Karnataka High Court
C R Shivananda vs H.C. Gurusiddappa on 30 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
Datezd this i;.ha 30*: day 95 SepE€mbar_.-- V.
PRESENT ;
THE H(T}N'BLE MR. JUSTECE ii: K{§'i:%£2§;R '
AN'u -- V *
$33 ;«mN*BLE MR. &§:s91*E1?r;__:r: méé' GQWDA.
£2§:cU;j;:§§T;VJ?.:;R35i* A:é§$.9;:;' ?_~?{j '6a--*;'*=' of 2001 §{E1GE§§Q%:§. '¥:;i":;s,*3.f' ;{1:§':f5:é;:;_;_r;;:_g. % $200 1 in REA Ne, 5&3? Q§=:;_foVo; V' ._ V' §E'§'%?€EE,',E'~E: " "
: 3%: :4: Sfiiééasizégzggéa v;S%;§$'€'§ ':2?';£:;T§_'jg-5'Vé;?f;i.?..7'i:% ' A' V -
SEQ 'é«:*;';.s: if} ..§{z;€§:*a"§pz1 _ §%§:s:;§:§<:::: as' :2: is; .:??;:}ad V ' §%:::::<i'::::;:z;,:jV;:::mi ' ' L2" * é " -- .Es'%3s::*:z3%:2a§*::«:é $z:.::::z:ja ' ' A §?%§§<t.§é§:r:;sf;§;¥:.§2§:* _§%is:.g.;*i:=;:s%.:*%:sf§ Ssaifiiijg '~i??.a§;'e;=;€n'ét-é $3.-' E33 Fmsidezzé §;°'§..:'§i Ev? §'=¢§a>z§§eg;,?g:::s:i:'c':: WA§3§si§3.;f:%$ :;8}; Sri € §§a.m.af:?2, Adveaaie} EX EN THE meg COURT 012* mmmaragm Ail' ~ V. K "§%E"'3=a " "'§"'§'2s ;1;;2€:?.>; C{}%,.Ei.""¥;. §}?'"::: :':':;'.'::%;e9 :3: 'E35 53 jua'.§;:'21er'2{. and $€i.£l€'d. Cm :'.m'.erim scheme. 11. . 2:Iz'r»:><?ic2d. {hat §,h<3 czpp€£{anI': be rem<Jv(.>.{T£ ~f'r{3-:33 -- .' V _p0$f;I':z'oz1 u>I'n'c."1 he (.){.'C{£}}f(3d as {$16 MaIf'1 czrm' U"££:I"' hig; u:orsi'1i;;> :'r1:.a..;=f;J{':é*V56;); ._Ii:;I1a:s " VV a:'Qzz.<3ci. 0:": I)e."1cz{/" Q!' the <2;3,r2a>l'fL':I'2 £,::'.Af.}1A>:"'iz {'::T1*zie>_ C.;>;.z.:j1" "
had rm jliI'iSCz',Z'(.T{.I'.()f'i i"O r".2>:.r_'{2:)z..' e:' '~.}1§r:2V v;.z.i;;m _{J{f}:5*{1.i()?'1 as izsstzci Q,' the 2'0 u}f'2::Tr:*:}'1V"T:":V'£;> §'i'§z.(i. b€?€i'.!'£ CZpp()fI'E{{;'d 53$!' .§i'z.e wiiii' jSz,:,:gzr'}'ii',"'A '§'f§i5 <?<)z'2{.«3r'2Z"i{)z'2 is q1.:1'.:.e i.:.:':Mi¢%.r:2§i--,';{ei§,V :2 .<:;cfzez";2c> for Elw acir_':1iz7is1"zf:;:ii§§:'z--, igi, :?vfICz'f:~ii:g:--:?;5fz;> {.'rusz". iI'2,UOl1.!i..!'i§; "i«1:1:{'>-- c:s;;_r3p(;:in;{'}'2'2<;>«z'zIi" «fa/f_____}iz"z.:.sfee2s or n'1cma_gé1"S.._ t.'?;e*-';1{?c':iz:I:fi;.._b()ii.:'td' Er) 'secrz.zre pz3rs(>r1s i,L.?}'101"}'E ~:.r Vgzss Tile f35l(.'f ihcL;i" (he i:L.:arfz:iI'1.:g.§'."i3:§e §LI)})€;if,ClI'1I'. shouZ.d. sz.ze:tCeed
