hand
and SAIL on the other regarding the supply of the balance 753,461 MT.
SAIL's case was that there was a deliberate ... during the relevant period 2007-08. SAIL's case is that as a result it had
to procure the balance quantity from other sources
these propositions and as held by the Supreme Court in the SAIL case,
appeal would lie only against orders passed under Section ... Though the
Supreme Court in the SAIL case was not required to decide this issue, it gave an
opinion on Section 26 which is reproduced
that case are different
from facts of the present case. The case relied upon by the
assessee pertained to employees of SAIL wher ... happened in this case. The Assessing Officer
disregarded Hon'ble ju risdictional High Cou rt in the case of SAIL DSP
VR Employees
contract price on 3rd
February 2006. It is SAIL's case that after obtaining the PAC Respondent
personnel left the site and the country ... which was only till 13th
June 2005 did not help SAIL's case as far as the majority of the Tribunal
was concerned. That
conclusion that as there was no case of violation
of the Competition Act , the case needs to be closed without hearing ... Court in the case of SAIL Civil appeal no 7779
of 2010. Though the Supreme Court in the SAIL case wãs not required
Government as held by the Supreme Court in the judgment in SAIL case (cited supra).
60. In view of the above, the impugned Award suffers
specifically so laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SAIL
v National Union of Water Front Workers ... 8905 of 2012 -3-
situation in SAIL case is that a person, who cannot be continued in the
contract work by virtue of a provision
judgment
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court delivered in the case of SAIL Vrs. Awadhesh
Singh and another reported ... judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court delivered in the
case of SAIL Vrs. Awadhesh Singh and another(Supra) is complete answer
to the controversy
post of Senior Sales Officer. The
petitioners in the present case sail in the same boat as they are
sandwiched between Ms. Kanta Kapoor ... made on account of the fact that the situation in the present
case in one respect is different. Ms. Kanta Kapoor being the junior
most
JUDGMENT: "u t
Case sailed. twice. Neither '4i'£1<:*"'a1ppe11:aj:.fi' fiifar V
Coungei for the appeflami
