Javed Rehman Shaikh vs The State Of Maharashtra on 23 December, 2021
Author: Surendra P
water bottle) yielded mixed
DNA profile from which two DNA profiles could be
interpreted,one DNA profile match with the DNA
profile obtained from Exhibit ... number 970- A/SFSL/DNA (76)/12&972-
C/SFSL/DNA- (77)/12 dated 31-08-2012.
ii) The DNA profile obtained from Exhibit
Exhibit marked-A (source: Swab from blood
stained FARSA) yielded highly degraded DNA.
3. The degraded DNA extracted from the Exhibit
marked-A (source: Swab ... amelogenin gender locus
using Amp FISTR Identifiler Kit.
4. The degraded DNA extracted from the Exhibit
marked-A (source: Swab from blood stained Farsa
noted as under:
"(a) Technical Errors
Firstly, the DNA-probe can be contaminated or
degraded. This is specially the case with field samples ... DNA. The degradation is especially likely when the
DNA is in warm, moist conditions. Normally, DNA
degrades in a couple of days and vaginal swabs
matches completely with the
DNA profile obtained from Exhibit-10(blood sample of
deceased Lekh Raj)
(ii) The partial DNA profile obtained from Exhibit ... spot) and Exhibit-5 (Hammer
produced by accused) yielded highly degraded DNA
from which no DNA profile could be generated.
::: Downloaded on - 15/04/2017
degradation or inhibition. Hence, it can be held that on
the said axe, blood was detected but due to degradation, DNA could not be generated ... colly) stands proved. As per the said report, DNA profile could not be
generated due to degradation of the sample. Role of the scientific evidence
Tissue
Sample II and Exhibit J: Tissue Sample VI
were selected for DNA Profiling Exhibit D: Long
Bone, Exhibit E: Tisue Sample I, Exhibit ... subjected for
DNA isolation by organic extraction method,
High Molecular Weight DNA could be isolated
from Exhibits A, B & C while degraded DNA
Vivek Sahajpal, Assistant Director
(DNA), SFSL, Junga, who opined in his report qua DNA profiling as
under:
"1. The DNA profile obtained from Exhibit ... Chand) and
this DNA profile matches completely with
the DNA profile obtained from Exhibit-9
(blood sample, Krishan Chand).
4. Identical DNA profile was obtained
Bahadur), from which one DNA
profile could be identified, and this DNA
profile matches completely with the DNA
profile obtained from Ext-16/A (pants ... that sample of
parcel 13 was highly putrefied and yielded highly degraded DNA
and did not show amplification, hence DNA profile could not be
.
generated
fact that DNA samples of the blood of accused-appellants Vikram Singh and Surender Singh did not tally with their own DNA samples of their ... frozen repeatedly since this will promote cell breakage and facilitate DNA degradation.
As regards the extra judicial confession, accused Vikram Singh along with accused Surinder