- - - -- -hi?-if: £53959: '?_1L(vJZ§';§"?€;«'i.§iv1'+'i?f';7"§§.'i.S(f?"E:?E'€{>FZ Qf' Elm' C{'}?_.£?"'E', or ' ' ' ' ' ' "
g3z*z?<?ZE,.;gEé Qf :"'h.z2 <:?(mciuCt', of {.319 1' {zg3;3§3ZZc2:%'2€";» AE'g€.>E'i':": I}:§f,f1:)ree .:1.n.(§ >';im:s3 {he a'e<2§"?2. qg" {Fm-> §;%<>'sV.i€"{Iz2'z§:*z$ in §n.§iz'::; ?'2{1:z,:z;> 325552' ifzeszf, £795 ' ._his;":i7{m:i'z:<fiz ffte? 5zp_;3s;>Z£a22§. Ems :s*f2<3s..m'2, f'2.§;2"::~saa>§;"
V«:z%§'§zi.j§§;z*".{§'2'é§ ;:>0;<;2'§'z"<m ::.:i'zi:,;:§'2 5'26 <:w::<:":,.z;22'a::;. szmii §"§:.8.=f.r ;L<>z*::§:c;%;j%;2;; gait,-,;U§ 5;§,.z:?32'_j'f:"zcz'i;':g:
Jmfim 95* RELEGEGEES 'f'REfSf2"; §9AE',?'§A} .£§PPEALLz%2¥T Vs. Tfi SR1'. BISESHWfiR 333., :'€%g><'>::"§s3:{.% in fiifi §§?;£ SC 295?: haw; :,:.:z'T:<%§m':58
gram: wc.2sj"1:J:' {fies benc.jl"iI"' <1'2_}'" ("he ;)u.bI:':::" 01' £1 sec.;{.:£;w/ji cgf zfzi. z'.c., an i.Z.?'I€7zSC(;'I'Z'{2i!1&'::§ Class, Q?' j_%;s'f---- i3er'2.<;§fi'.{. Qi' I?3ze,> gro:m'.€e-2 fnmsegj' G!" L/'(Jr §:s.~vc:»Za"L_.i":3 t':_'}I: {1:~i;cerI'(1frze(i inci.i.:.>fdu.aZs. An. i'!"':'.i"'€7.?;A£}?"i{/.'&}*.(\f'f:'2I-1 (111145 535;. cimwrl from 3119 u.s<1gc.> 51:263. C:_asz{r;r':'2 -. qfim " ' z'nS!'fiz..z{:'.<m. or _f'I°c;sm i.i'i«';% *-z'_z'2oc1_'.:';= '~._:'.z'% Vz.t:)'2é'_cf} a{ p:':);3<3r*i::.e$ }'2«:.:1,.=e,> been dcci"£:',, i.z:z'i:h a$;'- aiuso 535%:-:>:" es i'(;:.I;3 E :' fwd (rim: {.1335 I.{1;'t.c:':3,9;
36' "1'1'm1'eI'<}3'<;>., if i";'it:' {>1"'1g_;:Vié?1 :=<3'§ t:§:.e"»M'i:§:1. :z2'1k1'1(>w'1.1_. Elbe 1'1is1,<::1"y of é.1j1-_¢€§>_1'(>pc§:*1;y {3f"':1.E'1€"'«lf§r'§'1.;1.*:,i,'a:";<:i 11'12'u'm.ez' how it has br::€:aT: c1_§;:2.:1i'v .4_x--a.-Tg1.£1.';V-- byQi1jéié..,£_1:i1駧_'>.§1£hi » will <}§'t,e1'1 af§'<31'{% an a.:'1swm.". to 'E116'-"::.i;v_ V'1ic'3§*;__ w_1;_1::%'é,15:G:" that IV§u1.é[ a pr1'.VaE.€r in s31..i 1.1.: i ie in 2&1" ;-.1 p Lib} E if €~7;1.€§'{3;:ez'i';1£%;1i". :3:-*7 y an V. _ :3? 3;; E13. .i_-E:":.<;¥'.§.:>2:t:rE<:;;:t{.>:.:mi <3"? *:E'm:.st-;a=r éegai <*;:,7:'1<.7@§}'£.s, WW2? "j§i'§E%'x7{5T._"'fE.{_} '~--£:§:":<:§ 2::TiV"":L:i:és;wté:" it; %};'::€ 3::=::si:':'§.:~:-;« '=,i.'§.'.'i';:iTfh 2"iI'§$§E §'<}§: ' ;<::T:%'z": :si'<E:_-ii" ' "M a';:'.i%':'u';T 22g;;';:a=%22E.s.s.
