Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Gujarat High Court

A? ?? C|>=4L??\ D??Bw& #?R ?L?Jg? 4?O ... vs ? on 21 March, 2011

Author: Harsha Devani

Bench: Harsha Devani

Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK ����� ^V7?19 ��� ��� ���mimetypeapplication/vnd.sun.xml.writerPK ����� ^V7������������ ���Configurations2/PK ����� ^V7������������ ���Pictures/PK � � � ^V7������������ ���layout-cachecd`d(???? ??? a d??8?@?F ? ??c r??Sx,PN0?

? 9?Az8 Xb`aS?R" ' ?(&q?? + ?

??? ?\ ?��PK R?o?U���?���PK � � � ^V7������������ ���content.xml?=Yr?H ?s` M?Dy ?` ?? ZvYRI?B ??7 $?@�?&*???an8'"?r +A Z?+?m Hd?} ???t?`& ? =?{@?g? ?? ~??zxr?????76?6{??v?d^|h?^  x?9?? q ??:? ??K ????n?H?|? ???^???c?g? ?9?t??b&^? ?q5.�j??3?]???h= ?????????}~??%Ma????C?zq7&?N? I?`U}}?\ ?}zV?H?]??6?R ?b/YNY?R"?i}??j^ ???*?&??a3c?`R? g ? N`#? 5 ;9? :???R/?qs\??g! \?~??Ab}????$?,$?.???;?????W0? H?????M????? ???$??g ??qD?4?p??! ?5 ?? E?Y?gmQ? 8?! ?? `DBI?]` [?`.???y??? R?? li s ?e??Ax2?z? ?"? !s ????/ D??~?| ?e?X?m2 0kR Mn???! ?5,]? ? ??????5xx? ??: wKt,? w!???:T???f?[ ?

? }?P?m? ? PG?]??? ?? : y?? ??VE??7?; 6????`[???&z??p ? ??????Eo?VEo????[??? ??[ ?? E?t???l????`^{???????^???e?h?? m ?'???E??7?x*}?*d?? ?~5?Q???I`z??? ??RrS -?!?!4H? .`?\?p? c?d?;? ? 4Ss?0? �3&P]??qR&?? ?4?6S"??? (??a ????! u#I ` (?gW? ??? ?"?/X??c?T_{d|??? L}?? ???&I? ?R ?

R Zr&?'?N? g; m s)?{5?[I^??? ? la@oJ?"m?)?S6J?F#??G?x? zD?? =:?z 95~ 9?|?N??A` ? ? Y0?7??]??&?}o??KIC ?xd5??H`` ? ???:Ql ?x3???�?$?S?" B0h00?"`?I?9?jzR| [9!??/% ? A?{?f "?-?M0??! C?? ???^?~??. ??g?Ba??J? e?????? ???B?/?~ ???n???_?? ??=???_??}??b? >~x?yH2f? 7? ??#???wr? ????D?? |*> ??& ??6 ?? R??x 0?{??8h?A q/??Q?? �a ?`? |?- ?0fa Zt?? ?74?x tM?RP?? "CbxD 8?`?g???]d?w??{#*G%?aW6?F?V6?[?F[???( ?]d?? ?x: ?>2>d3 ??u-) Rx??7? ?? l??v? ????.? ?&?O ?0 ? ?" N??AD y?0??R?m? ?h8^?* k c?"` ? R?} 1?E0 { R? ? :FRpo?+Hl(0 )?? s? ?F ??`?? ?H: }?kA?b???U??`}S?k ~?i!?NG]?5? ?il?H}??% ?? 6? ??V 6?V?F;

