Page 10 of 51
C/SCA/1094/2018 JUDGMENT
processed on QCBS. That pursuant to the aforesaid tender notice,
the petitioner submitted tender ... submitted by Shri Nanavati, learned
advocate for the respective petitioners that adopting QCBS (Quality
and Costs Based Selection), by the respondent authority for the
contract
make the necessary selection of the successful bidder on the basis of QCBS
Method (Quality cum Cost Based Selection Method) where the weightage given ... respondent No.3 to be
the successful L-1 Bidder in the QCBS process of evaluation and the same was approved by
the concerned funding
tender was premised on the Quality-Cum-Cost Based
Selection (QCBS), assigning a maximum of 80 % marks to technical
assessment, and 20 % marks to financial ... procurement, like that of PSS, AIL chose Quality-cum-
Cost Based Selection (QCBS) which, according to AIL, is the most
appropriate and balanced process. Weightage
respondent No. 1.
2. The Managing Director, ATDCL issued notice inviting bid (QCBS) (E- procurement)
notice dated 29.1.2020 from reputed manufacturer/ authorized supplier for design ... Note- Bidder must submit authenticated information with supporting documents as above. QCBS
evaluation criteria. The assessment will be done on above basis.
Evaluation criteria
Quality and Cost
WP(C) NO. 27609 OF 2022 -10-
Based Selection (QCBS) method for projects greater than
Rupees Five Crores as per the Board ... iterated that the tender would be awarded to the bidder
with the QCBS method i.e., the "Score Pattern" which
was attached
Quality and Cost
WP(C) NO. 27609 OF 2022 -10-
Based Selection (QCBS) method for projects greater than
Rupees Five Crores as per the Board ... iterated that the tender would be awarded to the bidder
with the QCBS method i.e., the "Score Pattern" which
was attached
having been
made on the basis of Quality and Cost Based Selection (QCBS), which
system of evaluation was neither incorporated in the Standard Bidding
Documents ... such information through RTI.
5. The appellant came to learn that QCBS system was adopted for
assessing the respective bids of the parties by assigning
MSME clause from the tender document claiming it to be
contradictory to QCBS criteria, pursuant to which respondent Corporation
has amended the tender notification ... acquisition and processing of 500 LKM and 610 sq. km.
respectively under QCBS (quality and cost based selection); the Writ
Petitioner does not have locus
Selection would be on the basis of Quality cum Cost based
Selection (QCBS).
2.4.4 Quality cum Cost Based Selection (QCBS)
1. The evaluation methodology ... adopted by the Purchaser will be
Quality cum Cost Based System (QCBS) method of evaluation
where Technical Score (denoted by TS) will get a weightage
commercial bid. As per
the notification, quality and cost based system (QCBS) of evaluation is
introduced. The technical evaluation of the bidders will be decided ... QCBS
and thes fixed parameters in assessing the eligibility, performance, capability
for appointment of wholesale dealers for milk and milk products distribution
and sales. Each
