grounds of detention--Validity of law--Construction of
Constitution --Reference to debates and Report of Draft-
ing Committee-Permissibility.
HEADNOTE:
The petitioner who was detained ... consideration at all or not, a
reference to the debates may be permitted. PATANJAYLI
SASTRI J.--In construing the provisions of an Act, speeches
made
Constitution of India
India
Constitution of India
CONTITUENTASSEMBLY 00 of 1950
Published in Gazette 00
members of
the Constituent Assembly while intervening in the debate in the Constituent
Assembly with regard to the kind of religious education to be given ... very
good fee too." (See Constitutional Assembly Debates Official Report.
Reprinted by Lok Sabha Secretariat)
It may be noted that at the time when
Chief Justice of
India. Shri Parasaran submitted that the Constituent Assembly Debates show that the plea
for primacy of Chief Justice of India ... securing the independence of the judges, and
throughout the Constituent Assembly debates the most vigorous emphasis
was laid on that principle... the framers
discussion in the Lok Sabha on July 20 1993 and the debate
continued till July 28, 1993. The motion was thereafter put
to vote ... whereby it was secured "that the freedom of
speech and debates or proceedings in Parliament ought not to
be impeached or questioned
Union Powers Committee dated July 5, 1947 (see vol. V, Constituent Assembly Debates, page 60). List I then consisted of 87 entries and there ... report of the Union Powers Committee, dated July 5, 1947 (Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. 5, page 58):
We think that residuary powers should remain with
ideals is a question with a wide spectrum
which needs an elaborate debate. Harking back to the
question involved in this case, the Framers ... system which
would enure for a long time to come. During the debates and
deliberations, the issues that seemed to crop up at every
point
Anglo-Indian group in Lok Sabha and state Legislative Assemblies is a debated topic. BJP-led government has scrapped it stating appropriate representation ... provided, reservations in legislature granted to them, etc are hot topics for debates. Also Refer ] 334A. Reservation of seats for women take effect. 1 Notwithstanding
constitution’s anti-defection provisions were a result of a series of debates over the issue. Also Refer
words of
prohibition. [46G; 49C-F]
(b) The Constituent Assembly debates show that the first
draft of the 3 lists was such that ... statement in the
report of the Union Powers Committee (Constituent Assembly
Debates) namely that the 'residuary subjects could only
relate to matters which, while
