Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

(v) Shri Devadeveshwar Sansthan, Parvati and Kothrud Vs. Sushila Raghu Kadu 2002 (94) FLR 766; (vi) Bhuna Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd. Vs. Mohinder Singh 2001 LLR 141 (P & H HC); (vii) Municipal Corporation of Delhi Vs. Ram Kumar 2002 LLR 1171 (DEL HC); (viii) Novapan Industries Ltd. Vs. S. K. Murthy 2003 LLR 569 2003 (97 FLR 342 AP HC); (ix) Usha Workers Union Vs. Usha Martin Industries Ltd. 2003 (LLR 760 JHAR HC); (x) Hindustan Prefab Ltd. Vs. Labour Commissioner 2004 (LLR 309 DEL HC);

(xi) T. N. Vishakantaiah Vs. Management of Masoor Petro Chemicals Ltd., Richur, 2005 LLR (162 Karn HC); (xii) Tungabhadra Board Vs. Easu 2000 (LLR Karn HC); (xiii) Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan Vs. Union of India 2000 (LLR 776 Del HC); (xiv) Union of India Vs. Sh. Gajanan Maharaj Sansthan Page 33 to 55 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL) POLC - XI / KKD / DELHI / 16.09.2015 Mrs. Vijaya Tiwari Vs M/s. Brahmpuri Public School & Anr. ID No. 824/04 2002 (5 SCC 44 2002); (xv) Principal Kendriya Vidhayala Vs. Uttam Bose 2004 (ILL 686 GAU HC); (xvi) Sports Authority of India Vs. Sports Authority of India Kamgar Union 2005 LLR 541; (xvii) Manipal Academy of Higher Education Vs. State of Karnataka 2007 LLR 1119 SN (KARN HC); (xviii) K. H. Pandhi Vs. Presiding Officer Additional Labour Court 110/2004 BLT 101 (Del HC); (xix) Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board, etc. Vs. R. Rajappa & Ors. 1978 AIR 548; (xx) Apeejay School Vs. Darbari Lal & Ors. W.P. (C) No. 7695/1999 (High Court of Delhi) D.O.D. 28.05.2010; (xxi) Miss A. Sundarambal Vs. Government of Goa, Daman and Diu & Ors. JT 1987 (2) 101; (xxii) The Life Insurance Corporation of India Vs. D. J. Bahadur & Ors. 1980 AIR 2181; (xxiii) Manuelmony Matriculation School Vs. The Principal Labour Court High Court Campus Chennai 104 and N. Rajendran W. P. No. 34589 of 2007 (Madras High Court) D.O.D. 26.11.07; (xxiv) Management of M/s. Mahavir Senior Model School, Sangam Park Vs. Shri Ram Surat Mishra W. P. (C) No. 3522/2002 (High Court of Delhi) D.O.D. 15.09.2006; (xxv) Christian Medical College Hospital Employees' Union & Anr. Vs. Christian Medical College Vellore Association & Ors. 1988 AIR 37; (xxvi) Principal Amar Shaheed Inter College Vs. POLC UP & Ors. W. C. No. 17221 of 2001 at Allahabad High Court dated 24.03.2005; (xxvii) Peoples Welfare Society, Nagpur & Ors. Vs. Second Labour Court, Nagpur & Ors. decided on 22.10.1997 by HMJ F. I. Rebellow - Judge Bombay High Court; (xxviii) Gujarat State Cooperative Land Development Bank Ltd. Vs. P. R. Manded and Ors. 1979 AIR 1203; (xxix) Vijaya Bank Vs. Shymamal Kumar Lodh Civil Appeal No. 4211 & 4212 of 2007 D.O.D. 06.07.10 by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India; (xxx) Tata Memorial Hospital Workers Union Vs. Tata Memorial Centre Page 34 to 55 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL) POLC - XI / KKD / DELHI / 16.09.2015 Mrs. Vijaya Tiwari Vs M/s. Brahmpuri Public School & Anr. ID No. 824/04 and Another Civil Appeal No. 6394 of 2010 D.O.D. 09.08.2010 by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India;(xxxi) Kallakurichi Taluk Co­op. Housing Society Ltd. Vs. M. Maria Soosai & Ors. Civil Appeal No. 4357 of 2010 D.O.D. 06.05.2010 by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India; (xxxii) Deepali Gundu Surwase Vs. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya (D. Ed.) and ors. Civil Appeal No. 6767 of 2013 arising out of SLP (C) No. 6778 of 2012 D.O.D. 12.08.2013; (xxxiii) Allahabad Jal Sansthan Vs. Daya Shankar Rai & Anr. Civil Appeal No. 8924 of 2003 D.O.D. 03.05.2005 by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India; (xxxiv) Mohan Lal Vs. Management of M/s. Bharat Electronics Ltd. 1981 AIR 1253; (xxxv) Narotam Chopra Vs. Presiding Officer Labour Court 1988 (36) BLJR 636; (xxxvi) Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Employees of Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. 1979 AIR 75; (xxxvii) Manager, K. V. S. S. Mandawar & Anr. Vs. Mukesh Kumar Sharma Civil Appeal No. 2698 of 2010 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 30872 of 2008) D.O.D. 25.03.2010 by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India; (xxxviii) C. N. Malla Vs. State of J & K & Ors. 2009 INSC 1474; (xxxix) Dev Dutt Sharma Vs. Managing Society National Public School & Ors. W. P. (C) No. 11563/2009 (High Court of Delhi) D.O.D. 02.07.10; (xl) Executive Engineer, Public Health Division Vs. Kamlesh 2008 - II - LLJ - 826 (SC); (xli) Bhubaneshwar Mallick Vs. Employer in relation to Management of Central Coal Fields Limited Ranchi & Anr. W.P.(L) No. 3246/2001 (High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi) D.O.D. 17.03.2010; (xlii) Manorama Verma Vs. State of Bihar & Ors. 1994 Supp. (3) SCC 671; (xliii) CMC Hospital Emp. Union Vs. CMC Vellor Association 1988 SCC L&S 53 and (xliv) Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Rajnikant Dave (2006) 150 TAXMAN 387 (All.) Ld. counsel for management relied upon case laws (i) Safdarjung Page 35 to 55 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL) POLC - XI / KKD / DELHI / 16.09.2015 Mrs. Vijaya Tiwari Vs M/s. Brahmpuri Public School & Anr. ID No. 824/04 Enclave Education Society Vs. Municipal Corporation of India 47 (1992) DLT 424 (SC); (ii) Wing Commander S. K. Singh Vs. Ld. Governor, U. T. of Delhi & Ors and Air Force Central School, The Director of Education, Delhi Admn. & Ors. C. W. P. No. 540 & 1160/80 D.O.D. 21.02.1986; (iii) Miss A. Sundarambal Vs. Govt. of Goa, Daman & Diu and Ors. AIR 1988 SC 1700 (also relied upon by workman); (iv) Hanuman Mandir Middle School Vs. Ms. Saroj Anand & Ors. 1999 (48) DRJ 814; (v) Mohan Lal Jhanghala Vs. Managing Committee CW 7567/2001 D.O.D. 09.12.2003; (vi) Mrs. Poonam Malhotra Vs. School and Anr. MANU / DE / 7954 / 2007; (vii) Guru Harkishan Public School through its Managing Committee Vs. Director of Education & Anr. W.P. (C) No. 8058/2011 (High Court of Delhi) D.O.D. 14.05.2015; (viii) Management of M/s. Mahavir Senior Model School Vs. Sh. Ram Surat Mishra MANU / DE / 3167 / 2006 and (ix) Unni J. P. Krishnan & Ors. Vs. State of A. P. & Ors. 1993 SCC (1) 645. I have gone through material available on judicial file very carefully.