Document Fragment View
Fragment Information
Showing contexts for: internship completion in Astha Sharma And Others vs State Of J&K; And Others on 3 May, 2018Matching Fragments
12. Finally, a supplementary affidavit dated 24.04.2018 was filed, wherein five (05) candidates were identified by the SSRB, 03 in the Open Merit and two (02) in the RBA, who according to the Board itself were ineligible, inasmuch as, they had not completed their compulsory rotatory internship as Physiotherapists, without which they could not be presumed to have successfully completed their diplomas/degrees in Physiotherapy before the cut-off date. The names of the aforementioned five (05) candidates are reflected as under:-
16. The second ground of challenge, which was common in all the petitions is that some of the candidates whose names figures in the select list prepared earlier by the Board had failed to produce the necessary certificates, which were otherwise to be produced at the time of interview. The following are the candidates, whose names otherwise figured in the select list, but their recommendations were withheld for the reasons mentioned therein:-.
Father's/
S. Int. Sl.
Roll No. Name Husband's Remarks
No. Num
Name
Select List (Open Merit)
1 18 1020800242 Deepali Gupta Vijay Kumar Recommendation withheld and
Gupta is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree and within date
internship completion certificate
2 71 1020800380 Poonam Rokri Vijay Rokri Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of valid
PRC.
4 9 1020800214 Anshu Sharma Kuldeep Kumar Recommendation withheld and
Sharma is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
5 123 1030800092 Sumeet Kour S. Gurdeep Singh Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree and within date
internship completion
certificate.
7 118 1030800081 Sonia Chib Kartar Singh Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
12 55 1020800329 Monika Rekhi Ravinder Kumar Recommendation withheld and
Rekhi is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree and. within date
internship completion
certificate.
13 11 1020800222 Arti Gupta Vijay Kumar Recommendation withheld and
Gupta is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree.
15 102 1030800052 Shabir Ahmed Gh. Haider Recommendation withheld and
Banday is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
16 47 1020800306 Mamta Bhagat Rattan Singh Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
19 68 1020800369 Pallavi Bishan Gupta Recommendation withheld and
Mahajan is subject to clarification from
competent authority with
regard to residential district and
production of father's PRC.
Waiting List (Open Merit)
1 86 1030800013 Raviraj Singh Jasbir Singh Recommendation withheld and
Sudan Sudan is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree.
3 65 1020800359 Neha Sharma Harpaul Sharma Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
father's PRC.
4 33 1020800281 Jagan Deep Hardev Singh Recommendation withheld and
Singh is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/validity of
Degree and within date of
internship completion
certificate.
5 90 1030800019 Rimple Ram Lal Sharma Recommendation withheld and
Sharma is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree and within date
internship completion
certificate.
Select List (RBA Category)
1 107 1030800059 Shazia Zia Nissar Hussain Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
7 10 1020800221 Arjun Singh Mangat Ram Recommendation withheld and
Katoch Katoch is subject to production of
within date internship
completion certificate.
Waiting List (RBA Category)
2 48 1020800309 Maneesha Hushyar Singh Recommendation withheld and
Kotwal Kotwal is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/validity of
Degree.
Selection List (SC Category)
1 70 1020800378 Pooja Sham Lal Recommendation withheld and
Bhardwaj Bhardwaj is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/validity of
Degree.
2 34 1020800282 Jai Kishan Krishan Kumar Recommendation withheld and
is subject to production of
bonafide certificate/ validity of
Degree and within date
internship completion
certificate.
Selection List (ST Category)
4 45 1020800303 Liaqat Nazir Hussain Recommendation withheld and
Mehmood is subject to clarification with
regard to date of declaration of
Degree result and subject to
production of PRC.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioners urged that the candidates who failed to produce the requisite bonafide certificate, certificate with regard to the validity of the degree or failed to produce the compulsory rotatory internship completion certificate as Physiotherapists by the last date prescribed, as per the notification dated 28.02.2018, their names could not have been reflected in the select list at all. With a view to test this argument, it becomes necessary to understand what exactly was the requirement of the advertisement notice with regard to the production of the requisite certificates.
19. With a view to examine as to why the recommendations were withheld in regard to the names mentioned hereinabove, record was perused. In most of the cases, the recommendations were withheld on account of the non-production of bonafide certificate or non-production of validity certificate with regard to the Degree or the certificate with regard to the completion of internship. All these certificates were never required to be produced in terms of the advertisement notice supra. These certificates were required to be produced with a view to enable the Board to ascertain further as to whether the certificates already produced were bonafide or not.