?h A ?E?~ !h<&\? 8#:!v??8sG6_qW ? AxB?? tSzt???b?~?E ?_I? 9? 0???w ? ???9?? r5????t>?0 ?eQ?9?V c.?g ^ ??q D =FC?~ ?ex??t}K& ?? ??E!L??`=%?)?^ ?o?I?`??krs;9;?;?x?&??? ???V?#??? ??k????+? ??F????F????'p??+????9ox'?*O?w? ???R??>?9??P ??a??[d ??S6>?? hJwx???! ?mR?? jWc?????o ?vE.|?z???}k" ?4? ?? ?=9|?? ?m? e? ?\P?e?\& 2?s ??? l=?EN?ih/:X C ?( M?k????'?? ??`y #?!x& u??. ?S?@`J 0w??x??????wt ?r??X`? ?�? ?P?KCRH?2b?R &?X?? ?f 1??%?:K?Z??n?$ ? ? ??a?" ?� ?2? \??,Y@$>e?#3?f?9Q a?&?#F??qc??Z??-?????:?? ?? _ ?`???HE?8J? ?L� ?d8?8'??_`;!?A? ? ? 9 i ???7????

c??. Wl-?8 ? &? ???#` k?Z R$? ??[RH{?? a?)D?? ? ??3??

??2[ ??B(?i?F*?? `"?b r ?$?[ ? ??E/'?�#}? ??? [?~?; ???HZH Pg ROD?kb ?????I ????e!?

? ???,Z<$K K:_? 8?a-b*? B5??Q?@? ?"F? %2<�?n rrE?x|??S\??.?n� ??Y ? E? � 8?k "? .? iZA# P i4 !??) ?AP?? ??qWH_?bFc { V?.?h0? "??A??R??? 50+!:? ?"@"? ?K< ??/ `??@M K ?'?o?? |5 ?

? ?"?

8? >?? F &q?P?8? ?eK #?qa? p5??>? ???@0;? R?_ S"!?(& E??@? &2? ? ??? ?;M?O?rJ?@c8_??3?a ?~�?? ? ???w{2?CiRj? ?x F ?2?? 9'? {?wH?!!L9NB0?m?Z(6Db 9X?`?? ?? ?4?0 e ???? �Ii`F@hI5a?a@-_??@????N?~ Z? ?* ?$? ??x? 6)?g`J?" 9R?LD5' ?? ??9p# YK~?!?'??? (@?6?3?:I??"h??a?"&?D #9? ?)C ' ?4 Ya9O- ???~??

Z|?W,?D ]??3 ? |$9 ???&?&i? ?? ?X ????GO?b? ? ?~?{,??8?u?q?>g?S? "? "?&??Z?r/ ? ?`l0??3?};C? ?%?? Rm??*]g??Z]^D~ 1???? '?Y!?#k`a?"?`?$?9? ??"?7?WN3 ?^?$c? V ??i? `?T ,1S?? ?MKi}6E?i?~B 9S9L?:?&? 2 r ^ .b^00".?'? ??He4{U tp?3?& q?^?!uV???e\(? ?F ?:E?\ >T? ? r a?&??u R{a/ ?j??Xt? Dr???Z1!?? ?z7? ?xZO"?R9""= ?Z ? ?2 ?~???cR~0|z ?Fi?A? ?:_fj 0?,? n4 R??B_P? ?Q2]?X?L?R??Q ?fq`??A ?_ !X ?% "I?!?? .(?a? ?F ???H??@C?MD VC ??Rb"1?J6?9 ?e? s?d????:??? 8z???P%!?)Hf? Y ?9x?T_0?#x?$^?! Sx?H? !?3p??&)?fI(`H ?0~??? ? J 5O ?%?? 7 X�2A :?l 0 a ,Aw?BM???as?SU\? !?s"A ??v)_V?2\???= ?T} n�?$? ? 3 WU6?v @(J?? ?&?(x?? UE?>?? ?) S ??" ~y6?Ea +DN ?hc?Q? ?I "? 9?w? 9 ?:?j?0"?"d?#W ?&?

2b#/??u 6?k 0v&{?6$+mi? ?? B??`:)"?=& ???}L?) }?? X?A!,Q$b-]? ?? ?~?k ?'?+ 1?V ?kyi2 ? Rl??:??e?

:7 ! ???r? TRR?e ?Ye ? ? # R ?.S???9 ?? ? ??d? # Y B+? ? ` 'x|!?r ?E??*9 3$Em1=?q.[0 ?CE}?\``H?/9Q'f?$gV-?=I ?, v? Z h? a?�X??|J??=z? ??? ?M??�1Z?

