English, containing 5 detonators.
11.During investigation, the exhibits were sent to CFSL for
expert opinion and chemical examination of the exhibits
confirmed the presence ... Sayed Maqbool are
concerned, the same are found to be sufficient to form
components of Improvised Explosive Devices. It is alleged
that the detonators recovered
delivered the same
at CFSL the same day. According to him he had
also taken alongwith him CFSL form bearing the
specimen seal and that ... CFSL.
22. I have perused relevant copies of the Malkhana
register and there is no mention about the deposit
of the CFSL form with Moharrar
C.B.I vs . Vinod Kumar Bhatnagar on 8 August, 2014
1
IN THE COURT
accused Ahmed Illahi. The pullandas were
sent to PS along with CFSL form which were given to the SHO
with a request ... CFSL
Chandigarh but the same could not be deposited and sample
pullanda was returned to him along with the CFSL form in intact
condition
Prem Chander who filled up form CFSL and returned his official
seal after putting same on CFSL form. He has also deposed about
taking ... samples were sent to CFSL, Chandigarh on 21.11.2003 and he
further stated that on 19.11.2003 the CFSL form was deposited
with
reached the office of the CFSL. In the instant
case, IO testified that he filled up CFSL form at the spot. However, none ... office of CFSL,
Chandigarh. There is not an iota of evidence to show as to where the CFSL
Form containing the specimen seal had remained
CFSL through
Constable Ravinder. Constable Ravinder (PW 4) also deposed
that on 09.02.1996 he had taken the sample parcel to CFSL
with CFSL Form ... page 13
-:12:-
CFSL Form to CFSL authority alongwith sample. Thus, it is not
established that CFSL Form was also sent alongwith the
sample
also sealed in pullanda
with the seal of GP and CFSL form was also filled and
sealed with seal of GP and seal after ... Ramlal. It is further case of prosecution that case
property, CFSL form, copy of recovery memo was
handed over to SHO who after putting
sending the sample to the CFSL
without any explanation renders the case of the prosecution doubtful.
Absence of CFSL Form
19 The Ld. defence counsel ... sample is not
tempered with till its analysis by the CFSL analyst. The CFSL form should
not only br prepared and sealed by the officer
State(Supra),
there was no evidence regarding preparation of the CFSL Form
or its deposit with FSL whereas in the case at hand ... Devi Vs State (Supra), the evidence regarding the
preparation of the CFSL Form with the seal impression at the
spot and its deposit with
