Overseers
Engineering Service, Irrigation Branch, Punjab, or
Irrigation Branch (Provincial Draftsman and Tracers) Service
or temporary engineers taken into the service..
(c) Officers directly appointed ... Engineering
Service of irrigation Branch, Punjab or Irrigation Branch
(Provincial Draftsmen and Tracers) Service of outstanding
merit, who may not possess the qualifications specified
respectively.
3 Promotion from members of the 2 1 - - 1 -
. Draftsman and Tracers Service.
CWP No. 9607 of 2010 3
4 Promotion from Members ... Branch) Overseers (Engineering) Service
and the Draftsmen members of the
Draftsmen and Tracers Service.
Possessing qualifications prescribed in
Appendix 'B'
Total
actually doing the work of duplicating the designs and also as a tracer in addition to his work as spray man. The Court further found ... appellant-mills was Rs. 740/-per month whereas that of the tracer was Rs. 850 and Rs. 620 per month depending upon the departments
Sh. Yog Raj S/O Sh. Chet Ram vs State on 19 July, 2022
Author
than in support of it. In this case the respondent was a tracer in the Engineering Department in the Ex-Hyderabad State on the scale ... there was no distinction in their scales of pay and all tracers were placed in the same scale. The respondent was a non-matriculate. Upon
course
is relaxed in terms of Rule 6(i) for appointment as
Tracer, there is no necessity for again having
relaxation for being considered ... already taken care of
when relaxation is given for appointment as Tracer.
Otherwise, a person who has been found eligible to be
appointed
services of
the petitioner by way of absorption on the post of
Tracer/Chainman. Accordingly, petitioner was absorbed and
re-engaged as Tracer ... fixation of the petitioner. After re-engagement on the post of
Tracer, pay of the petitioner was fixed in the pay-scale
electrical cable only transmits electrical energy from point to point, whereas heat tracer was not a carrier of electrical energy. It is a self-consumer ... conductors otherwise, a short circuit blow out may result. The heat tracer on the other hand has current flowing between the two conductors through
also relied on the Tribunal's decision in Thermon Heat Tracers Ltd. v. CCE, Pune [2001 (132) E.L.T. 455]. Referring ... valid defence against the bar of unjust enrichment.
5.3 In Thermon Heat Tracers case cited by ld. counsel, another 2-Member Bench of the Tribunal
Narsinga Rao , . the Government of Karnataka had prescribed two different scales for tracers - one for matriculate tracers with higher scale and another for non-matriculate ... tracers with lower pay scale. The non-matriculate tracers complained of discrimination. The said plea was negatived holding that prescribing two different scales for matriculates