R w ????9 ??vM p?C? a? & ? D ?�? g?i? $?? X -W?? Qx3m!*?r ??\? n3J7? #? h2 ??$S:??&! ~ ? |?s %?D? $9N B iy?> ?O? ?S???-?n??2? 9:0?T= ?w??'Xp?= ??~6 q(? (? *?�?U: {??p Bi?? Q ?RRV? `1 ? ? ? ?8? nh?u?=??"33"??":^S???? _? ?m ???~5?*k??NY?7?R?l Va?? "

zZQbC)?^}?L?.?n??J \?6?t? aS : i? 2? D V&RJA? ? ??I#??Bt!]?9?? S "?

? aK?? ?_$)?}? d???l ~9?a?I?? :E?n?)? :?e, 6L")i U?DL? ?} ^?P/Y ] ?? "?h?C(???

FH6qU?? ?/ H - "???K????~juMm?& ?0? SaJ?O? ) ?&&??6%?RLQ?NU?zu?S??x? _? ] ?Uh?E??B?&??% 9?? * ??}?=p??;?? }'@ ! ?&?q? p?I?;?,?r" U?7"??? ?8?_w?[9I7_0 0 m???8L(K50? ?9?N (s ?? ?_???GD?? Sz ?L1^?'? ?|??? ?.???SE LBeE?0??P?'wK"?D??~(W< ?3 ? ?8s ? ???u?'R ? ?d`[?? } |+?!?z?/ ?? ?2L?N"?~?`?q? ??2L?k!L41la?:z ???? 67?%h ?P??dL!7/?? W?N=R?? rf}??%? 6 gj?I?w4%?$Q?!A?V?@Z(C? e6IU?)"C&>D:a?r H???? m0' ?? ]????$C zf?g???`8,_??&B8l?[ ?t ??H�G7"C??9?" 6 ????P???:?dr-?W? ? ?w &c?!?? Z" =?9?eZS1??"?+0??/< ?? 3?H(U? ???

?"Z??? ??# B :J? *?v!???? ??Sc?Y f J V?E??JY8; !? ?B` j( ??L??? r?^E???V :&?YAV?Ts m ???a? ?y& "?? ?? 1?"?n?&8?$S"? ?u??~}? _?F??\?9??"?\D??M hf?Q L? ??

?zY?^vK,?[? ?)Y?k ??B ?#?=?s?0?????L?LL?????5?fC???F?S? g T???@'? 3? d%?"]~ ?4 UF?" - e?&?:??_`? ,?)??5m? -8?Sp$cHE ??W???A?;m(??R =?Fa?(?? P? ?# D? ?]?? 6 ??eE?? *??& i??p ??w?8? ? ? ? ? ??>?C[Ey? ?1?3"????0??;r ? ?NZ?- @ ?"$#A? ?uzZ3O%^7 "?i 8@???z??

u???`\ ?a7?? ??? ^?T ??0???1?? ? @?4 ?CD&i T>??FH!u}??E&Uc ?5? ??G??d??Ln`?H?Z !? 9???j??B:?g? HZ7?h_?``6? 8??S6m ?? N!D?9??Y W > ?ri?????:?;> rZH?N?b??n?&?ZV??K i???`W?+M?p xQ?? ^?;jH?Q%m???�R??N Vy? k?n?m:???~CiC?)??- USS kzR}?dE?S?-?? z$ -; ~(G�X k?74?E??

4??|+? ]G ?3l9?1K1UsZ $??^?? ? X e:/?d?1C?6?"?j[?? >????K??w V?

?? ?d??FG ?VJ'?? ?S?

? R? ??g ?*?".??BO?~*?;)& ?}D??Z? ell ?@Sk$?? ? ??Z K ?J> ? ?B?`%b q| ?&?$&? 5I?Q????G? /L +bx?|?m?p??? ??LD _ O?$:?:r?* c?V??|?09S?????]>^?tO}f r?H$ ?BUQ ? 9?h9 /? o?; U!?F?]z? ?77?x?w,'???,"!�? ?$J??|XRX?=?/f??a?.!"??6jg?=?]R?b:Yf?6?r j% ??i G??? 8? U5 ;?9T?r }?jh??%}5?q? ?7]?; 52???)G8?????-G?z ?z.%}ok?w2???v?d???k?S ?

