Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

87. In Writ Petition No.12768 of 2019 (Rajendra Maheshwari Vs. State of U.P. and Others) it is stated that the petitioner is the tenant of Carmichael Library Association from the time of his grand father one Devendra Chandra on the ground floor for last more than 90 years and after the death of Devendra Chandra, Virendra Chandra, father of the petitioner became the tenant and after his death tenancy devolved on his son Rajendra Maheshwari, the petitioner herein and therefore he is a statutory tenant. It is stated that the petitioner is carrying on the business of selling Auyrvedik Medicines, Books, Mobile Recharge, Mala, Phool and Prasad etc.

Thus, on the basis of these documents it is not known as to whether the shop is in the name of Rajendra Maheshwari, the petitioner or in the name of Devendra Chandra or Virendra Chandra and such disputed questions of fact cannot be decided in the writ jurisdiction.

89. Accordingly, the Writ Petition No.12768 of 2019 is also dismissed.

In Writ Petition No.12817 of 2019 (Sohrab Ahmad Vs. State of U.P. and Others) it is stated that the petitioner is the tenant of Carmichael Library Association from the time of his grand father one Mohd Shafi on the ground floor for last more than 60 years and after the death of Mohd Shafi, Abdul Rajjak, father of the petitioner became the tenant and after his death tenancy devolved on his son Sohrab Ahmad, the petitioner herein and therefore, he is the statutory tenant. It is stated that the petitioner is carrying on the business of Cosmetics, Artificial Jwellery etc. in the name and style "Eram Jwellery Corner'.

Accordingly, the Writ Petition No.12821 of 2019 is also dismissed.

93. In Writ Petition No.12837 of 2019 (Ashish Agrawal and Another Vs. State of U.P. and Others) it is stated that the petitioners are the tenants of Carmichael Library Association from the time of his grand father one Ram Krishna Ke Das on the ground floor for last more than 80 years and after the death of Ram Krishna Ke Das, Govind Ke Das father of the petitioner no.1 became the tenant and after his death tenancy devolved on his son Ashish Agrawal, the petitioner no.1 and his mother, Smt. Nirmala Agrawal and therefore they are the statutory tenants. It is stated that the petitioners are carrying on the business of selling Cosmetics Items, Gota-Jari, Ias, Mala, Phool and Prasad etc. in the name and style of 'Ram Krishan Ke Das'.

Thus, on the basis of these documents when the shop number and address of the shop is not known these factual aspects of the matter cannot be examined in writ jurisdiction Accordingly, the Writ Petition No.12837 of 2019 is also dismissed.

95. In Writ Petition No.12876 of 2019 (Santosh Kumar Chaurasia and Others Vs. State of U.P. and Others) it is stated that the petitioners are the tenants of Carmichael Library Association from the time of their father Maniram Chaurasia on the ground floor and after the death of Maniram Chaurasia the tenancy devolved on his sons Santosh Chaurasia, Saurabh Chaurasia, Vikas Chaurasia and Ashwani Chaurasia, the petitioners herein and therefore they are the statutory tenants. It is stated that the petitioners are carrying on the business of selling Mala, Phool, Prasad and Pujan Samagri etc. in the name and style of 'Santosh Mala Bhandra'.