;?;::2::%:%;% :set% j 38. z E2"; {>z'<.'§€%:r° Ea: 2'2:'2sés1>i:m* 's.'i::é% ;'318_.:;2":é;?zin2.1§:>£i.:§; <3? éhfs.-: séguii ..V"1.1é'E{,Vft'?I: S€%<*'ié{m. 92 <>§'1:.hr;> {3{}§E.:?. ii. is :'1€:<::-3ss;u.'};' 3.0 §0<;§<; 2.32.5 '£:¥:::= Q;
{SO O1.fzcr purp(.>5.;e. re§;a.r'(;_? bemg had {0 spz':'iz Q/" Iliw {.:r'us:: and. it's a;);J£i.c:'(.:?J{Zi%:':;; Q)"- f V {T0 T7 'JTZO7 I )3 Ii I'f}(}S 83 I 0?"
{cl} LU-}1{,'.!'(j' I.f'1e? (>r'z'gz'.n.cz.i ;')zz1",r;<_;~;~a:£;f$;----zTrj2 uf_§f%(>{(,% E3'f* ;'z1V _f)C1.I'?", z.uez"«:'e laid cimzsn fig; r{;=§]'e;2:"c>ni.=2: ":~.o E:fLr'i c:'u"c:a. z.a>}"1z'C!"2 I.¥'1e?I2 z,z;.::zsf_ £3111. V!';,.o:s' "sz'z2.(r駻c*:>:z $5351. i.{J £959, (2 zmz'z.'fo:* 3:acrfi:-v;;é'fz'v;r)<>se?ssi13:' b {9} 'i.:.3i'"zc%z"€ {he <':rigimfzl ;3;;_;'f';;..:§;saa:s.j. §f"i. Z.i..':"'Z*'.L3E{;' <};f?i2'2 para". I'2.{u,-e. ;<4.>z_'41'1"{:e. I'.11'T'.é?Li:}_¥:f..'{.?f'ff;f £.(;i'.::E. d<'3z.i;=r1.,« { 1'} br-39:1 (1€i¢*cg:4t1I(%ig;»' ;9h'>_t::Z(ié(ti j"0r by s<}I1'1<3r ;:,*'2'<;;'c1Ii1§;, {fir _ . . ' ' = I(z'.:'j. " (:'."'i-'§iV£'>'u:"?L'I'V.:.'~».§{V$'~ b¢«'z'r1g:,: uselc-::;;s or ?'":.amg]'z.:E '=I_.<i> "§v?jii:;: _<?E§~.x':j1%%é2.infry. or ~~..C€,'(lSE?i"§. :0 £38. in 5:15:52 <.1*§2:3r:'£{;:.b§c>. :3?" 53:13' ~ <.:'£?£{s{-sari in :',2§"2§j :';=§'.f'z.:2.>z' §..i..'={".E§_.j £0 ;3;*"<i}vI'{:§:% £2 5;2.:.z'{.{.2E53§@ .:z.:'1;{'§ mg-?:.?'7.c>§§ <3}?
e§_;:§%;§?<:%§'§s,:e2 J z:;<.:z'z:.§; {.3226 g3:'e;::;3{%§"§"§; (:.::{z:'§(':.I%;':E:¢:= 5:3,; 5,.'-:':"£"'?:,.2g% s:};"'§?'1.;=i'.> .?*a§z;g{::2:;§ :?:2e:':':::; §":5,e:g'3. I5} §.§2.g.> :~:g.';:'z':"z. :é;".§E':.e? :.m5«:5..
