M.L. Subbaraya Setty (Dead) By Lrs. And ... vs M.L. Nagappa Setty (Dead) By Lrs. And ... on 23 April, 2002
Equivalent citations: AIR2002SC2068
M.L. Subbaraya Setty v. M.L. Nagappa Setty 3 ,
wherein in paragraph No.28, it is held as follows:
28. The trial court ... laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.L. Subbaraya Setty and K.
Adivi Naidu (cited supra), where it was held that
Apex Court in the case of M.L.Subbaraya Setty and others Vs
M.L.Nagappa Setty and others reported ... contrary to law laid down in
the case of M.L.Subbaraya Setty and others Vs M.L.Nagappa
Setty and others reported
Prasad VS. CIT Bangalore , (1975) 1 Supreme Court 160
iv) M.L. Subbaraya Setty Vs. M.L. Nagappa Setty , (2002) 4 Supreme Court ... issued against the family."
26. In the case of M.L. Subbaraya Setty Vs. M.L. Nagappa Setty [supra (iv)] it
was held
M.N. Aryamurthy And Anr. vs M.D. Subbaraya Setty (Dead) Through L. ... on 20 September, 1971
Equivalent citations: AIR1972SC1279, (1972)4SCC1, 1972(4)UJ84 ... SUPREME COURT 1279, 1972 4 SCC 1
Bench: S.M. Sikri , D.G. Palekar , A.N. Ray
JUDGMENT
1. These are appeals by the plaintiffs
rights and interests
declared by the preliminary decree. In M.L Subbaraya Setty (dead) by Lrs.
and Ors. v. M.L. Nagappa, Setty (dead
reported in Abdulla Ahmed v. Animendra Kissen Mitter , M.N. Ayyamurthi v. M.L. Subbaraya Setty and Godhra Electricity Company Limited v. The State
Similarly
1120
the decision of this Court in M.N. Aryamurthi v. M.L.
Subbaraya Setty , AIR 1972 SC 1279 relating to coparcenary
property
family settlement or arrangement. The Apex Court in M.N. Arya Murti v. M.L. Subbaraya Setty, , had an occasion to examine what constituted
partitioned. He relied
on the case of M. N. Aryamurthi v. M. L.
Subbaraya Setty , AIR 1972 SC 1279, para 17
and further submitted that
