parent Act.
Learned Senior Counsel contended that the judgment in SAIL
case was in the context of the mineral, Dolomite, and the ratio ... royalty differs from mineral to mineral
and therefore, the decision in SAIL case is not applicable to
the present case where we are concerned with
been give effect to and it has become final."
In SAIL case, Hon'ble Supreme Court held that consequent to
the abolition ... provide for automatic absorption of contract
labour. The direction in SAIL case may be applicable, had
9
there been no settlement between the management
award. It has further been contended that even in the SAIL case
reported in (2001) 7 SCC pg.1 it was held that there cannot ... case reported in (1992)
1 SCC pg 695 (Dinanath case) which has been reiterated by the
3
Hon'ble Supreme Court in SAIL(Supra
impact of the ratio of the Constitution Bench judgment in SAIL case on the unimplemented impugned award and the ratio of the Constitution Bench judgment ... background of these developments I haveto interpret the ratio of the SAIL case reported in (2001) 7 SCC 1. In paragraph 125 of this judgment
said case that the same is not applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case, the point in issue of the aforesaid case before ... before this Court in the present case are quite different and distinct.
14. In the case of SAIL and Anr. v. Awadhesh Singh
Agriculture & Technology case, UT
Chandigarh, Admn. v. Manju Mathur, SAIL case and
National Aluminium Co. Ltd. case).
42.2. The mere fact that the subject
good law by laying down the ratio in the case of
SAIL at paragraph-125 and 126 which reads hereunder as:-
"125. The upshot ... hereunder [para 125 (5) of the judgment
rendered in the case of SAIL].
It further laid down the proposition at paragraph-126 that the
aforementioned
referred to it by the order of
Reference."
In the case of SAIL Vs. Union of India and Others [2006 (9) Scale ... hearing on the basis of the principle laid down in the SAIL case which
is to be decided by the Industrial Adjudicator in view
Bench of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court reported in the case of SAIL & Ors. (Supra)
to lift the veil to find ... paras 125 & 126 of the judgment rendered in the case of SAIL
(Supra). The nature of job admittedly was in the prohibited
category
Bench of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court reported in the case of SAIL & Ors. (Supra)
to lift the veil to find ... paras 125 & 126 of the judgment rendered in the case of SAIL
(Supra). The nature of job admittedly was in the prohibited
category
