dying declaration of
the deceased. The recording of dying declaration started at
12:45 pm and completed on 1:00 pm. According to this dying ... Court held as under:-
"15. When there are multiple dying declarations, each
dying declaration has to be separately assessed and
evaluated and assessed independently
decided that if there are multiple dying declaration, the dying declaration becomes doubtful and such a dying declaration cannot be relied upon for the conviction ... down by the Apex Court that when there are multiple dying declaration, such dying declaration becomes doubtful but in all the law laid down
dying
declaration, held as under:-
"12. A dying declaration recording by a competent
Magistrate would stand on a much higher footing than the
declaration ... dying declaration, and in the earlier dying declaration, the
accused is not sought to be roped in but in the later dying
declaration, a summersault
question of an
inconsistent dying declaration but a dying
39
declaration which is completely opposed to the
dying declaration which is given earlier. There ... third dying
declaration which is relied on by the prosecution
is demolished by the earlier dying declaration or
dying declarations or is it the duty
that the dying
declaration being absolutely infirm, it cannot be placed reliance upon and
once the dying declaration is discarded, a serious dent is created ... dying
declaration is eminently vague is neither correct nor is it based on any
material on record. On the scanning of the dying declaration
Vasant Ganpat Padave(D) By Lrs. vs Anant Mahadev Sawant (Dead) Thru Lrs. . on 18
Mangalapuram Hospital. The injured died within half an hour. Whether in that condition deceased can give a dying declaration is a matter of guess ... investigating officer. So the names given were different in the second dying declaration. Multiple dying declarations allegedly made were not tallying. It is also stated
required. In case, there are multiple dying declarations and there are inconsistencies between them, generally, the dying declaration recorded by the higher officer like ... dying declaration in their statement. Third dying declaration was made before the Executive Magistrate (PW-9) Rakesh Kumar who had proved the dying declaration
medical report
of accused lend sufficient corroboration the dying declaration made
by the deceased. The dying declaration inspired confidence.
14
Cr.A. No. 534/2011 ... wherein it was held that when there are multiple dying
declarations, each dying declaration has to be
separately assessed and evaluated on its own merits
accused to attack a dying declaration in a case where the prosecution seeks to rely on a dying declaration against an accused ... situation where in the first dying declaration given to a police officer was more elaborate and the subsequent dying declaration recorded by the Judicial Magistrate
