Eastern Coalfields Ltd vs Swadhin Kumar Banerjee & Ors on 29 July, 2013
On the other hand, Mr. Tarakeshwar Pal, learned
Advocate appearing for the opposite parties, has
vehemently opposed the submission made by the learned
Advocate for the petitioner and he has relied on the
decisions of Jasbir Singh v. Punjab & Sind Bank & ors.
reported in 2007(1) CLJ(SC) 151, Bachan Singh v. Union of
India & ors. reported in 2008(5) Supreme 101 particularly
paragraph no.14, Smt. Nipa Dhar (Nee Ghosh) v. National
Aviation Company of India Ltd. & ors. reported in (2011)2
WBLR(Cal) 793 and Shalimar Paints Ltd. v. First
Industrial Tribunal reported in 2012(5) CHN(Cal) 160 and
thus, he has submitted that since there is no direct
evidence against the respondent no.1, the learned
Tribunal has rightly concluded.