Judge in respect of Annexure
P/1 order, effecting an inter-zonal transfer between two different Railway
establishments is sought to be challenged in this ... superior officer from one
zonal railway to another zonal railway or from Railway
6
Protection Special Force to a zonal railway or vice versa
inter zonal transfer; (v) the transfer of the petitioners in both the petitions, from
RPSF to RPF, was also an inter zonal transfer ... both the petitions, when sought transfer and were granted
transfer, not only from RPSF to RPF but also inter zonal, that their seniority
was fixed
therein that transfer on request or voluntary transfer cannot result in reduction of rank of enrolled member of the Force. All transferred Head Constables ... zonal transfer. Rule 99.2, however, governs determination of seniority on transfer on own request or mutual exchange which reads as under:-
"99.2. Transfer
various grounds, stating
that there is no reason assigned for a zonal transfer and that the order is
being passed by way of punishment ... part of the
respondent to assign the reason for making any zonal transfer. It is not in
dispute that the respondent possesses the authority
staffs who opted for Zonal Headquarters and they would be considered for
posting against Zonal level posts on transfer to the zonal cadre ... transfer without any reason. It is further averred that the applicant was a
permanent constituent of the Claims office, which was transferred to the zonal
Scale IV. On 2
September 2011, the respondent was transferred to the Zonal Office at Mumbai.
On 7 October 2011, she was transferred ... order of transfer dated 14 December 2017 had proposed the transfer of the
respondent from Indore to a branch falling under the Zonal Office
impugned transfer order, is, constituted in the trite factum, that care giving
at Civil Hospital Suni, wherefrom, the writ petitioner is transferred, to Zonal
Hospital ... Hospital,
Suni, would become direly affected, upon, the writ petitioner becoming
transferred to Zonal Hospital, Mandi, especially when thereat the seat of
the Radiologist, would
transferred to Zonal Office. Zonal Office
in turn shall keep the amount in a Non-Operative Account
and consolidate the same and transfer to Head ... option after expiry of time for
such exercise would be transferred to the Zonal Office and after
consolidation, transferred to the Head Office for crediting
petitioner, he has
been served with Ext P7 order, transferring and posting
him at the zonal office of the Corporation in Chennai.
4. Immediately ... Tourism
cadre. Facts being so, the petitioner was transferred to
the zonal office only on administrative exigencies.
Moreover, even though the presence of E5 level
them; (v) that the petitioners
represented for inter-zonal/inter-divisional transfer, on working couple
ground, and their inter-zonal/inter-divisional transfers were approved ... duties at the place of their
posting on such inter-zonal/inter-divisional transfers; and, (vi) that suddenly,
without any reason or cause, the respondents
