Moradabad to give the pistol for repairs. The Mgte. has gravely erred in law in finding that even after Rajinder Singh had taken ... done so to overawe the raiding party and, therefore, the Mgte. was in error in holding that there was no use of the pistol
Kerala Mgte/Kgte Certificate Holders ... vs The Kerala Public Service Commission on 9 January, 2012
Author: K.Surendra Mohan
Bench: K.Surendra Mohan ... POUSHA 1933
WPC.No. 30727 of 2010 (M)
======================
PETITIONER(S) :
============
1. KERALA MGTE/KGTE CERTIFICATE HOLDERS ASSOCIATION,
REP.BY ITS PRESIDENT K.P.PRAHLADHAN
year 2003, B.Com in 2009 and MGTE qualification in 2003.
According to him Ext.P3 series of certificates issued by the
Director ... Technical Examinations in
the year 2003, is the same as certificate in MGTE qualification
with the only difference that it has been issued by Government
Technical Education, found that the objection against the
petitioner, that the MGTE qualification in Drawing, which was
obtained by the petitioner, could not be considered ... petitioner, it was not revealed that the petitioner had passed the
MGTE qualification. It was felt, therefore, that it had to be
ascertained whether
KGTE (Lower) in Composing, Proof Reader's Work and Book
Binding, MGTE (Higher) in Composing and DTP (Word Star, Ventura and
page maker). Petitioner ... Junior
Foreman 290-560 Not more Pass KGTE or MGTE By promotion
than 30 years in SSLC lower in composing, from their
(No age limit
stated that this qualification is
equivalent to KGTE and MGTE prescribed in Chapter XXXI KER as well
as the orders equalising qualification. It is stated ... Certificate (Higher Grade) of the
State of Tamil Nadu and is not MGTE as provided in the Kerala
Education Rules and the Government orders
qualification prescribed for them was pass in 8th standard and
KGTE/MGTE letter press machine work. In the case of the
petitioner ... respondent University,
compared to the 8th standard with KGTE or MGTE (lower) for the
Printers of other Universities in Kerala, etc; even for the offset
equivalent with ITI
(Electrician/Wireman/Electronics) / Certificate in KGTE/MGTE.
Petitioner submits that the qualification has to be based on Board
order dated ... years of service Electrical/Wireman/Electronics
as Overseer (Electrical) certificate in KGTE/MGTE
Ext.P4 further states that "the proforma may be forwarded
post, the
mandatory requirement is that the candidate should possess
KGTE or MGTE in Composing (Lower).
3. The 4th respondent/appellant herein is having only ... order
dated 22.06.2007, declared this certificate to be equivalent to
KGTE or MGTE for the purpose of this promotion.
4. The writ petition was heard
party respondents did not possess the
notified qualifications and they possess only MGTE. The
question as to whether MGTE is a higher qualification ... challenge made by the petitioner, the Tribunal upheld the
challenge holding that MGTE is neither a higher qualification
nor an equivalent qualification. The Government
