Search Results Page
Search Results
1 - 10 of 28 (0.29 seconds)Sh. Mahipal Singh vs Presiding Officer, Industrial ... on 11 May, 2010
8. My ISSUEWISE findings are as under:
ISSUE No.1
Whether this court has no territorial jurisdiction to try this case?OPM
Vide order dated 07.03.2015 ld. counsel for management submitted that he is
not pressing contentions of the management regarding this Court not having territorial
jurisdiction to try this case and this Court may proceed with the assumption that this
Court is having territorial jurisdiction to try this case. Further it may also be noted that
in this case admittedly management is having its registered office at 12A, Shivaji
Marg, New Delhi and reference under section 10 (1) (C) and 12 (5) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 has been made by Dy. Labour Commissioner (West - District),
Labour Department, Govt. of NCT of Delhi to decide the industrial dispute as
mentioned in the first para of this award. Being guided by the case laws reported as
Raj Kumar Jaiswal Vs. Rangi International Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and Sh. Mahipal Singh
Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - III and Ors. (supra), undoubtedly, this
Court can be said to be having territorial jurisdiction to decide the reference in hand.
Issue is accordingly decided against the management.
Raj Kumar Jaiswal vs Rangi International Pvt. Ltd. on 27 October, 2009
8. My ISSUEWISE findings are as under:
ISSUE No.1
Whether this court has no territorial jurisdiction to try this case?OPM
Vide order dated 07.03.2015 ld. counsel for management submitted that he is
not pressing contentions of the management regarding this Court not having territorial
jurisdiction to try this case and this Court may proceed with the assumption that this
Court is having territorial jurisdiction to try this case. Further it may also be noted that
in this case admittedly management is having its registered office at 12A, Shivaji
Marg, New Delhi and reference under section 10 (1) (C) and 12 (5) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 has been made by Dy. Labour Commissioner (West - District),
Labour Department, Govt. of NCT of Delhi to decide the industrial dispute as
mentioned in the first para of this award. Being guided by the case laws reported as
Raj Kumar Jaiswal Vs. Rangi International Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and Sh. Mahipal Singh
Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - III and Ors. (supra), undoubtedly, this
Court can be said to be having territorial jurisdiction to decide the reference in hand.
Issue is accordingly decided against the management.
Section 25F in The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 [Entire Act]
Shri Chander Sain & Ors. vs M/S J.B. Garments on 17 April, 2009
Ld. counsel for management has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Angile Insulations Vs. Davy Ashmore India Ltd. and Another
(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 153; (ii) Rajasthan State Electricity Board Vs.
Page 10 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Universal Petrol Chemical Limited (2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 107; (iii) National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. and others Vs. M/s. Haribox Swalram and others AIR 2004
Supreme Court 1998; (iv) International Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air
Cargo Workers' Union & Anr. 2009 LLR 923; (v) Air India Limited Vs. Jagesh Dutt
Sharma & Ors. 2007 LLR 23; (vi) General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur Cotton
Mills, Rajnandgaon Vs. Bharat Lal & Anr. 2011 LLR 113; (vii) Chander Sain and
others Vs. J. B. Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (viii) Ram Singh and others Vs. Union
Territory, Chandigarh and others 2003 (99) FLR 1064; (ix) Anand Sawrup Data Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Ors. 1997 (2) Civil Court Cases 44 (P&H); (x) Cement
Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour CourtCumIndustrial
Tribunal, Hisar & Ors. 2010 LLR 704; (xi) New Delhi General Mazdoor Union &
Others Vs. Standing Conference of Public Enterprises and another 1991 LLR 516; (xii)
Charan Singh Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - Cum - Labour Court - II,
Gurgaon and Another 2014 LLR 747; (xiii) Chander Sain and others Vs. J. B.
Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (xiv) Sunil B. Waghela Vs. M/s. Juhu Vile Parle
Gymkhana Club and others 2002 LLR 1206; (xv) Bombay Hospital Trust and another
Vs. Dr. Shailesh Hathi and another 2006 LLR 992; (xvi) Ravindra Baburao Ambolkar
Vs. Gujarat Tea Canteen and another 1996 LLR 40; (xvii) Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei
School 2005 (3) SLR 643; (xviii) Ashok Leyland Ltd. Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu &
others 1992 (64) FLR 755 (xix) Nazir Ahmed Vs. A. Ramachandran and another 2000
(4) L. L. N. 948; (xx) Mahindra and Mahindra Vs. The Presiding Officer and another
2012 SCT (4) 345; (xxi) North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.
Nagangouda 2007 (1) L. L. N. 582; (xxii) Kendriya Vidyalaya Sanghathan and Anr. Vs.
