goods. After eliciting his explanation,
processing the matter further and obtaining the CVC advice,
ultimately the respondent was issued charge memo dated 10.5.2007
levelling ... petitioners had argued that there was no absolute bar
in the CVC‟s instructions from not holding disciplinary proceedings
on pseudonymous/innocuous complaints. In this
year 2001. The Chief Technical Examiner (CTE) of the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) had technically examined the works relating to the construction of building ... NHAI in the year 2000 and CVCs comments were sent to the Chief Vigilance Officer (CVO) of the NHAI as early as 19.02.2001. This
disciplinary authority thus proposed major penalty, which was rejected by CVC. However, based on the advice of CVC, the disciplinary authority communicated its decision ... been inflicted upon the applicant, despite a categorical finding not only by CVC but also the disciplinary authority on two occasions, only on the dictates
Shri R. N. Dwivedi vs Central Vigilance Commission (Cvc) on 2 March, 2009
CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION
Appeal No.CIC/WB/A/2008/01082 dated ... Section 19
Appellant - Shri R. N. Dwivedi,
Respondent - Central Vigilance Commission (CVC)
Facts:
By an application of 13.2.08 Shri R. N. Dwivedi, Ex-General Manager
applicant as on the basis of complaint made by a contractor to CVC, the department without seeking comments/approval of CVC straightway started the disciplinary ... complaint made by contractor ER Gurnam Singh Chadha was forwarded by CVC vide their letter dated 2.9.2004 for further necessary action, and that the Engineer
thrice and further
to declare fresh biddings is in contravention to the CVC guidelines
issued by Central Vigilance Commission on tendering process dated ... circular mandates the timely processing of tenders. It is
submitted that CVC feeling concerned about the delay in processing of
the tender has written
order of compulsory
retirement against the petitioner. Thereafter, an opinion of the CVC was sought
for by the disciplinary authority. The CVC however recommended ... punishment of dismissal. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
the CVC had no authority to suggest punishment and ultimately it was the
prerogative
memorandum dated 4th February,2009 issued by the Central
Vigilance Commission(CVC) a three member committee was
constituted by the PGCI to examine the issue ... having been forwarded to the Ministry of Power and the CVC, no
action is being taken. Accordingly, the petitioner was constrained to
file the writ
Officer (IO)s Report dated 3.12.2007 (Annexure-A2), 2nd stage advice of CVC dated 26.5.2008 (Annexure-A3), and the Notice dated 17.6.2008 (Annexure ... Officer (I.O.) vide DDA order dated 31.12.2007. The Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) was consulted on the IOs Report, who rendered 2nd stage advice
applicant the matter was referred to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) for its 2nd stage advice and on being tendered on 24.11.2006 the representation ... fully proved
7. The matter was referred to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) alongwith the above views of the DA, recommending that th case warrants
