Union Of India & Ors vs Gyan Chand Chattar on 28 May, 2009
Equivalent citations: AIRONLINE 2009 SC 561
Author: B.S. Chauhan
Bench ... Union of India & Ors. .... Appellants
Versus
Gyan Chand Chattar .... Respondent
JUDGMENT
Dr. B.S. Chauhan, J.
1. This appeal has been preferred against
Union Of India (Uoi) vs Gyan Chand Chattar on 1 May, 2002
JUDGMENT
J.N. Bhatt, J.
1. By this Letters Patent Appeal invoking Clause
RAJASTHAN AND
OTHERS (supra)
ii) UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS VS. GYAN
CHAND CHATTAR (supra)
iii) S. BHASKAR REDDY AND ANOTHER VS.
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE ... disciplinary proceedings cannot be allowed to
stand.
15. In GYAN CHAND CHATTAR (supra), the
Honb'le Apex Court was considering a departmental
proceedings wherein
following the judgment of
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v/s GYAN CHAND
CHATTAR reported in (2009) 12 SCC 78 opined that
a lenient view ... that lenient view is to be
taken, following the judgment in GYAN CHAND
CHATTAR (supra) and also observing that the
applicant being a Lady having
Learned counsel for the petitioner placed
reliance on the case of GYAN CHAND CHATTAR
(supra) to contend that where allegation of demanding
and accepting bribe ... Apex Court in
paragraph 21 of GYAN CHAND CHATTAR (supra) are
not ratio decidendi of the case and those observations
were made while discussing
that lenient view is to be taken, following
the judgment in GYAN CHAND CHATTAR (supra) and
also observing that the applicant being a Lady having ... service, she would put
to great hardship and inconvenience. In GYAN CHAND
CHATTAR case, the Hon'ble Apex Court at paragraph 21
held that
Gyan Chand Chattar vs K.K. Agrawal & 2....Opponent(S) on 19 March, 2014
Author: M.R. Shah
Bench: M.R. Shah ... SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 101 of 1982
======================================
GYAN CHAND CHATTAR....Applicant(s)
Versus
K.K. AGRAWAL & 2....Opponent(s)
======================================
Appearance:
(MR DIPAK C RAVAL
Gyan Chand Chattar vs K.K. Agrawal on 29 October, 2002
Author: J.M.Panchal
Bench: J.M.Panchal
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT ... SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No. 101 of 1982
--------------------------------------------------------------
GYAN CHAND CHATTAR
Versus
K.K. AGRAWAL
--------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
1. Misc.Civil Application
Gyan Chand Chattar vs K.K. Agrawal on 27 August, 2002
Author: J.M.Panchal
Bench: J.M.Panchal
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT ... SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION No 101 of 1982
--------------------------------------------------------------
GYAN CHAND CHATTAR
Versus
K.K. AGRAWAL
--------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
1. Misc.Civil Application
Dilip Kumar Sahu vs The State Jharkhand on 8 January, 2025
Author: Sujit Narayan Prasad