?"f9?kU xJ0>? ?z ?mE0,?

??

rIX ? ?R?? ?r =? ???0YI)?ZgR??�i R??G?}? N5X ?AAat9?A? Y?{?: ??0m}? ? ?? Sc`$?D9??:? ?K5?0 ??7????a"%????? ??P-???? $?A9G?N N?`V ?h?e?? ?jh?dt? ??;z? ?q?8???�?S ?d#?| /'.u????R9?@t?j6g&?_54 ?m? ?6?{*?S }T? ???} Y ?A?� ? p C�"??h ?! ]??_?? RPk+ ? hVRbK?9a??K" c ?-? ?C?q_[ J>cIG&&??mW R? q?"???#?Z"*?~ ?N?0+B+`??8? -?

>?B?'?w? "? ?! i?}?Q??? ?5s}?l5 ??#?+X?O?? ?T??? PK ?4? ��:?��PK � � � ^V7������������ ���styles.xml?Z?o?6 ~?_ah??dIvS?Y?b??uCR H:?" h:?D e???w$E?2%+IW?a}( ?????;? ?:?OI n?Vi? i??C ? L } W?SjB??

#x?K-?S`??D*}?tv? ux ?C? ^?B?l??z? %?G=??` �HH? D_c?mW K?kW?,?\ ? m R? ?qQ????a G? "c?)!C? ?] ??l9"?wAq &?t?q ? Be?X B@!p??a7KQ ??2N???(??? ? 6&V4??3t ??a?3dk?\0 ? 3?1 ?? ?? A? ? P 0D?YM Y?? ~?`` ? k Y?`,Ft ?

a? ?? C|>=4l??\ D??bW& #?R ?l?Jg? 4?O ZK?MoSh? ? ??"d:??P ?Cr E ??? � ?=?[L ?R??(`0w"??:?ZB?3? ?4 ?V? 1?t?`?3O ??? d "9??9?dV?m u)x{ j? r? oR?!}?X???T ?(I_ ?u ?2?[??8A ??m6 : ??I?? ??U???? :I? AW1? ???(? ??? gx???S??1?�? ?Wo?a&AGO?f?I$?Y?? K??mD?/ ??b?? ??N?P vS?

?1 =1 ?q \? m=?M* *? ?f ?RkS???x?)?^?ua??~???g9? I ??? 6?

?+"s?]ap?a?`???

Ck U E?)?0??9 #& ? ???z ??W? ?3? ?* 6?ZW pg??Z? q???? ?E???c3E:?R?Qq?4?' ?>???W??|7???&-?kM? ???s??4?? ry? h`?@ RS?snm)??t?6 u35U?* Ptn n?3? ???h?y23 W-??a_?c e?? s.9"s L9????U??V???

x???O??~??!?7?x9??B9Rhk? ?x5?x`??G?::? L?MA+?~?Wd7? PK c x?x ��&&��PK ����� ^V7?{ ?? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.0$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m3$Build-8968 2007-10-22T17:22:44 2007-10-22T17:22:44 en-US 2 PT1S PK � � � ^V7������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.pngmT}4?{ _u9D??!? ]ay76 . ?R "/k5#r#????4?h&-D??nk???"(o?Y\S??a???]?????|??s???|~?? ??????? h ? ? ??V???? ?( H% ?? azSF???7?R?W !&??qRw? ?Z?K]m]M?o (0N?8???g,dp? ?CH ? P??Y?xt7????y????!?0!? ??a? QR??_?~? `?

$*?RI\?.?c ? GD? ?pS- 0O;?E?o?clO#???F?xK??xf(@??L?R????n? ?}:pb . ? ?YYze?T? C .?C #?J????? ???F?=`!?? ? ???P?oRRO"i>|?p????Q]? ?o?d? ? ???e??(??2L? ]? _? ? ?x!?VL?i?}? /i J ??M? g b??? O&? 8o&`l?G %z i= ? ? x?2??m??@]?a?p? 9_ 4???�??

