promotion and in the field of choice has to be considered for promotion. The fact of the imposition of the minor penalty of censure ... such person for promotion, as his fitness for the promotion has to be judged, in the case of promotion by seniority, on the basis
into consideration in the matter of promotion, the respondents cannot withhold promotion of an employee only on such censure(s).
In other words ... from being considered for promotion, it would impact the date from which he would be granted promotion, inasmuch as, the promotion would not take effect
into consideration in the matter of promotion, the respondents cannot withhold promotion of an employee only on such censure(s). Any other interpretation may also ... points at the rate of 2 per Censure but for the 5th Censure Respondents clarified that the Censure was awarded consequent to a major punishment
holding Departmental Promotion Committee for admission of names to promotion lists:-
The DPC should assess the suitability of the employees for promotion on the basis ... into consideration in the matter of promotion, the respondents cannot withhold promotion of an employee only on such censure(s). Any other interpretation may also
promotion as Professor w.e.f. 1.7.2007, but such promotion was denied to him for undisclosed reasons. Such promotion with effect from 1.7.2009 was again ... unfit for promotion. Although the Governing Body granted promotion to 39 faculty members who were found unfit for promotion by the Standing Selection Committee
have been
awarded the penalty of censure, is
postponed by one year. Since, penalty of
censure effects promotion by one year, it
effects grant ... earned a censure, the censure should not be
treated either as an impediment or obstruction for
consideration of his promotion but his case for such
sealed cover procedure was adopted. On
13.9.2001 the penalty of censure was awarded. Promotion
was granted to the respondent on 26.11.2001. However, he
claimed that ... High Court noted that awarding
of penalty of censure would not affect the promotion of the
respondent and the department was not right in contending
followed in imposing any penalty of withholding increment or promotion, censure, reduction in rank, compulsory retirement or dismissal in pursuance of departmental proceedings for indiscipline ... time being in force made under Section 18; (b) grant leave and promotion to such officers and servants; (c) dismiss or reduce in rank
promotion shall commence
only from the date of actual promotion and in no case, it may be
related, even notionally, to the date of promotion ... occasion to consider the question of impact of minor penalty of censure on promotion in its judgment in Union of India and others
currency of the censure.
(b) Censure awarded to an officer will be considered while deciding his suitability or otherwise for his promotion to the next ... ground to defer his promotion.
(d) For promotion to Air Ranks, No. 1 Promotion Board shall consider the award of censure while deciding the promotability