S. C. Sharma 2005 LLR 275 and (xxiii) Municipal Council, Sujanpur Vs. Surinder
Page 11 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Kumar 2006 (3) L. L. N. 806.
Kanpur Electricity Supply Co. Ltd vs Shamim Mirza on 7 November, 2008
7. ARGUMENTS
I have heard Mr. Y. B. Singh, ARW and Mr. Jagbeer Singh Bhadana, Adv. for
management. Ld. AR for workman has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Gangadhar Bajpai and others Vs. Indian Oil Corporation and
others 2010 (124) FLR 316; (ii) Chet Ram Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal -
Cum - Labour Court - 1 and another 2010 (127) FLR 379; (iii) State Bank of Bikaner
& Jaipur Vs. Om Prakash Sharma 2006 (109) FLR 1203; (iv) Union of India and
another Vs. Major Bahadur Singh 2006 (108) FLR 146; (v) Assistant Engineer,
Rajasthan Vs. Ram Charan 2006 (109) FLR 1207; (vi) Triveni Sheet Glass Works Ltd.
Vs. State of U. P. and others 2006 (108) FLR 655 (vii) Bajaj Tempo Limited Vs.
Employees' State Insurance Corporation 2006 (110) FLR 461; (viii) Asish Dey
Chowdhury and others Vs. State of West Bengal and others 2014 (141) FLR 1101; (ix)
Bhogpur Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd. Vs. Harmesh Kumar 2006 (111) FLR 1202; (x)
Management of M/s. Hewlett Packard Global Soft Pvt. Ltd. Vs. K. L. J. A. Kiran Babu
2014 (142) FLR 757; (xi) Kanpur Electricity Supply Company Limited Vs. Shamim
Mirza (2009) 1 Supreme Court Cases 20; (xii) Raj Kumar Jaiswal Vs. Rangi
International Pvt. Ltd. MANU / DE / 2859 / 2009 (xiii) State of Punjab and others Vs.
Rafiq Masih (White Washer) 2014 (142) FLR 638; (xiv) Sh. Mahipal Singh Vs.
Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - III and Ors. MANU / DE / 1408 / 2010 and (xv)
Hira Lal Patni Vs. Sri Kali Nath A.I.R. 1962 Supreme Court 199.
Angile Insulations vs Davy Ashmore India Ltd. And Anr on 18 April, 1995
Ld. counsel for management has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Angile Insulations Vs. Davy Ashmore India Ltd. and Another
(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 153; (ii) Rajasthan State Electricity Board Vs.
Page 10 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Universal Petrol Chemical Limited (2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 107; (iii) National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. and others Vs. M/s. Haribox Swalram and others AIR 2004
Supreme Court 1998; (iv) International Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air
Cargo Workers' Union & Anr. 2009 LLR 923; (v) Air India Limited Vs. Jagesh Dutt
Sharma & Ors. 2007 LLR 23; (vi) General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur Cotton
Mills, Rajnandgaon Vs. Bharat Lal & Anr. 2011 LLR 113; (vii) Chander Sain and
others Vs. J. B. Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (viii) Ram Singh and others Vs. Union
Territory, Chandigarh and others 2003 (99) FLR 1064; (ix) Anand Sawrup Data Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Ors. 1997 (2) Civil Court Cases 44 (P&H); (x) Cement
Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour CourtCumIndustrial
Tribunal, Hisar & Ors. 2010 LLR 704; (xi) New Delhi General Mazdoor Union &
Others Vs. Standing Conference of Public Enterprises and another 1991 LLR 516; (xii)
Charan Singh Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - Cum - Labour Court - II,
Gurgaon and Another 2014 LLR 747; (xiii) Chander Sain and others Vs. J. B.
Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (xiv) Sunil B. Waghela Vs. M/s. Juhu Vile Parle
Gymkhana Club and others 2002 LLR 1206; (xv) Bombay Hospital Trust and another
Vs. Dr. Shailesh Hathi and another 2006 LLR 992; (xvi) Ravindra Baburao Ambolkar
Vs. Gujarat Tea Canteen and another 1996 LLR 40; (xvii) Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei
School 2005 (3) SLR 643; (xviii) Ashok Leyland Ltd. Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu &
others 1992 (64) FLR 755 (xix) Nazir Ahmed Vs. A. Ramachandran and another 2000
(4) L. L. N. 948; (xx) Mahindra and Mahindra Vs. The Presiding Officer and another
2012 SCT (4) 345; (xxi) North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.
Nagangouda 2007 (1) L. L. N. 582; (xxii) Kendriya Vidyalaya Sanghathan and Anr. Vs.
S. C. Sharma 2005 LLR 275 and (xxiii) Municipal Council, Sujanpur Vs. Surinder
Page 11 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Kumar 2006 (3) L. L. N. 806.
International Airport Authority Of ... vs International Air Cargo Workers' ... on 13 April, 2009
Ld. counsel for management has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Angile Insulations Vs. Davy Ashmore India Ltd. and Another
(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 153; (ii) Rajasthan State Electricity Board Vs.
Page 10 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Universal Petrol Chemical Limited (2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 107; (iii) National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. and others Vs. M/s. Haribox Swalram and others AIR 2004
Supreme Court 1998; (iv) International Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air
Cargo Workers' Union & Anr. 2009 LLR 923; (v) Air India Limited Vs. Jagesh Dutt
Sharma & Ors. 2007 LLR 23; (vi) General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur Cotton
Mills, Rajnandgaon Vs. Bharat Lal & Anr. 2011 LLR 113; (vii) Chander Sain and
others Vs. J. B. Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (viii) Ram Singh and others Vs. Union
Territory, Chandigarh and others 2003 (99) FLR 1064; (ix) Anand Sawrup Data Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Ors. 1997 (2) Civil Court Cases 44 (P&H); (x) Cement
Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour CourtCumIndustrial
Tribunal, Hisar & Ors. 2010 LLR 704; (xi) New Delhi General Mazdoor Union &
Others Vs. Standing Conference of Public Enterprises and another 1991 LLR 516; (xii)
Charan Singh Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - Cum - Labour Court - II,
Gurgaon and Another 2014 LLR 747; (xiii) Chander Sain and others Vs. J. B.
Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (xiv) Sunil B. Waghela Vs. M/s. Juhu Vile Parle
Gymkhana Club and others 2002 LLR 1206; (xv) Bombay Hospital Trust and another
Vs. Dr. Shailesh Hathi and another 2006 LLR 992; (xvi) Ravindra Baburao Ambolkar
Vs. Gujarat Tea Canteen and another 1996 LLR 40; (xvii) Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei
School 2005 (3) SLR 643; (xviii) Ashok Leyland Ltd. Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu &
others 1992 (64) FLR 755 (xix) Nazir Ahmed Vs. A. Ramachandran and another 2000
(4) L. L. N. 948; (xx) Mahindra and Mahindra Vs. The Presiding Officer and another
2012 SCT (4) 345; (xxi) North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.
Nagangouda 2007 (1) L. L. N. 582; (xxii) Kendriya Vidyalaya Sanghathan and Anr. Vs.
S. C. Sharma 2005 LLR 275 and (xxiii) Municipal Council, Sujanpur Vs. Surinder
Page 11 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Kumar 2006 (3) L. L. N. 806.
Air India Limited vs Jagesh Dutt Sharma And Ors. on 11 September, 2006
Ld. counsel for management has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Angile Insulations Vs. Davy Ashmore India Ltd. and Another
(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 153; (ii) Rajasthan State Electricity Board Vs.
Page 10 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Universal Petrol Chemical Limited (2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 107; (iii) National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. and others Vs. M/s. Haribox Swalram and others AIR 2004
Supreme Court 1998; (iv) International Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air
Cargo Workers' Union & Anr. 2009 LLR 923; (v) Air India Limited Vs. Jagesh Dutt
Sharma & Ors. 2007 LLR 23; (vi) General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur Cotton
Mills, Rajnandgaon Vs. Bharat Lal & Anr. 2011 LLR 113; (vii) Chander Sain and
others Vs. J. B. Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (viii) Ram Singh and others Vs. Union
Territory, Chandigarh and others 2003 (99) FLR 1064; (ix) Anand Sawrup Data Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Ors. 1997 (2) Civil Court Cases 44 (P&H); (x) Cement
Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour CourtCumIndustrial
Tribunal, Hisar & Ors. 2010 LLR 704; (xi) New Delhi General Mazdoor Union &
Others Vs. Standing Conference of Public Enterprises and another 1991 LLR 516; (xii)
Charan Singh Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - Cum - Labour Court - II,
Gurgaon and Another 2014 LLR 747; (xiii) Chander Sain and others Vs. J. B.
Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (xiv) Sunil B. Waghela Vs. M/s. Juhu Vile Parle
Gymkhana Club and others 2002 LLR 1206; (xv) Bombay Hospital Trust and another
Vs. Dr. Shailesh Hathi and another 2006 LLR 992; (xvi) Ravindra Baburao Ambolkar
Vs. Gujarat Tea Canteen and another 1996 LLR 40; (xvii) Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei
School 2005 (3) SLR 643; (xviii) Ashok Leyland Ltd. Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu &
others 1992 (64) FLR 755 (xix) Nazir Ahmed Vs. A. Ramachandran and another 2000
(4) L. L. N. 948; (xx) Mahindra and Mahindra Vs. The Presiding Officer and another
2012 SCT (4) 345; (xxi) North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.
Nagangouda 2007 (1) L. L. N. 582; (xxii) Kendriya Vidyalaya Sanghathan and Anr. Vs.
S. C. Sharma 2005 LLR 275 and (xxiii) Municipal Council, Sujanpur Vs. Surinder
Page 11 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Kumar 2006 (3) L. L. N. 806.
Cement Corporation Of India Ltd. vs Presiding Officer, Industrial ... on 21 March, 2001
Ld. counsel for management has filed written submissions and relied upon case
laws reported as (i) Angile Insulations Vs. Davy Ashmore India Ltd. and Another
(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 153; (ii) Rajasthan State Electricity Board Vs.
Page 10 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Universal Petrol Chemical Limited (2009) 3 Supreme Court Cases 107; (iii) National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. and others Vs. M/s. Haribox Swalram and others AIR 2004
Supreme Court 1998; (iv) International Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air
Cargo Workers' Union & Anr. 2009 LLR 923; (v) Air India Limited Vs. Jagesh Dutt
Sharma & Ors. 2007 LLR 23; (vi) General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur Cotton
Mills, Rajnandgaon Vs. Bharat Lal & Anr. 2011 LLR 113; (vii) Chander Sain and
others Vs. J. B. Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (viii) Ram Singh and others Vs. Union
Territory, Chandigarh and others 2003 (99) FLR 1064; (ix) Anand Sawrup Data Vs.
Punjab National Bank & Ors. 1997 (2) Civil Court Cases 44 (P&H); (x) Cement
Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Presiding Officer, Labour CourtCumIndustrial
Tribunal, Hisar & Ors. 2010 LLR 704; (xi) New Delhi General Mazdoor Union &
Others Vs. Standing Conference of Public Enterprises and another 1991 LLR 516; (xii)
Charan Singh Vs. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal - Cum - Labour Court - II,
Gurgaon and Another 2014 LLR 747; (xiii) Chander Sain and others Vs. J. B.
Garments 2009 (122) FLR 359; (xiv) Sunil B. Waghela Vs. M/s. Juhu Vile Parle
Gymkhana Club and others 2002 LLR 1206; (xv) Bombay Hospital Trust and another
Vs. Dr. Shailesh Hathi and another 2006 LLR 992; (xvi) Ravindra Baburao Ambolkar
Vs. Gujarat Tea Canteen and another 1996 LLR 40; (xvii) Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei
School 2005 (3) SLR 643; (xviii) Ashok Leyland Ltd. Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu &
others 1992 (64) FLR 755 (xix) Nazir Ahmed Vs. A. Ramachandran and another 2000
(4) L. L. N. 948; (xx) Mahindra and Mahindra Vs. The Presiding Officer and another
2012 SCT (4) 345; (xxi) North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.
Nagangouda 2007 (1) L. L. N. 582; (xxii) Kendriya Vidyalaya Sanghathan and Anr. Vs.
S. C. Sharma 2005 LLR 275 and (xxiii) Municipal Council, Sujanpur Vs. Surinder
Page 11 of 27 (ANAND SWAROOP AGGARWAL)
POLC XI/KKD/DELHI/30.04.2015
Radheyshyam Vs. M/s. Kenmore Vikas (India) Private Limited ID No. 357/10
Kumar 2006 (3) L. L. N. 806.