than 3
years then what is the reason they have not
been transferred- political, official or facility
charges? Information to be provided with
full detail ... This is a personal matter and not related to the Zonal
transferring an employee who has served for office.
more than 3 years? Full detail
observed that the matter is not pertaining to Zonal Office-Delhi. Zonal Office-Delhi has not
conducted any enquiry as referred in your application ... Respondent: Mr. Shiv Kumar, CPIO & DGM;
The RTI application was transferred to Zonal Office Hubli and PAD Head Office on 08/07/2011.
Both
cannot plead that the CPIO should have
transferred the same to the concerned Zonal unit. However, despite this, the
CPIO should have transferred his application ... However, the FAA directed
the CPIO to transfer the application to Zonal Units to provide the information
within 10 days. In compliance with the directions
reply to the RTI application had not transferred
the RTI application to the Zonal offices for information against points 1 to 5 and that ... later
she had a change of mind and had transferred the application to these Zonal offices . Had she
(Appellate Authority) taken the decision to transfer
Commission noted that Railway Board
has only transferred points a, b, and i to the zonal railways and that they are silent in respect ... information against points a, b and i which have been transferred to the Zonal
railways has been provided to the Appellant by the PIOs
Zonal Railways and the application has already been transferred to the PIOs of Zonal Railways
requesting them to furnish replies directly to the Appellant ... received any information from
any Zonal office although the RTI application was transferred to them. The Respondent PIO is
therefore directed to transfer
have been transferred to Eastern and Northern Railways for response.
Similarly query at item no. 3 had been transferred to Zonal Railway for response ... queries at item nos. 8 to 11 be directed to be transferred to the concerned PIOs.
The Appellate Authority decided this appeal vide his order
them to take a policy decision and that it was then transferred to Zonal Railways
and that the information was supplied after collecting the same
Statistics and
Programme Implementation, Kolkata to obtain information
pertaining to his transfers.
2. Vide CPIO order dated 23 February 2010 and 2 March 2010,
point ... person. Appellant sought to have
all file notings regarding his transfer at Zonal Office ( EZ)
Appeal: No. CIC/DS/A/2011/002398/C
level. CPIO
also stated that points 5 and 6 have been transferred to Zonal Railways with the direction to send
the information directly to the Appellant vide ... that CIC's
notice for hearing was also transferred to the concerned PIOs. (16 Zonal Railways).
3. During the hearing it was noted that
