Mines-Law Providing for respecting for coal and ac-
quisition-Validity-"Unworked land", meaning of-"To undertake
any operation in the land ... preamble, for
providing for the acquisition by the State of unworked land
containing or likely to contain coal deposits, and under
coal remained workable;
Clause (7). In the event of any coal remaining unworked for any reason whatever (otherwise than as provided in clause ... method was unsound and dangerous as it would render Hathnol unworkable; the Company was depillaring the area in spite of protests and the only
case like the present, where the minerals have been found to be unworked, and, consequently, not in the actual possession ... sort of possession that can be inferred, in the case of completely unworked minerals, from the title is nothing but constructive possession. In the case
reduced the rate to +28.88% above the
estimate rate which was unworkable, caused the
Corporation to sustain loss of an amount ... rate to +28.88% above estimate on 1996 schedule of
rates which was unworkable."
.SP 2
38. The statement of allegations in support of
these
been worked continuously since 1947 and it is not a dormant or unworked mine or land justifying acquisition of it or any portion ... purpose of prospecting and they are legally within their rights to notify unworked areas under the Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development
BEING UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND
UNWORKABLE AND ETC.
IN W.P. NO.226141/2020
BETWEEN:
1. VEERAREDDY
S/O SIDRAM REDDY PATIL,
AGE: 28 YEARS ... BEING UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND
UNWORKABLE AND ETC.
IN W.P. NO.226146/2020
BETWEEN:
1. BHEEMARAYA
S/O BASAPPA GUDDAD,
AGE: 55 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE/PRESIDENT
effect that the scheme has not become unworkable, but it is the new management itself which has deliberately tried to create a situation which would ... show that it is unworkable, I must reject that contention of Mr. Laud also." The learned judge thus clearly refers to his findings
order to prevent a
provision from being unintelligible absurd unreasonable
unworkable or totally irreconcilable with the rest of the
statute. [11OA]
R. v. Dakees ... order to prevent a provision from beingunintelligible,
absurd, unreasonable, unworkable or total irreconcilable
with the rest of the statute. This rule of literal
construction
mining lease. Hence it is proposed
to take power to acquire unworked coal bearing areas covered
by private leases or prospecting licencees which are found ... take powers by fresh legislation to acquire the
lessees" rights over unworked coal-bearing areas on payment
of reasonable compensation to the lessees
Beedis which can be rejected, validity
of-- Sec. 37(3) if unworkable.
Interpretation--Reports of Commissions and
Committees--Admissibility in evidence about the prevailing
system ... made provision for
maternity benefits to women employed in an establishment
was. unworkable.
HELD : (Per Ray, C.J., Khanna, Mathew, and Bhagwati, JJ) :
Parliament