3%.' H "E1'<> ;4's.§§i"<:-'xi'? iihégz <T;§25::".r;::,é<>:'"; 9% :f3€:(.."§i<}E'} $2. €..E'::';': ssuii. " '"1'§:'z.:s;i bis: 0%' 2»: <:';6;?:z':,a3T.:r;1 <':§:.2-:1';-1:t'E.m' 2:1':::.% p2"23:§; {<1}? {'f{¥"£"'i 222:1 :'€3Ei€§'s«3, in 64 <?om:.=,> :m.(ier any Qf' Efzesry z:f§.cm.sr:g_ W?:.(;>rI . {f£:;;j}2:'2(,£a:2zi cfirgmfes £.I'1.:3 £3}Ci$i{3?"i{I'C? sf (1 {"I'z_z_-sf; ' 3" deClarai.'z'zi>I2 film. {he Imsi. cit):-355 axis:
made as <1r'1.(72'liczry I0 Zihe IIifJ';Z;.A?:>1V I"{:"E¥".(;:} fl C'iL1iI%:?L€;€i:V " V' ;,m,(f,e2' the seCE"{.{>n if Ilhc p£cai2"z.f.gi[;f'< §f'! e3iEi. a'>rTii'EI_i €si._£0.. i.z":': but wliegrz the? (.'CL;'§€ g')"Zr;:'._z':[zV'{g',{j"']Eivf'£'sA..;iE11jV .3 u;g;.r2z' <;_f"a cause: Qf"o::iéI"i(mg 'i'?:z,§%.:: n.<§"::;z(§%*rci'%'zi.j'c}r g:;iv'f2r'2g mm 5: {ie'3r_jl{2r'cz(.5if§; =o:>£Vi'.'c;{_ff. w"zr:"'l«9.-3% I-3raLj§<rg{c;£2z:":;e C(}C§«{3.
pI"<'n.:iS:.<'m Qf se?c:1.i<.3?-2 v %CTE§¥ ff T?'1<;>jir':(1i;'1g_§1s {:0 Cz"';i';:i§fi>Zi.<? Ij"rLz23i;' in s:.z.<rh Q2';:f:;.??i§:si.c::':a§.'<3s z.§::E>z4zfcit'E§.é%_"::.{§__{%§;t)re' man. an ()biIezj.- --f§:r'ici:.:_V£2§ir"2.;TzV€:a'E" c£«f§r2:§;_!.'iI4'1.1:4e I":E'1€ finai ciecrisi.or.w 1>V.i:z:j€? ';;§;1'iVf, '9§'i'2:3' is (ha: in our' €,~fi;}E'!'1'4Ef)'?'2'A"§ff"§fE? ":Zf;?'{V,%2'.,_'3?"(£).I'2. _.{gf' _zf2eWI~I£gh Cc>uz'ii s}'zou£,d. b§t.;.ij 5? §f3&:: :ia_}é.§1:%";.:3E {F29 (:(me:7Z.:.z.d:'ng _;><}r!*z'0z"z, Qf :233%;:_j:,:-=:§gV%':2ge}:ii, ;3C§:§g-9863 Eng; shes §..n'.a:Z coamf and ; '{g:}:f:Z'fI'T'?£?jd.i1§jVE.'?'E%;' E-:i_% z";;§':. C<>:,z.rf" ::;;r2 czgig/Mai sfuizéf dfr"e<?:.' ':'{fi_"£I:§S?'i?'§§f:§S{£§{§§{"'E'I§'i$' ;2££z.frzz',2_}{}':s= 32:5: ?'}"Eé?¥"£?5§_.; :42:.?§.::§2<3:.zi. V' 'V :15'.-5:? Vf;»:>':';'.z§;"nzézde .ie;:,:%3;'§:<7§ 51> (312.3; e:§€<:E(z.r{;_§.:<i>z"z. 5:5; 5:5: .i'§é'.s'>.}:'.%.::ce.:*{§:7i.é2:' :33" 5'2"1.5.> p:°<:=;<}e?'¥§c?3= T's} ;f.'%'2.z1S €?X3"£????. 5,32%? €>rEE:'/?';;'(:}{(-}§:\é',g:'~"£;/'£83.14-Y €i.f§€}i.i,f£?€§ azmé :".§'zz3m;%':'z{zE e:§ss,w;1é:'<~3a: :':'2<>:£§°g'Ee3d,, Eu * §:;;'}<%:«: {.f<'}1.1:"é' :3; 332$? <"t.2::':s:=;§= GE' $'§¥§?Z&?§£§ '§%%§.R§:£&TZ%3}<1fi?AN§ samswgygg mg ,5i.?§'$?'§*§ER VS. E E57
14. IE" 1'10 d02.sbI". :.z'u.:? that. ii is c}r:.Eg;.&..z.?--%té"- " .
o:.Z{e>ga{"z'<')rEs in {he plaizfi fflilé. s§'z(2t.z[d. be 3<>(>k¢fi§. i'?'£'_Z:.:'(§' .. V in z)}'1.@fz'!"_<;{': EIESTICUECTG. I10 w}2.e2':':"'2(-3:' Ihc. 1,U€E.i"a'n the a.z72i"Jz'.z' of Sectiion 92:.§C§;és}}§3st2f:?iv:a'ii.<2§i " V'
143.!) B. Bagga Sirggit 2:. C}z,zr;'1::fii'2. /j'{{§§{VAV .£--.E'~3}'2 "
}"«'Zc§;' 2613: S€')f'1(l3'1 Sirjzgh 21*}-X;;?.§:z}':.(,1r" "Sf¥"i:Q5T'? ;'§;?§€ ?;§}§§3W Pun; €I?'Ed 1*:"cz.r' 463 and Rc2(';;?.L?:.§.if5rf:::?'zr'i?::.;.r::g"f..§i{7:'":.?:'z;§z[2.i' .='VCi!'€1iI'E, A1143 .1945$._Ou.{iI2'".2*fi;§,'. "n. Bz.z£ <:§f?.er €L?i.d€??'I(.*t? I.€£;C&?f?. '§§"""%fi.S?.j§}.i.£.}§'§,d. z':4i21"c£i:A bz*e>.czc}'2. Qf"
iimsz' a£ie>ge:?Qf_ froze; n r;}.?..f5_es3z2' v:r:za::g:.f,é.'ii>z:V:f"fifizcii z'"h.a:' {hf-3 p:"a_:,;z;=éz'f§:>;V' ff?-<>I"i(::i:j_2. Q3' .%i,..-fie? ..i,<:»f_é:,?c1g;z.:¢% E1?"T.€3 is not. I31r;»;;<;;>}?1.'_V5:.'1-7:'§1,rig;. :::;;$£*i::€V _;f"i:_>u::i'_1a1'gzzion in jczczs ar r'e(1s§m 'J';>az1:z":; , I"I'iC;;4'€(:;" vz'.ez,i: 29:) brz',r'1_g {he I.VZ.?."Z§'t;~'fi"v..,§}§QT'$%?(f,§f?5l"Z¥ zL"3'2.g2r: (;sz.z.2'§. p:.z.rp<)rt§n.§; 50 be !3§%:.};,.:§E2.{T V $.92 mam: be dfS,F"i?§SS€€§.
Y'?z.isvV"'u;_;:s V<V>z'VzVV<%:' Q} '::.I'2."e. §:r:>z.zr'1<£s z'eE;:.e3d cm by z.i'1e Higiz ;' {f£:=:.;.rE ;'<}?"_ V§'?V;€}Z(£ié'2g; é'f'za§" :f"}'1e 314.5 5 was; ma, °mis;::€:":E:€z§:':c2E_'2E{3 :.€'z'*é:iie.>§' 535%: §%2= 9 "4z§3§V§ETX {.'.i>'u:""§'. in %i,§'i:5;i <?a:a:::% £3? R.i2E}¥Z§G§P.é§ ;m;2:; Vargggs vs, yzzzgf Eviéffifi sgmffiffssg' fififi §'§'§§ERS§ ':"z:ir;:2{.}f;°%..£%{:i :2: am 29% 3a 444 ..f:'i:;:.25:Li'£'«:7;;r:; w:ZE..'§f: %;:?1a*. Eezgzxf. g:.}{:>ss'§€'.:éx:2:3 32:": z"::%s»5g;3:*r<%': 2:71? :2, Z_}_E'1€§§":I' .' $<";{:é,§<}:'": 92 :2? {f:E?{T E1313 heici u_s:1{§<é1":~ 84 1"I<-3: do amt. krmw thziii §<.a1*i}i}2'1sz11..}pe: ha-11:1 <::><;»:%c:}&1..i.a:§%:r.V§VV"
