consider their decision of declaring the applicant as unfit due to
stammering and offer him the post of Assistant Loco Pilot.
2. The facts ... unfit in A1 & B1 medical
classifications due to presence of stammering. As a result, he became
unfit for the post opted
found unfit
in Aye-one, Bee-one medical tests due to stuttering / stammering.
In the communication, he was informed that if he is dissatisfied with ... speech. Despite this, the RRB
declared the applicant unfit, due to stammering which has resulted
in denial of the post of ALP, is violative
found that he was not able
to speak properly and he was stammering.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that stammering ... discharging the petitioner from service
only on the score that he was stammering.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents vehemently
1 of 3
::: Downloaded
such interview the private respondent spoke fluently
3
while the appellant stammered. Therefore, the authority were justified in
not giving appointment to the appellant ... person who stammers can be
appointed as a teacher. G.R. Case no. 248/2004 was pending during the
selection process in 2007 and this
aged twenty
two years. She could not write and she used to stammer slightly of
which her in-laws and husband were aware prior ... alleged that the deceased had informed him that since she used to
stammer slightly, the accused did not like her and used to taunt
deaf and dumb.
According to the defendant, Nokhu was having problem of
stammering and he was having sound disposing mind and was
well aware ... stated that Nokhu was not deaf and dumb, rather
he used to stammer. In his opinion, deafness and dumbness are
only physical incapacities, which never
above post, observing that he had a defective distant vision and
stammering. Being aggrieved of the same, the respondent requested for
a Review Medical Examination ... dated
23.01.2024, declared the respondent unfit but only on the ground of
stammering. Unsatisfied with the said report, the respondent got
himself examined
which mentions
"Speech should be without impediment i.e. no stammering" . He
then points out Clause 6(4) and 6(9). Clause ... impede efficient discharge
of training/duties. Clause 6(9) mentions "Stammering, as specified
later". Clause 7(f) deals with the 'Minor Acceptable
declared unfit on account of stammering. The writ petition has
been filed challenging the declaration of unfit on grounds of
stammering. The learned counsel ... Clause 20 of the Uniform Guidelines. Sub-
clause (g) contains "pronounced stammering" as one of the
grounds for rejection of candidature
State Medical Board. It seems that he suffered from a stammer, and on the 3rd July, 1954, he again appeared before the State Medical Board ... learned counsel --the physical defect from which the respondent suffered, namely a stammer, is not something which came into existence after he had entered into
