Oil And Natural Gas Corporation Ltd vs Planetcast Technologies Ltd on 5 April, 2021
vs.
Planetcast Technologies Ltd. OMP (Comm) No. 31/19
(RAJ KUMAR CHAUHAN)
District Judge (Commercial Court)
SE/Saket/ND/05.04.2021 Page 62 of 67
(NHAI) 2019 SCC Online SC 677", it was held that the Court
should not go into the merits of the case by re-accessing or re-
appreciating the evidence before the Learned Arbitral Tribunal.
The arguments raised by learned counsel for petitioner are having
a thrust for seeking re-appreciation of the evidence by this Court
notwithstanding that the Learned Arbitrator has dealt with each
aspects in detail by giving a well reasoned finding on this issue.
Admittedly, in view of the law referred above, the Court cannot
re-assess or re-appreciate the evidence which has been rightly
and cogently appreciated and considered by the Learned
Arbitrator while making this reasoned Award. Therefore, the
finding on this issue does not suffer from any patent illegality,
legal perversity so that it can be concluded that said finding is in
conflict with public policy of India.