Mehta v.
State of Maharashtra7 has held that ECIR is an internal document of
the Enforcement Directorate, and unlike ... letter annexed to the summons stated that ECIR being an
internal document, cannot be shared with the Applicant. The
Applicant replied to this summons
stand taken by
the ED that ECIR is an internal document created by the
department before initiating penal action or prosecution
against the person involved ... proceeds of
crime). Non-supply of ECIR, which is essentially an
internal document of ED, cannot be cited as violation
of constitutional right. Concededly
stand taken by
the ED that ECIR is an internal document created by the
department before initiating penal action or prosecution
against the person involved ... proceeds of
crime). Non-supply of ECIR, which is essentially an
internal document of ED, cannot be cited as violation
of constitutional right. Concededly
cannot be urged that the ECIR
is an internal document. Therefore, in the absence of adherence to
26
the requirements ... does not register FIR
and keeps the ECIR as an internal document. All the above-
mentioned circumstances are said to render the questioning
being to coerce him into making false statements.
THE CONTENTIONS
20. The document in the nature of Enforcement Case Information
Report (ECIR) is concededly ... respondents, however, seek
to refer to it as "an internal document of Directorate of Enforcement
for proper identification of a particular case
obtain bail bond from the accused. Police cannot demand any property document from him. A station bail cannot be cancelled by the police. Cancellation ... personal liberty of the human being. The influence of this international document is found in the subsequent basic document of India viz., Constitution of India
Appeals Hon. Mario Carroza Espinosa.
As regards Ms. Verhoeven, described in the documents enclosed, a warrant of
arrest was issued against her on January ... detention period is grounded on the need
of taking into consideration Chilean internal procedures to subsequently
request the Government of the Republic of India
whether ECIR can be considered as the FIR and not an internal
document, this issue has been addressed and directly decided by the
Division Bench ... PMLA. The Division Bench categorically
observed that ECIR is an internal document of the Enforcement
Directorate, and unlike FIR, it is not a public document
knowledge is guaranteed by the Indian Constitution as well as the international documents to which India is a signatory. Those who rule this country ... harmony between various groups. Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute Pune, enjoys an international reputation as a research institute in the State of Maharashtra. It was unfortunate
Manmohan Singh Johal vs State on 19 August, 1968
Equivalent citations: AIR1969P&H225, 1969CRILJ932, AIR