a1g1'<:e:'1':i:*;':.%. in f':::v<.;>1.1I' of "'\="'ee1*2::'~3§';;a1i.v2.1 S2-1:113}. Ka;'i§321sa[.)pz.1 used {.9 w<:};"s!.2§p i:h.t> §}a'(i:i--.i.g;e He 2:1cimii.s 1132.11". éjy 1.}'1e sick? sf <:<'m'1p1::r~:>;. He: do 1201.. 1«:1'1<.ui~T.ii.'-..._'v'c:e§9:a.:shz.si1{g:i -.:S'.§:fii2:j' éfild <t<>:g.s:ai:1":s.::%i.<:(:i ii... 1%: 2'1d:'1';i£.s:; ":.'»{£A:.:'t't..'p€é>.pAl£2_.E&2a.t,ze ZE{H} <'%<>1-131 ;"11<?i,<3.{'i 1119 SE-.'L§q--1("i *...{v;'2'ri§. 2.12:: s3}1op;:3i:r3g; <?é(.):'13p1e>:. Hrs: do ;.;'c>{V'. k'1'1c}r,x;' " shzapss in 'zhs grmmd {.E{>(>2'. _;<js_I:1 I-tie ($0 110%. k.rmv+.:* \>v1'1€1I.1c1' 1'1i:e:~ ig,§11c.}:'a.11c.e about \/lie1":1sa}:»%§=.:ixr§.1 . -C.$.,.='ic:i'i('):1 pm<i:ee<:ii.1.'1 21g2'3..i.I3.si':
CA/1.8. a1i(iE. g<>§n_;;' up ':19 E--ii;._.§h C<}:.,s1"1.. ER-3 a<§n1i£T;;..+; ~t.E}a'i. 'Ei€.<% £%x=;.'}i::%<: <12? '§{<;;{'i£ 3:12.31. 2. S5ifl{'.E;E :ci':><:::.:'£, 3%} ":s_.:*€:-':2.-:§'§<.'s. I?.1;i:%.'1:1.<.>%;. :?~;=;':€n. am;/~' {:§<'>::.7z.2::'2<'i:2:'.::s= :0 $231}? 'i.E122;€': Keéii §Tfi':.:€.'i A :3;-2z.1"1[2:.g§2: §..§'".{€f.v§'%.'ik'§"£-;i§ET§% 5}? £318 €'§'1:'i?<:7 §Ts.z"?:.:"E'E',$.
58.' _ V _ . :'.:a:':§:s.*:' 1..a=-':£i..:2%:>:.<;a:'~; <%5:gs.§T§[:i.:":£;%::'§ is};
'..£-3.1%'A--iE~«{'},32.:%§'é.;:-a§2§};.1. 2:zg_:}';é<:§ "?§::% jg'"é?§1'§"f*%2 <.}.§'.": §=§*%.{}?.2E{L%€f}{}. E--Ea wzié; M} '%;I:;:*.{:}z"g§E§:§.;j 35%; E-'€..§'7{ §R:*.=::<}§"<§ {:3 E."§§.{§'?_i.f?§_:} iiiwiz. 231%". {.?E'2§2'z12:g§;¥J§:.z;"
'E'z;%..¥iL.1§<. C}§fi<':<? £23 E§}r§~..i-:3~45§. LE2": 'E§5{.§--:"Ea:E» fies. 235213 :.xr<3.:"k:':1g,>; ass _WW W. 15% j 92 Vee.1'as§:2:1§vz1 Sz=::1'3a_j i.<}»:;:k pmzsess;-3i()1'1. <3?' i'.}'1<~3: ;3r<31:=er':;y:"~ifr€}m C',M.S. Szissrry only. 'i"E'1.211'. p1"<3j[>ez"t'.y is zww in a13<:.s.€-seS"ssi'§§'13 'G---E.;"_T Se:::(JI1d £1ef'<:I'1cia1'1t' in 17153 iI2C1iv7£::1L1a1mg:a1pac:iij§."'"'-I39, F1'2;1.:":s§',1'1(:.i; 'V the: {.i(I}{TL,I§I'1€?I'1i,S in the Kath L1f'1;_"'2:?3i:)=.2"i',..L§';>jj'a1Ii :'§'»»5i;1'i%'i;_' I--i{0s;2:1mu3.'t'. a2:1':d Karisicic'ies;1'1wa.fz:z ._§\/i'1.,1¥.i.' i::@_ei1:.g Ulfi',"b'1"{E.I1V(i?§1.§'S 0%' _ L tin': Kcxii Maui. Eh? der1ie{1 the s::£<'g;;é%:21T.j<31'1 i.h.';:.1_; i.1.:<)1;.l*}ee1* of {he fi.1'5:'si;. c§cf'em;ia.n1 £.':1'}€1 C?.§'=.»'TE.,i:§:- ':.2s::i'i"c"a?zMrf€?: r&%iz9:1.€2<:E Le Géifiih o4;:m=:r. 1*-ie do not §<;1'10w if ébbigla :35 ':.V11c%1':'.1"1vV':je1'(}:';?f '£10 M.a:123. ura.
