principles
of natural justice. In S.K. Kapoor 's case as well as
S.N. Narula 's case, S.N. Narula v. Union ... down even before the said judgment of S.K. Kapoor
(supra) in the case of S.N.Narula (supra) and in fact the
subsequent order
Supreme Court in a
judgment reported in (2011) 4 SCC 591
( S.N.Narula Vs. Union of India and others ) in
paragraph ... Singh ) after
following the judgment reported in (2011) 4
SCC 591 ( S.N.Narula Vs. Union of India and
others ) in paragraph
also the view taken by this Court in the case of S.N.Narula
vs. Union of India & Others , Civil Appeal ... Patel 's case(supra),
the latter decision is a judgment per incuriam. The decision in
S.N.Narula 's case (supra) was binding
2024
HRIDAYANATH PANDEY ..... Petitioner
Through: Mr.H.S.Nagpal, Advocate
versus
M/S NARULA BAKERS S N FOOD PRODUCT..... Respondent
Through: Nemo
CORAM ... Delhi, in S&E/105/ND/2022, in the matter titled
as Hridayailath Pandey Vs. M/s Narula Bakers & S.N. Food
Products
reported in (2014) 7 SCC 340
after following the judgment in S.N.Narula Vs. Union
21/25
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ... held as follows:
“12....The said decision of
S.N.Narula case is an authority for the
proposition that the advice of UPSC, if
sought
justice. This is also the view taken by this Court in S.N.Narula
v. Union of India .
9. It may be noted that ... decision in
S.N.Narula case was prior to the decision in T.V.Patel case. It
is well settled that if a subsequent coordinate
that, even before
these decisions, the Supreme Court had held, in S N Narula v UOI7 ,
that the UPSC report had necessarily to be provided ... delinquent
employee. The decision in S N Narula is brief and may be
reproduced, in extenso, thus:
"1. Leave granted. The appellant was initially
decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court
in the case of S.N. Narula Vs. Union of India and Others ... find that Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
S.N. Narula (supra) has held in paras 6 & 7 as under
justice. This
is also the view taken by this Court in S.N. Narula v. Union of
India .
9. It may be noted that ... decision in S.N. Narula case was
prior to the decision in T.V. Patel case. It is well settled that if
a subsequent coordinate
submitted that Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of M/s Kusum Ingots and Alloys Ltd. vs. Union of India and another ... Union of India and ors. vs. S.K. Kapoor 19 and S.N. Narula vs. Union of India and ors.20
REJOINDER SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF
