae $ a "3 SOY ADS pe wa . G hg th 2 a oF} a @ ey a rf oH fog a @ ® werk wont OTS rd by c} @ a a 83 ha KS i Lt wef c CO a o e ce Em ost iM ma 3) pp , sy 13 w "3 ty 3 oy . b Oa a er | en 4 Oo fo 43 ct o poe ON os fa et bE ap nog rm to iy By vod 5 w c a Voor Wy re on : "A Oo bai ks mt wD Ad C4 x gS o a wed os . "4 fe Ton Brew ot bat 4) ee G2, ai gree} £3 wD "x et cs i try ab u ' af wo so i a be ic G3 ved aa Pe aa wd a 3 ef pont gran bi 2 . ae) 5 w aa "4 c aa cs ae C5 +s aon ve ae A os > ct a oO i 2 rm OM 43 3 SoS w id 43 me BR te ae i oo <F 90 Le oye xd i LA ee O " } ty 1) ' =F OS Ps a go © Oe & %S a i ad , C a i Pm + ui os ee Oo 4 " 2) re v . m Bw vs wi 1 wg oo ns . gt og M 3 S © bom po og 8 at Oo. @ Hog 8 2 8 8 ' Ort 4 2 o @ @ |G @ ' GC Sf &@ Mg h Gs '4 is ti co Sy 5 wo Pa és i Gi a ao @ - fy © 9) um m3 re 4) 5 "4 ie 43 "4 N yt ha :
rt ae @ "rd '4 * vet @ i C nee , ud i} 4 wy ' or . 0 ge Bd ded ry i A C
4 n ~ ert * me r3 ro vd 2 i c 3 "t 2 Bg tt OT gg ' © a us it rie xt 4 "4 ea 4 a ore ' Ch hn ia) a if Me ™ - 43 4 4 : ' % wo 3 " Ke a © 4 ; Cf ig i $4 $3 43 vet 43 4. 3 ee Wa rs ci ayerk i é 3 3 ' a 4 © a oy A me sed z 44 n a La ore ro sf Oo . its 3 oq "es od he tig ' a a I ard ie en G 43 ee O - {3 om . oO QO LO us os jt ip ' ip O $ ae at a (x3 "4 Cy vu fe 4 4 3 D i, 4 god , 3 ( 4 zy Hi aa bs oO o : oD ot % 3 >» & SB BS C 3 : x 7 be & @ @ @ A & Gh O 3] a ei > ~~ ua AS ° ae wn i @ 4 iG 5S) $4 . is Mort 6g aC ee 3 fi S " ord rd os BH he . oF ot th "4 3) oa Pel cy a 3 3 od * + #5 rd beg ' fed Go Yq 44 44 mg 4) fa "vt a co wo ih @ fe 5 4 t 56) ie G os weet 3 + ce 7 ed oe hy te . css oh o oo on a 5 eat a Gs e) i? O 3 peed ts 4 B06 ms iB ; Mo o rs O Ee 2 43 swt ace oO Fad in os wy - : a} rf a a sn t Sg : ; hed , 0 D ce & te fA a a £4 ro bs 4 hes ee wD rt iy 's) Oo {> wy wD 1G QO 4 a4 a re Oy ; te t = s € and 7779/2014 yO oy 2 at a. wr bo Ma OR 3 ma uf} 45 Qo trative) « ins 2 (R.Vij aykumar) Member (Adm Member (Judicial) (R.N.Singh)