He 3.dmj.t'.ss £.1'1z1:1, f'E2"s-1sif-.«:ieik:é'{1c12:i':%::. 1i1~r_i;%s---f§§"e<§. s=s:.,1iLss in re$pes:7*<.
of suit. S{':I'}€.d'L1] c"'[3,z."()]'5{?I'f_i€. f'1"i1ei_r<:'»: 'z'_.s 1'_1o 0rd€2' of §2'1}z2rz<:t.i0:';
in fav<>3._,1:~ of .€'1'ié £':';-.s_i' 'tis:>1e;«:j1d:'s._1j1:.-- :1: t'.h<.}se (.',E.1S,%é;'S. E33. ",__i1." :55, §':3:_1.1";:'s" E§;i.i%kg1'{§1..1:'zd. we 1;1za2va=. is 1:><>.':: 5:? éize; <'::a::5¢*._§.&<>i' x:7ie:%§'<:;('1<,§;¥1z'.i:i;&;--2 ;m<:§ 3' 'ah? <i;~1"2:.E :mc.i {E<>:;t:.m':e:ma.1""j;
,e'<;ier.,ie:rz.';.<*':_;;% 2,%;§;..£gfi*;vE:%'2::?§; haw:-E }i;1"<7{.i':.;::e:.% E0 :::~5i.;1§3§§s:s:;?; EEKTEE" 233526, "§3p~." 3.éis§;vV'€E'3<r ssg:%e.ii':'§"'§<": <'t2::s;§:% 0? a'E&>.§%:ri'2£§;:':.:'a.:'s.?-5»? 31:16; 3 '%:E:2-'ii.
_. ' v.«~--« ' '%'..§?::<.'%§::§E;-:i--::.£.§§'é" E_{.{.,1 E?{2':_§2,a;:3p;:° iéiéé? (.3? $316 ElE'E§iiE.1§E'§{f%.E"'iE§€ff§ ' "znjzsti §'§§£j;;;§;~;i§ s'~;'a:'§>~~Ee.:;e:~is<%{=r :;}.§" ihei? é..::%z'1:'z;':§' --i;Q:£3,S;§l§}7. S€i,*{}ZF3.€§ " _ ' E:31'é2'i:3.?;i§'f's5 }'{3'1I§'E§_;€'I' 55-i:~aE.<::'r is m2rr:'£a={§. £0 %I'E'.;{: 5;:11i{i E,s3z'::21r1'L.'§ 35/ 105 m~1'£.11:'e. IE" is 211 ptxbiic €111.31. IE} feicti. bath £116 pE1I"{'i€S (10 not {iis;:>L1§.e 1':}'1a'%. {'1c%i:%::{Ti;1:'1t.s»?. €1i'"1C§ 3 are :1'2anz1§§ing§ }')§'(i)[}t'33"I..§t°?€3 ml" the §a,<5'i 12:1{.>re 61211:] sixty ye.a1's. _§"t'"is;:f 'é"h.r~:
('i<>LI;.'s:s::? of :;uc?h ;'112.m;1ge12'1c:*2';,i., 1211195; h;.1\.:€ _..i.rf:,ii'i:3,v1.t§dT 1_<':gr;1.1"
§31'<_:><.:&:c%«:§ir1g:'§$, :'c<'*<m;%1f€.=(:i §)0ss3(-3ssio1"1 :,'f§'£'.)I'}_1_"1}'"}{?.' "*£;,¢1'1"z1::".a'%',._<.;','-1:72;? up A' I'3'13.1.§§i${{)1'i{';'(.§ <'r<:*:r'1ss1.r:,§<7§:i{>n:3, VI»€;.%1 m.1ii ~-- i<,=1'1;;211t, <;r<>iiz:{tE,.i:': :'e:':m's5s, 1"e%:";'£..s:; .s;€§"L'£§,:VV{:-.-3V'xi"~:'*<,:'e:%(:i §::r;%'g§i. 3g';?$€%L>21r£1t:€ EL);-mk 21{?{:c>1.1:':i', zmci ihey that §11('}1'1fii:~g" for a1'1y e:*}'1a.1'i142z§::Ie Er: far;-1(:t, they i1"1L€*.£'Ed (",{)E"}S{'i'L:I..