Satyam Computers Services Ltd vs The Additional Commissioner Of ... on 21 September, 2012
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao , B.Manohar
1
IN THE HIGH COURT ... JUSTICE B.MANOHAR
STA No.1/2011 (Tax)
BETWEEN :
SATYAM COMPUTERS
SERVICES LTD
SSL BUILDING,
PLOT # 22 TO 25 &
27 TO 34, HI-TECH
Satyam Computer Services Ltd vs The Deputy Commissioner on 3 April, 2008
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
IN THE HIGH COURT
Infotech Ltd.,
Foursoft Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., Geometric
Software Solutions Company Ltd., Tata Elxsi Ltd.,
Visual Soft Technologies Ltd., Flextronics Ltd.,
Satyam Computers Services Limited ... companies which assessee is seeking
exclusion, Bodhtree Consulting Ltd, Geometric
Software Solutions Co. Ltd, Satyam Computer
Services Ltd, and Infosys Technlogies Ltd, were
in assessee
Infotech Ltd.,
Foursoft Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., Geometric
Software Solutions Company Ltd., Tata Elxsi Ltd.,
Visual Soft Technologies Ltd., Flextronics Ltd.,
Satyam Computers Services Limited ... companies which assessee is seeking
exclusion, Bodhtree Consulting Ltd, Geometric
Software Solutions Co. Ltd, Satyam Computer
Services Ltd, and Infosys Technlogies Ltd, were
in assessee
Infotech Ltd.,
Foursoft Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., Geometric
Software Solutions Company Ltd., Tata Elxsi Ltd.,
Visual Soft Technologies Ltd., Flextronics Ltd.,
Satyam Computers Services Limited ... companies which assessee is seeking
exclusion, Bodhtree Consulting Ltd, Geometric
Software Solutions Co. Ltd, Satyam Computer
Services Ltd, and Infosys Technlogies Ltd, were
in assessee
finding?
(5) Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding
that Satyam Computer Services Ltd cannot be
considered as comparable only on the ground that
financial ... cannot be regarded as a comparable.
24. As far as Satyam Computer Services Ltd.,
is concerned, we have already held while regarding
this company
Ltd., Four Soft Ltd., Thirdware Solution
Ltd., Geometric Software Solutions Company Ltd.,
Tata Elxsi Ltd., Visualsoft Technologies Ltd.,
Flextronics Software Ltd., Satyam Computer
Services Ltd ... Software Solutions Co. Ltd., Four Soft
Limited, Tata Elxsi Ltd., [Seg.], Infosys
Technologies Ltd., Flextronics Software Systems
Ltd., Satyam Computer Services, Thirdware
Solutions Ltd
Ltd., Four Soft Ltd., Thirdware Solution
Ltd., Geometric Software Solutions Company Ltd.,
Tata Elxsi Ltd., Visualsoft Technologies Ltd.,
Flextronics Software Ltd., Satyam Computer
Services Ltd ... Software Solutions Co. Ltd., Four Soft
Limited, Tata Elxsi Ltd., [Seg.], Infosys
Technologies Ltd., Flextronics Software Systems
Ltd., Satyam Computer Services, Thirdware
Solutions Ltd
High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad while
deciding M/S SATYAM COMPUTER SERVICES LTD., vs.
DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT, (W.P.No.37487/2012 and
connected
Technologies Ltd., Exensys Software Solutions
Ltd., Thirdware Solutions Ltd., Wipro BPO
Solutions Ltd., Tata Elxsi Ltd., Flextronics
Software Systems Ltd., Satyam Computer
Services Ltd