??? ?/ ?? R.!j?HqxeA8?Y^?5 ?{ !d:? ??? ?

@c )? ?Hd: ????.~U|??|?&Ym?~N??? ??Ys?vr??\![ Z??#?]? ??? ????0 '? ???}?'?_?S?c ?~?q?gi3?v??ew+??

}??Z?s ?[ B ),^"e`?e??maT._?? )??7???Ts9Sz??w`?? ? /??+??R??H? ?(?6?0 ~?T????Lh??Y??A?>aVS??` ?{??:??? iR??|1?GRa s?? ???? x??w 2???? ?2??n?/??q:? ?& $ HS?` -?'??w?? onL|?? ?.?a?g?z??~{? ????bq?8O?6noo???fi?r?gx`7?l?? D?d??v'kx>8??x?q?yx?Q? "????d ???a??0 ?????i}K c?m??ULw?4^?????????!9 ? S !]? ??C3??m?^~?T?? ?l~??F?^r?9.~!$FAg?? ?}? ?�&??Q ?? m& ?0 "?) ?`?Z?? !,!??U>??g(7??????j??^? ??I ?^??Z )?W ?3E?0??'J`?$?S???$? ?? ?Fc0??????e9? ?1A??m}?|?-h U>l??^?? ? %?9???Yt{??? ?? V0? 0b j?x ?V "bcF< ?,?Rpt? ??g?% v?SR~??S?? !??I? %y1 ???"6d ztZ???S M@} ?

?P?RDqP Rb ?)GO??HF?o8),} ?? ??H ` }w`$uc?bP?? L????BI ??`:??r ?? [ ?I??n& 0 ?;?v?0 W m."Zy??[Nu??~m ?Vb0c #I? i3 ?O?A? ?LS[R?I?X?J*A Y? ,D)?(qS? f][??2? ?E????K ?d?O 9?e?8 ?

? v|?. ?$????l? ?}@?B ? ? 'L D? ?x?af? ?%JQ?,??N?? &*?K?lh;T>@=?7???e?J $?a!??4?`? 9??G tUM???Q9??>:? ?.?' ]T (?u?Oc^]?o?[fd?? ?h[ 6 ??? ?

uL?}+??9 \ 1!p ???d�?? 1 ?L U?0[a??? ?9 R??9 0?Si "t9~?G? ?Y?6S??? ???V? [?o=?t?mA????P?b ?????x?9?ti? PK H ??! ��? ��PK � � � ^V7������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml? 1o?0 &??

?{|?T! R?J"?? }&?$ ;?/ ??UC?a&6??~?7x?:Wa??yeM?b? a?f? 1?$O? _-? ?:?:y?oY%????+?????f< ??hvy?R ? �:d?^;]` l?8??"?(? ?: 2?rRyIT? l??~?:L??0 ??\iR??k?&?L??? c.?Z?TR? N& ?1"?` ? ?:?F? T? 8R??( Z ??q???n?k0x?j> ? !??? " ? ?k?? ?T?%?hAx& ? C` a?? "???G?VH? ?aXR6??H?=PW`? c??

0? r0v =?X~ PK oUy?8 ��} ��PK � ����� ^V7?19 ��� ��� �����������������mimetypePK � ����� ^V7������������ �������������D���Configurations2/PK � ����� ^V7������������ �������������r���Pictures/PK � � � � ^V7R?o?U���?��� �������������"���layout-cachePK � � � � ^V7 ?4? ��:?�� �������������( ��content.xmlPK � � � � ^V7c x?x ��&&�� �������������X ��styles.xmlPK � ����� ^V7?{ ?? ��? �� ������������� &��meta.xmlPK � � � � ^V79?"?M ��a �� �������������?)��Thumbnails/thumbnail.pngPK � � � � ^V7H ??! ��? �� �������������N/��settings.xmlPK � � � � ^V7oUy?8 ��} �� �������������?3��META-INF/manifest.xmlPK ���� � �O ��$5����     Top