member)
sitting en banc. That this Tribunal is therefore bound by judicial
discipline to adhere to the decision in the ATV case ... While the learned counsel
for the appellant principally placed reliance on the judicial precedents,
nevertheless, considering also the grounds raised in the appeal
position of law" is clearly against all settled
principles of judicial discipline and may even be contemptuous in
nature.
34. This observation made ... Supreme Court and the High Courts on the issue relating to judicial
discipline.
35. It would be pertinent to refer to the decision of Supreme
Assistant Commissioner to deny
the refund are contrary to judicial discipline. With
respect to refund for the 1st period, the Tribunal
had ordered for refund ... that the refund has been granted to
the appellant following the judicial discipline applying
the ratio of the judgment in CST vs. Flemingo Duty
also in
violation of principles of natural justice and principles of judicial
discipline and also of Master Circular dated 10.03.2017 issued by
CBIC ... earlier SCN, should have been dropped by following the judicial
discipline by the adjudicating authority.
8. We also find that as per the requirement
monetary limit before
following them in the name of judicial discipline.
In respect of an order where it is decided not to file
appeal ... Central
Excise Act but is also contrary to judicial discipline as the binding
effect of a decision of a Tribunal cannot be taken away
matter, I find that the principles and
tenets of judicial discipline require that the orders of the higher
appellate authorities should be followed unreservedly ... Tribunal and indeed he did to keeping in mind that judicial
discipline required him to do so.
10. The present appeals have been filed
tribunal or authority in any proceedings
subsequent thereto by way of judicial discipline,
the Supreme Court being the Apex Court of the
country. But, this ... this Court because permitting to do so would be
subversive of judicial discipline and an affront to the
order of this Court. However this would
consideration.
3.10 It is submitted that the rule of judicial discipline and propriety
by observing that the Doctrine of Precedents has a merit of promoting ... consistency in judicial decisions providing assurance to
individuals as to the consequences of their actions.
3.11 The principle of judicial discipline was explained
consideration.
3.10 It is submitted that the rule of judicial discipline and propriety
by observing that the Doctrine of Precedents has a merit of promoting ... consistency in judicial decisions providing assurance to
individuals as to the consequences of their actions.
3.11 The principle of judicial discipline was explained
consideration.
3.10 It is submitted that the rule of judicial discipline and propriety
by observing that the Doctrine of Precedents has a merit of promoting ... consistency in judicial decisions providing assurance to
individuals as to the consequences of their actions.
3.11 The principle of judicial discipline was explained