{T{'§E}g. 2-1 L{::1Ejg.=2':21'«1\z'§é1:'j::..21p21jé"();" the benefit, of ]Qc<:);:}ic% b:;:*§.{)_n;:;2;i:51' J r.;>:._ '£1-'szftzé:";2:5{h.2z_iv=:=1 .;u'1c% Li'r'1ga},--'21i. Cc>mn:::.r2ié;y. 'E38. 'V _ '§h«:> {i<:>z.'z1°t. in ihté <:2:::::.€: <35 'E'HAYARAltfMAL "msm $1? :2; 'E-73$ ANS @'fi':fERS, r<%§;=ei>1t"%;.e£§ I Affi .j'5?€I. Z 588, ::§{f';':1ii'1§§ ax.»-"§':E'1 "£'.h<*~, {}i,§.€ff~§?i'.§{}I'1 w§;2<3é4E1<%r 2-1
-:.i.z'2':.. 21 {T§'1<::v;'§§.'sj=; <1}? S§<.>::::§3 §§'}{fi.£~g:'fih w{.:r:.':§£§ E} E' z.;:2~1'f::'2 ;;z_ v E:
'{'7.{'}§'§:~}§§1é,.;.§.,§'lT' ER 'E';':.2:<:::':; §':2=2§-; E1 5225.? 2:::-5: ::2':.:'§<>:":--
"i=-3-,§}§E{i?'?'?'§:T§(7?E.€ZE?"{Z?'I'i. '«iTf'E<}:;E£r§;' «:.'§f° E%'<2:.:z'.f'2. f:'§:ii<:z m_e¢z:'2:".r'z§ a _;::I::z{:aa :.,z:§'2:?:'a<- ;2€§§,m'.m:; er' E"I':z:.¢{5ZEez"s znczgg jzwzf z'z;>s;§: (mssf <>:"§":.e%z° ;3:'0:.:i3€<>;'::5;. E§i:z<iz..:.<; in fmiiiczi €I'(}IE§_'-;Z°._',§¢?¥' zfze.» e%5§z'.{z}J§§'$?"z2'%':ec?§":.§ Qf ié// =?»x.M, ,.
the if-_3L1.iI i"i1.:-'(.3 L111.c:.§t-:1" E§r::<'¥;.i(.3:'T1. 92 0f Cede <3»? Civil E53:'<)<:e%i31,ii=<=?;' £101', :'1'12:i.1:1é,z1i.7:':;.1}::3E<x 67'. E\.f§<:fi1" 2.zc;11z:i.is:e;i0:1. <3? Q36'-SE5 21§3}i2€:2a§.«.'.-'s;*.. (5%, «am 2}.pI.)E%;{%a11i<>:'T1 1231' 532-13'. this; £.',{)1.11~'£.::__by.._ji}s3_<3.:'dé':*? "€1ai_.ed,-- I8,{>9.2iIf){}'L ;_'.{1'2'i1":€L.*.d 5-mzziy s:.:bj¢%=:f:i,_i<3 <fe z'i';>;-x.:£i'*: €§?{}I?--£'iit.§'{?I'1$' 'ia;h€c safici m*<'1<;::" is in §'<m:<: éiéi :.o<E;1.§;. §'}v;é":E?.3;("?3é;i,4 wés, ;§21s'=:s§§ ¥;,'}:ic:% ibllewiizg Qrtiezz 2",} fippeals are ql_lbxped;
ii} '.,«"1f"i«£-:'V_flf§i§?'?'?£'!':i.i c3.I'1:ff d Cf(fT:£:"£:f" '«<;3,!'f..:z',i':c3 Lriai COt,.U'{, is ._ §"s:;.' r.>z $§~ ._ fig") ' }%""?'s:.;; (§z'sm.i;~;:»;e(i5 ;'*::f.VE 2': ?\/.}'V%'{§fi,>.Z'".£:/-: }_'}C£,f-}§S€{T§ in §§1£%$ei3 a;3peaEs :§z.am:1E . , """ H V5}? .:::3'}:'£§:f"§'E5a-;'-:5 50 E;>e;=c;z.r §I'T:¢>:'.§' <..2:.;fr2 <>:}§~:§.s5M 3&5"
§§§$§ Séfé §§-§ E{:~3§:> /' ugig mu