E. T. Sunup vs C. A. N. S. S. Employees Assocn. & Anr on 13 October, 2004
Equivalent citations: AIR 2005 SUPREME COURT ... Mathur
CASE NO.:
Appeal (civil) 3157 of 1998
PETITIONER:
E. T. Sunup
RESPONDENT:
C. A. N. S. S. Employees Assocn. & Anr.
DATE OF JUDGMENT
Confederation Of All Nagaland State ... vs E.T. Sunup And Anr. on 26 May, 1998
Equivalent citations: 1998CRILJ3451
Author: H.K. Sema
Bench ... Petition No. 17(K)/96 in which the present contemner Shri E. T. Sunup, Financial Commissioner, Government of Nagaland, Kohima was arrayed as respondent
placed on the decision
of Hon'ble Apex Court in E.T.Sunup v. C.A.N.S.S. Employees
Association and another1 ... circumvent the orders and deny
the benefit. The judgments in E.T.Sunup's and Maninderjit
Singh Bitta's cases, on which much
only whether the breach was on account of willful
disobedience i.e, whether it was not casual or accidental and
unintentional. (V.C. Govindaswami Mudali ... undermining the
court order should not be countenanced. (Maninderjit Singh
Bitta1; E.T. Sunup v. C.A.N.S.S. Employees Assn. ).
Bearing these aspects
noticed this tendency of the officials in the case of E.T. Sunup v. C.A.N.S.S. Employees Association and another22. The relevant
Vinay Chandra
Mishra , Anil Ratan Sarkar v. Hirak Ghosh and E.T.Sunup
v. C.A.N.S.S.Employees Association , and quoted that even
repeatedly followed established rule of
law. In the case of E. T. Sunup v. C.A.N.S.S. Employees Association
With
reference to Government officers, this Court in the case of
E.T. Sunup v. Canss Employees Assoc.. [(2004) 8 SCC 683]
took the view
fatigued and
economically emasculated in pursuing protracted
litigation."
17. In E.T. Sunup vs. C.A.N.S.S. Employees
Association and another
reliance of a judgement of Supreme Court in the case of E.T. Sunup Vs. C.A.N.S.S. Employees Association and another reported ... decision of the Supreme Court in the case of E.T. Sunup (supra) is concerned, there is no dispute that if the Government Authorities circumvent
