travelling from Barka Kana to Anand Vihar Railway Station
with a valid reservation ticket in Jharkhand Express, that the train was
running late, and that ... passenger, the
record clearly shows that he was travelling on a valid reservation ticket
bearing PNR No. 6156876002 from Barka Kana to Anand Vihar Railway
petitioner had no eligibility
for claiming reservation under 2A Category as he has not
placed on record the valid Caste and Income Certificate ... terms of
Recruitment Notification, the applicant did not
possess necessary valid reservation certificate as on
the last date of receipt of application which would
issued by the Government of West Bengal
both dated July 2, 2025 valid for the year 2025-2026
declaring the income and asset certificates ... understand the reasoning as to
why a candidate, despite having a valid reservation
certificate, will not produce the same to get the benefit
of reservation
petitioner
was already in possession of reservation
certificate and there has been no change in
his reservation. Accordingly, the existing
certificate ought to have been ... petitioner can be treated as
unreserved category candidate despite
having a valid reservation certification in
his favour has to be decided.
6. The respondents
record.
2. The petitioner seeks benefit of reservation
under OBC category relying on the certificate of
reservation dated 6th December, 2025.
3. Prayer has been ... status at
such late stage. The petitioner did not have a valid
reservation certificate on the date of credential
verification.
7. In view
Level-8 through
restructuring and matching savings attracts the rule of reservation.
7.10 Learned counsel further submitted that in the cadre of Traffic Controller,
pursuant ... promotion arising out of cadre restructuring, and consequently, the
application of reservation is valid and in accordance with law.
REJOINDER
8. In rebuttal, learned counsel
Court & Ors) ruled that candidates for public
employment must possess valid reservation certificates (OBC-
NCL, EWS, etc.) by the application's last date
Ramashankar Yadav vs Western Railway on 6 April, 2026
1 OA No.105/2023 and
Ravindra Kumar Suthar vs Western Railway on 6 April, 2026
1 O.A. NO. 211
required candidates to
possess requisite certificates in the prescribed format for OBC reservation. Rule
25 stipulated that OBC status, including creamy layer determination would ... Rules, 2017, to contend
that candidates seeking reservation benefits must be in possession of requisite
and valid certificates in support of their claim
