while entrusting the
investigation of the case relating to the
killing of Sohrabuddin and Kausarbi to
CBI, this Court, by order dated ... have been killed because he
was an eyewitness to the killings of
Sohrabuddin and Kausarbi.
46. CBI also filed
investigation has
revea led that subsequent to the murder of Hamid Lala,
Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram Prajapati continued their criminal
activities in the States of Maharashtra ... Rajasthan and Gujarat.
However, Sohrabuddin remained elusive and beyond the reach of
the Gujarat Police. It was, therefore, that the accused Amit Shah
(petitioner herein
issued from time to time, in a
petition filed by brother of Sohrabuddin, the Investigation Agency found
that death of Sohrabuddin and subsequently reported death ... appellant-Dinesh, whose bail
was cancelled had surfaced as the wanted accused-Sohrabuddin was
involved in an offence registered in police station under his jurisdiction
issued from time to time, in a
petition filed by brother of Sohrabuddin, the Investigation Agency found
that death of Sohrabuddin and subsequently reported death ... appellant-Dinesh, whose bail
was cancelled had surfaced as the wanted accused-Sohrabuddin was
involved in an offence registered in police station under his jurisdiction
occurrences, inasmuch as
one being the conspiracy relating to the
murder of Sohrabuddin with the help of
Tulsiram Prajapati and the other being the
conspiracy ... murder Tulsiram Prajapati -- a
potential witness to the earlier conspiracy to
murder Sohrabuddin. We are unable to accept
the claim of the learned
encounter is a part of the same chain of
events in which Sohrabuddin and Kausarbi were killed and
directed CBI to "take ... hand, initially CBI took a
stand that the third person accompanying Sohrabuddin and
Kausarbi was Kalimuddin. However, with the aid of further
investigation, it unveiled
encounter is a part of the same chain of
events in which Sohrabuddin and Kausarbi were killed and
directed CBI to "take ... hand, initially CBI took a
stand that the third person accompanying Sohrabuddin and
Kausarbi was Kalimuddin. However, with the aid of further
investigation, it unveiled
encounter is a part of the same chain of
events in which Sohrabuddin and Kausarbi were killed and
directed CBI to "take ... hand, initially CBI took a
stand that the third person accompanying Sohrabuddin and
Kausarbi was Kalimuddin. However, with the aid of further
investigation, it unveiled
trial Court seems to
have been swayed by the fact that Sohrabuddin, husband
of Kausarbi had shady reputation and criminal
antecedents. That was not certainly
regard to the murder of the witness of the first encounter of Sohrabuddin, which was committed after a gap of one year. The Apex Court
